May 11, 2009

Advertising Losses Put Squeeze on TV News
By BRIAN STELTER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/11/business/media/11local.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


It is getting so bad for local television stations that some are turning 
to newspapers for help.

The bankrupt Tribune Company has merged its TV stations and daily 
newspapers in Miami and Hartford, and it already produces a lighthearted 
morning show in south Florida with the help of the newspaper’s 
columnists. Bob Gremillion, the executive vice president for publishing, 
calls it a “circling the wagons” approach.

No one would dispute that “the two industries are very challenged,” he 
said. “We’re combining and fighting together.”

The mergers are an example of local TV’s agonizing search for new 
business models as some balance sheets turn red. Starting Monday in 
Chicago, four stations’ news departments are combining their camera 
crews. In other markets, stations are adding newscasts on the cheap even 
as they lay off people. On the opposite extreme, a handful of stations 
are closing their news divisions completely.

The news for stations has been grim lately: without election 
advertisements to defray the losses in automotive ads, a cross section 
of station owners reported 20 percent to 30 percent quarterly drops in 
revenue last week, suggesting that the local TV business is almost as 
weak as its print counterpart.

“Unfortunately, there was nowhere to hide during the current storm, as 
declines in both local and national advertising accelerated,” Timothy E. 
Stautberg, the chief financial officer for the E. W. Scripps Company, 
which owns newspapers in 14 markets and TV stations in 10 markets, told 
investors last week.

About two-thirds of Americans say they regularly get news from local TV, 
according to the Pew Research Center. News is responsible for 40 percent 
to 50 percent of a station’s revenue on average, and many stations are 
still profitable. But owners see their audiences splintering and they 
see their parent networks bypassing them on the Web. What they are 
struggling to maintain is relevance.

Station revenue is down across the country: at E. W. Scripps, down 20 
percent compared with the same quarter last year; at Belo, the owner of 
20 stations, down 23 percent; at LIN TV, the owner of 29 stations, down 
21 percent. The media conglomerates are also affected; the News 
Corporation reported a station revenue decline 28 percent and the Walt 
Disney Company reported a 30 percent decline.

Underscoring the weakness in the overall advertising market, struggling 
car companies like General Motors and Chrysler — traditionally among the 
top sponsors of local news — have essentially cut their ad spending in 
half from a year ago, according to the station owners. To a lesser 
degree, News Corporation said, “virtually every category was down in the 
quarter.”

Ads from political candidates and advocacy groups usually buoy stations 
in election years, so odd-numbered years are generally weaker. But this 
year the declines are much more dramatic.

Even before the ad shortfalls, news departments were feeling the effects 
of the recession. Robert A. Papper, a journalism professor at Hofstra 
who surveys TV newsrooms every year, found that local stations shed 
1,200 news jobs last year. Mr. Papper also found a 13 percent drop in 
reporter salaries and a 11.5 percent decline in anchor salaries.

At the same time stations are trimming staff, they are trying — just 
like newspapers — to transform into 24-hour news-gathering operations 
with robust Web sites. But the comparisons to newspapers end there, at 
least in the minds of many in the industry who are betting that the TV 
losses are not permanent. Rupert Murdoch, the chairman of the News 
Corporation, said Thursday, “My own personal feeling is that we will see 
a return to television advertising faster than we see it to newspapers.”

By then, though, some stations may not be broadcasting anymore, at least 
not in their current form. Some experts are predicting consolidations in 
saturated local markets. Recalling an old expression, Dennis Thatcher, 
the chief operating officer of Mission Broadcasting, said the current 
scramble for ad dollars is like “dinner for three in a two-porkchop world.”

In Scranton and Wilkes-Barre, Pa., Mission’s station is the one going 
hungry. Last month, Mission shut the news division at the struggling 
station, WYOU, and put syndicated entertainment shows in place of newscasts.

The station draws strong ratings for CBS’s prime-time shows, “but the 
audience went other places for news,” Mr. Thatcher said, still sounding 
saddened a month after the decision. Despite anchor swaps, set redesigns 
and new newscasts at 4 and 7 p.m., WYOU could never effectively compete 
with the two powerhouse stations in the market.

“It’s one of the most difficult decisions you have to make as a 
broadcaster, and one I hope I never have to make again,” he said.

In Mission Broadcasting’s other markets, though, stations are adding 
news. Mr. Thatcher recently added a morning newscast in Abilene, Tex., 
and is weighing whether to add weekend newscasts in Terre Haute, Ind.

Other station groups across the country are also increasing newscasts. 
Mr. Murdoch said Fox stations were doing so because “we have the staff 
there. It doesn’t cost money.”

Mr. Papper said many stations are doing more with less; in 2008, network 
affiliates set “a new record for the amount of news” on weekdays, with 
an average of 4.6 hours a station.

Much of this news, its producers acknowledge, is recycled from the day’s 
newspaper or taken from wire services. Nevertheless, the stations play 
an important role. In a speech at a broadcasting convention last month, 
Fred Young, who recently retired from Hearst-Argyle Television, said 
that “when news is breaking, it usually pulls the news consumer back to 
the local television station — the spot at which most of them are most 
comfortable.”

To be able to afford to cover the news, an increasing number of stations 
are sharing their camera crews in arrangements called pools. NBC and Fox 
stations started pooling some resources last year in cities like 
Philadelphia and New York. This week, two more stations will join the 
pool in Chicago, leaving one lone holdout, WLS, among the major 
affiliates in the Windy City.

Partnerships between local newspapers and local broadcasters are 
happening in a similar vein. In Fort Lauderdale, Fla., last summer, the 
Tribune station WSFL, a CW affiliate, moved into the building housing 
the South Florida Sun-Sentinel newspaper, also owned by Tribune. The 
print and TV — actually, make that text and video — employees are now 
assigned to stories by a single assignment desk, and they are bringing 
back all the necessary elements for a story, be it video for TV or audio 
clips for the Web site, Mr. Gremillion said.

Last month the station started a lively four-hour morning show. 
Borrowing elements of the “Today” show, the hosts sit around a coffee 
table and intersperse news headlines and weather reports with celebrity 
gossip and, on Friday, a segment about the “top five worst TV moms in 
history.”

“It’s a conversation,” said the executive producer, José Suarez.

The newspaper’s personal finance, fashion and television columnists, 
among others, regularly appear on TV, either on set or via a webcam 
connection from home. Mr. Gremillion said the morning show “gives the 
station a personality.”

“It’s clear that local news is what differentiates us from other media,” 
he said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to