July 20, 2009

Wikipedia May Be a Font of Facts, but It’s a Desert for Photos
By NOAM COHEN
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/20/arts/20funny.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


Some may wonder: Could there be a bad picture of Halle Berry or George 
Clooney?

Just visit Wikipedia. There you’ll find a fuzzy shot of Ms. Berry from 
the mid-1980s, when she was part of a U.S.O. tour with other Miss USA 
contestants. She is out of focus and wearing a red-and-white baseball 
cap — in short, she is barely recognizable. Mr. Clooney, in his 
Wikipedia entry, is shown in Chad wearing a khaki vest and a United 
Nations cap. Smiling, he is ruggedly handsome in the company of two 
women who work for the United Nations; still this is hardly a glamour shot.

Then there are big names like Howard Stern or Julius Erving who have no 
photograph at all on Wikipedia.

At a time when celebrities typically employ a team of professionals to 
control their images, Wikipedia is a place where chaos rules. Few 
high-quality photographs, particularly of celebrities, make it onto this 
site. This is because the site runs only pictures with the most 
permissive Creative Commons license, which allows anyone to use an 
image, for commercial purposes or not, as long as the photographer is 
credited.

“Representatives or publicists will contact us” horrified at the 
photographs on the site, said Jay Walsh, a spokesman for the Wikimedia 
Foundation, which operates the Wikipedia encyclopedias in more than 200 
languages. “They will say: ‘I have this image. I want you to use this 
image.’ But it is not as simple as uploading a picture that is e-mailed 
to us.”

“In general,” he added, “we need them to know that giving us a 
photograph from Annie Leibovitz won’t work unless Annie Leibovitz is 
O.K. with it.”

Photographs are a glaring flaw in the Wikipedia model. Unlike the 
articles on the site, which in theory are improved, fact checked, 
footnoted and generally enhanced over time, photographs are static works 
created by individuals. A bad article can become a better article. A bad 
photograph simply stays bad.

Wikipedians have tried to make up for this defect by organizing outings 
where groups of contributors take high-quality photographs of buildings 
or objects. Likewise Wikipedia has tried to gain permission from large 
photographic collections to use their material.

Last winter the German Federal Archives released 100,000 low-resolution 
digital copies under a license so they could appear on Wikipedia. 
Recently a Wikipedia user, Derrick Coetzee, downloaded more than 3,000 
high-resolution photographs from the British National Portrait Gallery — 
to serve, in essence, as the head shots for important historical figures 
like Charlotte Brontë or Charles Darwin.

The gallery threatened legal action against Mr. Coetzee, saying that 
while the painted portraits may be old and thus beyond copyright 
protection, the photographs are new and therefore copyrighted work. The 
gallery is demanding a response by Monday from Mr. Coetzee, who is being 
represented by the Electronic Frontier Foundation. In an e-mail message 
on Friday a gallery spokeswoman, Eleanor Macnair, wrote that “contact 
has now been made” with the Wikimedia Foundation and “we remain hopeful 
that a dialogue will be possible.”

But none of this has made much of an improvement in Wikipedia’s 
photography. Any gallery of hideous Wikipedia photographs would include 
the former N.B.A. star George Gervin, who is standing stiffly in a suit 
in a shot that is cropped longer and thinner than would be typical even 
for a basketball player. The unrestricted photograph came from the 
office of Senator John Cornyn of Texas, who has been cut out of it.

As in Mr. Gervin’s case, the government is a prime source for public 
domain photographs. President Obama, for example, looks composed and 
serious in the official portrait that sits on the upper right-hand 
corner of his article.

But Wikipedia contributors also cull government collections for 
photographs of celebrities’ meetings with politicians, hoping to find 
something to post on the page.

The former home-run king Hank Aaron is shown in an out-of-context, oddly 
cropped photograph from a 1978 visit to the White House. Likewise the 
main photograph of Michael Jackson was taken from his 1984 visit with 
Ronald and Nancy Reagan.

Recent photographs on Wikipedia almost exclusively are the work of 
amateurs who don’t mind giving away their work. Amateur may be too kind 
a word; their photos tend to be the work of fans who happen to have a 
camera. The opera singer Natalie Dessay is shown looking the wrong way 
at an autograph signing; the actress Allison Janney appears in 
sunglasses at the Toronto Film Festival. The Coen brothers, Joel and 
Ethan, are seen from middle distance at Cannes in 2001, with Ethan 
covering his mouth, perhaps because he has just coughed.

Then there are the photographs taken from the stands, with the subject 
barely a fleck. Barry Bonds is apparently the outfielder in the center 
of one photograph on his page; David Beckham can be discerned with his 
hands on hips during a 1999 soccer match.

A few celebrities, like Plácido Domingo and Oliver Stone, have had the 
foresight to provide their own freely licensed photographs. And 
considering the money that stars spend to maintain their image, it is 
surprising that more have not invested in high-quality, freely licensed 
photographs for Wikipedia and other sites. Perhaps they don’t recognize 
how popular Wikipedia is. In June, for example, Ms. Berry’s article had 
more than 180,000 page views.

Also, it can be difficult to persuade a talent photographer to go along 
with that approach because one free photograph can drive out all the 
others, said Jerry Avenaim, a celebrity photographer. He is unusual in 
that he has contributed about a dozen low-resolution photographs to 
Wikipedia, including a shot of the actor Mark Harmon, originally created 
for TV Guide.

In an interview Mr. Avenaim still sounded torn about the idea of 
contributing his work. He said he was trying to accomplish two goals: 
“One, I really wanted to help the celebrities that I care about to show 
them in the proper light they want to be shown,” he said. “Second, it is 
an interesting marketing strategy for myself.”

He said that having his work on Wikipedia has increased his online 
visibility as reflected in search-engine results and traffic to his Web 
site,, but that the costs are potentially high. “This is the lifeblood 
of my career,” he said, noting that photographers may get paid very 
little for a celebrity shot for a magazine. They make their money from 
resales of the image. And even a low-resolution photograph that is 
available free — say, his shot of Dr. Phil — becomes the default 
photograph online and means there is no need to pay for another one of 
his shots.

That, ultimately, is the issue for photographers who might want to 
donate their work to Wikipedia, but not the entire Internet.

“To me the problem is the Wikipedia rule of public use,” Mr. Avenaim 
said. “If they truly wanted to elevate the image on the site, they 
should allow photographers to maintain the copyright.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to