May 10, 2009

Data, Not Design, Is King in the Age of Google
By MIGUEL HELFT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/10/business/10ping.html?ref=technology&pagewanted=print


CAN a company blunt its innovation edge if it listens to its customers 
too closely? Can its products become dull if they are tailored to match 
exactly what users say they want? These questions surfaced recently when 
Douglas Bowman, a top visual designer, left Google.

In a rare display of independence among otherwise tight-lipped current 
and former Googlers, Mr. Bowman laid out on his blog the reasons for his 
abrupt exit, creating a bit of a commotion in the technology 
blogosphere. There was no sugarcoating. Mr. Bowman essentially said that 
Google was not friendly to designers.

Mr. Bowman’s main complaint is that in Google’s engineering-driven 
culture, data trumps everything else. When he would come up with a 
design decision, no matter how minute, he was asked to back it up with 
data. Before he could decide whether a line on a Web page should be 
three, four or five pixels wide, for example, he had to put up test 
versions of all three pages on the Web. Different groups of users would 
see different versions, and their clicking behavior, or the amount of 
time they spent on a page, would help pick a winner.

“Data eventually becomes a crutch for every decision, paralyzing the 
company and preventing it from making any daring design decisions,” Mr. 
Bowman wrote.

Google is unapologetic about its approach.

“We let the math and the data govern how things look and feel,” Marissa 
Mayer, the company’s vice president of search products and user 
experience, said in a recent television interview.

The Web, of course, offers designers and innovators an unprecedented and 
powerful mechanism to test their ideas. They can mock something up, 
throw it up online, and get immediate feedback from users. Better yet, 
they can mock up multiple designs and test them quickly. Then, they can 
repeat the process until they home in on the design that seems to be 
most popular.

The approach may be the ultimate experiment in crowd-sourcing — letting 
users collectively design products. But experts in design and innovation 
say the approach has limitations and downsides.

“Getting virtually real-time feedback from users is incredibly 
powerful,” said Debra Dunn, an associate professor at the Stanford 
Institute of Design. “But the feedback is not very rich in terms of the 
flavor, the texture and the nuance, which I think is a legitimate gripe 
among many designers.”

Adhering too rigidly to a design philosophy guided by “Web analytics,” 
Ms. Dunn said, “makes it very difficult to take bold leaps.”

And as much as it may sound jarring, the customer is not always right.

“Customers sometimes do not know what they want,” said John Seely Brown, 
the co-chairman of the Deloitte Center for Edge Innovation, a research 
and consulting organization based in Silicon Valley. “It can be 
dangerous to just listen to what users say they need.”

None of this means that input from users is unimportant. Indeed, Ms. 
Dunn, Mr. Brown and others say designers must find a multitude of ways 
to understand users’ needs at a deeper level.

“It is more from engaging with users, watching what they do, 
understanding their pain points, that you get big leaps in design,” Ms. 
Dunn said.

That approach informed a redesign at Cooliris, a start-up whose software 
offers a way to view pictures and videos on a three-dimensional virtual 
wall of thumbnail images. In the new version, which Ms. Dunn helped 
design, the company includes headlines and other text next to images.

“Even though it changes the visual impact, it is critical that people 
have access to that information as they are scanning the wall,” Ms. Dunn 
said. “Now that it is out there, we can do the kind of micro-testing 
that Google talks about. But the broad design decision was not made that 
way.”

It is hard to criticize the results of Google’s data-centric approach. 
The company is hugely successful. If a certain hue of blue causes users 
to click on ads at even a marginally higher rate, it can translate into 
millions of dollars flowing to the company’s bottom line.

What’s more, many of Google’s products are utilitarian. They are meant 
to help people complete tasks quickly — not to dazzle them the way, say, 
an iPhone dazzles users.

Even Mr. Bowman insists he never meant to slam Google. “Google’s 
approach works really well for Google,” he said.

BUT Mr. Bowman has found a place that better suits his sensibilities. He 
is now the creative director at Twitter, where he says he has a greater 
opportunity to shape the look and feel of the service. Already his team 
has unveiled a major design overhaul. On the margin of users’ pages they 
added a search box and a list of “trending topics,” subjects that are 
most popular with tweeters at a given time.

He has also found a new way to listen to customers: reading their tweets 
in reaction to the new design features.

“Using data is fundamental to what we do,” Mr. Bowman said. “But we take 
all that with a grain of salt. Anytime you make design changes, the most 
vocal people are the ones who dislike what you’ve done. We don’t just 
throw the numbers in a spreadsheet.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to