May 11, 2009 Cable's vanishing act Some Comcast customers without a converter box are losing favorite channels
By AARON NATHANS The Wilmington [DE] News Journal http://www.delawareonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090511/BUSINESS/905110317&template=printart Barbara Foreman of Wilmington said she took Comcast's ads at face value when they said to "sit back, relax and keep watching your favorite shows." Because she's connected to the cable television provider, she figured she didn't need to take any steps to be ready for the digital television transition. But in the last few weeks, some of her favorite shows have disappeared. Foreman, who buys Comcast's limited basic service, said she enjoys Korean programming on the MiND network, which she lost in mid-April. And her 87-year-old mother, who has expanded basic service at her Wilmington home, lost her British comedies when the New Jersey public television station went dark. Comcast moved the channels from analog to digital, requiring customers with Comcast's analog subscriptions to get converter boxes. On May 19, three more channels -- MSNBC, Turner Classic Movies and the Comcast Network -- will require the box. That will make 11 stations in all that have "migrated" to digital in recent years for expanded basic customers. There is a small added cost for an upgraded converter box for digital cable after one free year. Company officials say they're moving the channels to open up space on the network for services such as more high-definition programming and faster Internet speeds. The converter box, they say, is different from the one used by TVs that rely on antennas and rabbit ears. The last stations that are still broadcasting over the air, instead of digitally, will go digital on June 12. "You're talking about two entirely separate events," said Comcast spokesman Jeff Alexander. "The federally mandated transition affects over-the-air broadcast channels. It does not affect cable customers. It's apples and oranges." But Foreman said that explanation didn't justify Comcast's ads. "What's annoying everybody is all the advertisements that went out, if you have cable, you do nothing," Foreman said. "It's like, why do we have to go get a converter box from Comcast?" Bruce Leichtman, a New Hampshire-based cable television analyst, said there's a lot of confusion out there. "Even my mother called me about this a few days ago," Leichtman said. "The digital transition is not the digital migration. They are related but they are not the same thing. A lot of people are struggling with that." Leichtman said for every single bandwidth used by an analog channel, 10 to 12 digital channels, or three high-definition channels, can take its place. "Analog is a killer," he said. Only 30 percent to 40 percent of households in the country have high-definition televisions, but that's the highest-income audience, Leichtman said. "Any company is going to respond the most to those who spend the most money," he said, adding that those without HD are still being served. Barry Orton, professor of telecommunications at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, said cable companies are headed in the direction of all-digital. Other cable companies, like Charter and Time Warner, are doing this, too, he said. Orton said the Comcast ads amounted to "puffery." "It's certainly not completely misleading. It's partially misleading," Orton said. But he didn't have much sympathy for customers who are resisting the change. "You're hanging on, and the technology and information you want has moved on to other formats," Orton said. "That's what happened with my Betamax, it's what happened with my reel-to-reel recorder, it's what happened with my cassette player. It's what happened to VHS. This is the way the planned obsolescence of entertainment technology works. You get something, it works for a while, but the industry and the technology moves on, and sooner or later, you can't buy information for it anymore, unless you convert it." The "vast majority" of Comcast cable customers already have some form of digital cable, Alexander said. Comcast has offered one digital converter box to limited basic customers -- those who pay for the fewest channels -- for no cost for 12 months. That will get them back the two public TV stations. After the first year, each box will cost $1.40 per month. For expanded basic customers, they can get one box at no cost and additional ones at $4.95 per month. That will get them reunited with such channels as the Game Show Network, AMC, the Style Network and the Cartoon Network, and, after May 19, MSNBC, TCM and the Comcast Network. Al McLachlan, of Greenville, said he found the advertising campaign "baloney," but decided to work out a deal with Comcast that kept his family's favorite stations, such as AMC. The former expanded basic customer bought a bundle package that kicked him up to the digital preferred tier, and also received Internet and telephone service. He's paying more each month for a digital box to cover a second television set. "It caused me to embrace Comcast even though I was criticizing them," McLachlan said. Avril Madison, a limited basic customer living in Wilmington, said she got so upset at the changes, she contacted the Public Service Commission, which she said investigated on her behalf. Her letter from the PSC said Comcast was within its rights to move the stations, but informed her she was entitled to three, not one, free converter boxes for one year, with the monthly fee thereafter, she said. "These are terrible economic times to have to add something more to your monthly bill, when you're trying to keep your costs down," said Madison, who said she went through the "rigmarole" of installing the set-top boxes, and is happy to have her public television stations back. "If you have more than one TV, it adds up." Alexander said he did not know why Madison was told she was entitled to three free boxes, because the general policy as he understood it was one box. Alexander said expanded basic customers who get the box will also get on-demand programming as well as some stations they didn't have before, such as Bloomberg, C-SPAN 3 and Shop NBC. Additional Facts YOU'LL NEED A BOX Comcast expanded basic customers have lost these stations over the last several years and need a digital converter box to get them back: Game Show Network TV Guide Network Leased Access Cartoon Network AMC Style Network WYBE/MiND NJN These customers will need a box for these stations come May 19: MSNBC Comcast Network Turner Classic Movies -- ================================ George Antunes, Political Science Dept University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927 Mail: antunes at uh dot edu *********************************** * POST TO [email protected] * *********************************** Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
