July 21, 2009

Driven to Distraction
U.S. Withheld Data on Risks of Distracted Driving
By MATT RICHTEL
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/21/technology/21distracted.html?_r=1&hp=&pagewanted=print


In 2003, researchers at a federal agency proposed a long-term study of 
10,000 drivers to assess the safety risk posed by cellphone use behind 
the wheel.

They sought the study based on evidence that such multitasking was a 
serious and growing threat on America’s roadways.

But such an ambitious study never happened. And the researchers’ agency, 
the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, decided not to make 
public hundreds of pages of research and warnings about the use of 
phones by drivers — in part, officials say, because of concerns about 
angering Congress.

On Tuesday, the full body of research is being made public for the first 
time by two consumer advocacy groups, which filed a Freedom of 
Information Act lawsuit for the documents. The Center for Auto Safety 
and Public Citizen provided a copy to The New York Times, which is 
publishing the documents on its Web site.

In interviews, the officials who withheld the research offered their 
fullest explanation to date.

The former head of the highway safety agency said he was urged to 
withhold the research to avoid antagonizing members of Congress who had 
warned the agency to stick to its mission of gathering safety data but 
not to lobby states.

Critics say that rationale and the failure of the Transportation 
Department, which oversees the highway agency, to more vigorously pursue 
distracted driving has cost lives and allowed to blossom a culture of 
behind-the-wheel multitasking.

“We’re looking at a problem that could be as bad as drunk driving, and 
the government has covered it up,” said Clarence Ditlow, director of the 
Center for Auto Safety.

The group petitioned for the information after The Los Angeles Times 
wrote about the research last year. Mother Jones later published 
additional details.

The highway safety researchers estimated that cellphone use by drivers 
caused around 955 fatalities and 240,000 accidents over all in 2002.

The researchers also shelved a draft letter they had prepared for 
Transportation Secretary Norman Y. Mineta to send, warning states that 
hands-free laws might not solve the problem.

That letter said that hands-free headsets did not eliminate the serious 
accident risk. The reason: a cellphone conversation itself, not just 
holding the phone, takes drivers’ focus off the road, studies showed.

The research mirrors other studies about the dangers of multitasking 
behind the wheel. Research shows that motorists talking on a phone are 
four times as likely to crash as other drivers, and are as likely to 
cause an accident as someone with a .08 blood alcohol content.

The three-person research team based the fatality and accident estimates 
on studies that quantified the risks of distracted driving, and an 
assumption that 6 percent of drivers were talking on the phone at a 
given time. That figure is roughly half what the Transportation 
Department assumes to be the case now.

More precise data does not exist because most police forces have not 
collected long-term data connecting cellphones to accidents. That is why 
the researchers called for the broader study with 10,000 or more drivers.

“We nevertheless have concluded that the use of cellphones while driving 
has contributed to an increasing number of crashes, injuries and 
fatalities,” according to a “talking points” memo the researchers 
compiled in July 2003.

It added: “We therefore recommend that the drivers not use wireless 
communication devices, including text messaging systems, when driving, 
except in an emergency.”

Dr. Jeffrey Runge, then the head of the highway safety agency, said he 
grudgingly decided not to publish the Mineta letter and policy 
recommendation because of larger political considerations.

At the time, Congress had warned the agency not to use its research to 
lobby states. Dr. Runge said transit officials told him he could 
jeopardize billions of dollars of its financing if Congress perceived 
the agency had crossed the line into lobbying.

The fate of the research was discussed during a high-level meeting at 
the transportation secretary’s office. The meeting included Dr. Runge, 
several staff members with the highway safety agency and John Flaherty, 
Mr. Mineta’s chief of staff.

Mr. Flaherty recalls that the group decided not to publish the research 
because the data was too inconclusive.

He recalled that Dr. Runge “indicated that the data was incomplete and 
there was going to be more research coming.”

He recalled summing up his position as, the agency “should make a 
decision as to whether they wanted to wait for more data.”

But Dr. Runge recalled feeling that the issue was dire and needed public 
attention. “I really wanted to send a letter to governors telling them 
not to give a pass to hands-free laws,” said Dr. Runge, whose staff 
spent months preparing a binder of materials for their presentation.

His broader goal, he said, was to educate people about the dangers of 
distracted driving. “Based on the research, there was a possibility of 
this becoming a really big problem,” he said.

But “my advisers upstairs said we should not poke a finger in the eye of 
the appropriations committee,” he recalled.

He said Mr. Flaherty asked him, “Do we have enough evidence right now to 
not create enemies among all the stakeholders?”

Those stakeholders, Dr. Runge said, were the House Appropriations 
Committee and groups that might influence it, notably voters who 
multitask while driving and, to a much smaller degree, the cellphone 
industry.

Mr. Mineta, who left as transportation secretary in 2006, said he was 
unaware of the meeting.

“I don’t think it ever got to my desk,” he said of the research. Mr. 
Ditlow, from the Center for Auto Safety, said the officials’ 
explanations for withholding the research raised concerns. He said the 
research did not constitute lobbying of states.

And he said it was consistent with the highway safety agency’s research 
in other areas, like seat belts.

Mr. Ditlow said that putting fears of the House panel ahead of public 
safety was an abdication of the agency’s responsibility.

“No public health and safety agency should allow its research to be 
suppressed for political reasons,” he said. Doing so “will cause deaths 
and injuries on the highways.”

State Senator Joe Simitian of California, who tried from 2001 to 2005 to 
pass a hands-free cellphone law over objections of the cellphone 
industry, said the unpublished research would have helped him convince 
his colleagues that cellphones cause serious — deadly — distraction.

“Years went by when lives could have been saved,” said Mr. Simitian, who 
in 2006 finally pushed through a hands-free law that took effect last year.

The highway safety agency, rather than commissioning a study with 10,000 
drivers, handled one involving 100 cars. That study, done with the 
Virginia Tech Transportation Institute, placed cameras inside cars to 
monitor drivers for more than a year.

It found that drivers using a hand-held device were at 1.3 times greater 
risk of a crash or near crash, and at three times the risk when dialing 
compared with other drivers.

Not all the research went unpublished. The safety agency put on its Web 
site an annotated bibliography of more than 150 scientific articles that 
showed how a cellphone conversation while driving taxes the brain’s 
processing power, reducing reaction time. But the bibliography included 
only a list of the articles, not the one-page summaries of each one 
written by the researchers.

Chris Monk, who researched the bibliography for 18 months, said the 
exclusion of the summaries took the teeth out of the findings.

“It became almost laughable,” Mr. Monk said. “What they wound up finally 
publishing was a stripped-out summary.”

Mr. Monk and Mike Goodman, a division head at the safety agency who led 
the research project, theorize that the agency might have felt pressure 
from the cellphone industry. Mr. Goodman said the industry frequently 
checked in with him about the project and his progress. (He said the 
industry knew about the research because he had worked with it to gather 
some data).

But he could offer no proof of the industry’s influence. Mr. Flaherty 
said he was not contacted or influenced by the industry.

The agency’s current policy is that people should not use cellphones 
while driving. Rae Tyson, a spokesman for the agency, said it did not, 
and would not, publish the researchers’ fatality estimates because they 
were not definitive enough.

He said the other research was compiled as background material for the 
agency, not for the public.

“There is no report to publish,” he said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to