May 20, 2009, 12:49 pm

The High Cost of Selling Cheap Music Services
By Saul Hansell
NY Times

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/20/the-high-cost-of-selling-cheap-music-services/?pagemode=print


After writing about how Napster renegotiated its deals with record 
labels to offer its music subscription service at a lower price, I 
called RealNetworks, which offers the Rhapsody service, to see if its 
executives were excited about cutting similar deals that would allow it 
to offer its own $5-a-month music service. For years, after all, people 
trying to popularize music subscriptions — which allow you to listen to 
anything you want for a monthly fee — have been telling me the concept 
is great but the price the record labels want is too high.

But Mike Lunsford, Real’s executive vice president, was anything but 
excited. Sure, more people will want a service that costs $5 a month 
than one that costs $13 a month. (Indeed, the new $5 offer is better 
because it also includes five MP3 tracks to keep each month.)

But even a great value doesn’t mean the service will sell itself. Like 
any business that sells subscriptions, from Sports Illustrated to 
Netflix, Rhapsody needs to advertise to attract new customers. Paying 
for that marketing and the other costs of operating the service is 
harder with fewer dollars moving through the company.

“At $5 a month, we’d need five times as many customers than we do now to 
make it all work,” Mr. Lunsford said.

Napster doesn’t have this problem because it is now owned by Best Buy, 
which can promote the service in its weekly circulars and through its 
stores.

“If they had to pay for all that promotion, it would eat up all the 
profit on Napster,” Mr. Lunsford said.

For the last year, Real has been trying to find a way to offer Rhapsody 
without having to sell subscriptions one at a time. Its idea is to 
bundle the music service with Internet service and cellphone plans. It 
hopes that an Internet provider or wireless carrier would see access to 
unlimited music as a way to stand out from the competition, at a 
wholesale cost of a few dollars per subscriber.

The company just struck a deal with Vodafone, which will include its 
music service as part of an unlimited wireless data plan that costs 16 
euros ($22) a month.

It hopes to strike similar deals in the United States and other 
countries. The new pricing flexibility from the music labels will help. 
But labels still want to charge a higher price for music delivered to 
cellphones than to computers.

Nokia appears to be in a similar standoff with the labels. It is hoping 
to bring its “Comes With Music” program — which bundles a service 
offering unlimited access to music with certain phones — to the United 
States this year. But so far, it has not been able to strike deals with 
the labels.

The labels may have a point. If your cellphone could play any song you 
wanted in an easy and unobtrusive way, that would be worth something.

But over and over again, customers are saying the right price for music 
is free. Since a free service, like Pandora, doesn’t have the huge 
subscriber acquisition costs of even a low-priced subscription offering, 
I wonder whether businesses like Real and Napster, and eventually the 
music labels, will one day realize that free may well be better for them 
than cheap.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to