Group: Overhaul FCC Broadband Rulings
Open Access Sought Via Revamp Of Regulations

by John Eggerton
Multichannel News

5/18/2009 12:00:00 AM MT

http://www.multichannel.com/article/232691-Group_Overhaul_FCC_Broadband_Rulings.php


Washington — Open Internet-advocacy group Free Press has a modest 
proposal: review and, if necessary, reverse any regulatory rulings by 
the Federal Communications Commission that don’t promote open broadband 
competition and openness.

In a report with the ambitious title of Dismantling Digital 
Deregulation: Toward a National Broadband Strategy, Free Press also 
called for codifying the FCC’s access principles into network-neutrality 
rules, and for classifying broadband as a telecommunications service, 
thus allowing for open-access conditions to be imposed on 
Internet-service providers.

The Supreme Court effectively laid the groundwork for the 
network-neutrality debate in its 2005 Brand X decision, upholding the 
FCC’s determination that cable operators did not have to open their 
broadband lines to outside ISPs.

The FCC proceeded to apply that principle to broadband delivery in general.

Free Press’s broadband remake would also include a data-driven standard 
of market power and abuse by broadband providers. It also wants to open 
more of the “public airwaves” for use by unlicensed devices like 
laptops. And it would like to see the universal service fund transition 
from supporting phone service to underwriting broadband service.

The report received favorable reviews from acting FCC chairman Michael 
Copps. “The Free Press Report really highlights the many broadband 
challenges that were ignored for far too long,” he told Multichannel 
News in an e-mail.

Copps laid some of the blame at the feet of his agency. “[T]he 
commission unfortunately contributed to the problem over the last eight 
years,” he said. “Too many Americans don’t have access to affordable, 
high-speed broadband today and that’s because there was never any plan 
to get there. Nor did we do the kind of in-depth analysis we should have 
been doing. The commission is now committed to seeing that change.”

“We are eagerly working on developing a national broadband plan and we 
welcome any and all suggestions for how to proceed, including those from 
Free Press.”

The FCC is currently seeking comments on the national broadband rollout 
plan it must present to Congress by February of next year as part of the 
economic stimulus plan’s broadband-deployment initiative.

“America’s broadband failures are the result of policy failures and the 
blame falls squarely on the FCC’s shoulders,” said Free Press research 
director S. Derek Turner, who wrote the report. “The FCC predicted a 
future of broadband competition, and then regulated as if it were 
already here. While promising consumer benefits, it tore down consumer 
protections. Digital deregulation reduced the broadband revolution to 
broadband mediocrity.”

Copps might have found a lot to agree with in the Free Press report, but 
will his successor, Julius Genachowski, feel the same way? Genachowski 
helped craft the Obama administration’s technology policy, including its 
support for network neutrality.

Randolph May of free-market think tank The Free State Foundation, isn’t 
sure, but he isn’t taking any chances, either. “I just don’t think we 
know, and until we know for sure that [Genachowski] doesn’t accept this 
vision, then we have to make it clear why it would not be a good thing 
for the country to adopt,” said May.

That’s not a good thing, according to May, because it is “a radical 
vision of the return of the very same type of common-carrier regime for 
broadband that prevailed in the last century.”

May said that has been the end game all along for network-neutrality 
backers, but “rarely, if ever, have they unabashedly made it so clear.”

McDowell said he had only read a summary of the report, but cautioned: 
“I think we should step back, take a deep breath. … What’s most 
important is that we look at the U.S.’s broadband situation from a 
multitude of viewpoints and not rely on one or two lenses to view the 
situation through.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to