JULY 21, 2009

Pay of Top Earners Erodes Social Security
Fund Expected to Be Exhausted in 2037
  
By ELLEN E. SCHULTZ
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124813343694466841.html#mod=testMod


The nation's wealth gap is widening amid an uproar about lofty pay 
packages in the financial world.

Executives and other highly compensated employees now receive more than 
one-third of all pay in the U.S., according to a Wall Street Journal 
analysis of Social Security Administration data -- without counting 
billions of dollars more in pay that remains off federal radar screens 
that measure wages and salaries.

Highly paid employees received nearly $2.1 trillion of the $6.4 trillion 
in total U.S. pay in 2007, the latest figures available. The 
compensation numbers don't include incentive stock options, unexercised 
stock options, unvested restricted stock units and certain benefits.

The pay of employees who receive more than the Social Security wage base 
-- now $106,800 -- increased by 78%, or nearly $1 trillion, over the 
past decade, exceeding the 61% increase for other workers, according to 
the analysis. In the five years ending in 2007, earnings for American 
workers rose 24%, half the 48% gain for the top-paid. The result: The 
top-paid represent 33% of the total, up from 28% in 2002.

The growing portion of pay that exceeds the maximum amount subject to 
payroll taxes has contributed to the weakening of the Social Security 
trust fund. In May, the government said the Social Security fund would 
be exhausted in 2037, four years earlier than was predicted in 2008.

The data suggest that the payroll tax ceiling hasn't kept up with the 
growth in executive pay. As executive pay has increased, the percentage 
of wages subject to payroll taxes has shrunk, to 83% from 90% in 1982. 
Compensation that isn't subject to the portion of payroll tax that funds 
old-age benefits now represents foregone revenue of $115 billion a year.

The magnitude of executive pay has been difficult to measure, even as 
policy makers grapple with ways to rein in compensation at companies 
receiving taxpayer bailouts. Companies aggregate the salaries of all 
employees in their filings to the Internal Revenue Service and to the 
Securities and Exchange Commission, and disclose details only for top 
officers.

But payroll taxes provide an indirect way to calculate amounts 
executives receive. Only earnings up to a certain ceiling are subject to 
a U.S. payroll tax of 12.4%, split between employer and employee, which 
finances Social Security retirement benefits.

The ceiling, which is indexed to the average growth in wages, is 
$106,800 in 2009, up from $102,000 in 2008 and $97,500 in 2007. 
(Employers and employees also each pay 1.45% on an individual's total 
income, with no salary ceiling, to fund Medicare.)

Social Security data show that 6% of wage earners have pay that exceeds 
the taxable earnings base, and that their "covered earnings" above the 
taxable maximum totaled $1.1 trillion in 2007. Adding the portion of 
their pay below the taxable wage base, $991 billion, totals $2.1 trillion.

The $2.1 trillion figure understates executive pay, however, because it 
includes just salary and vested deferred compensation, including 
bonuses. It doesn't include unvested employer contributions and unvested 
interest credited to deferred-pay accounts. Nor does it include 
unexercised stock options (options aren't subject to payroll tax until 
exercised), and unvested restricted stock (which isn't subject to 
payroll tax until vested; the subsequent appreciation is taxed as a 
capital gain).

Also not included in the total compensation figures is executive pay 
never subject to payroll tax. This category includes incentive stock 
options (which are generally taxed as capital gains), "carried interest" 
income received by hedge-fund and private-equity fund partners (also 
taxed as capital gains), and compensation characterized as a benefit 
(benefits generally aren't subject to any taxes).

Benefits, a category that includes employer-provided health care and 
contributions employers make to rank-and-file pension plans, totaled 
nearly $1 trillion in 2007; it isn't possible to tell what portion 
represents benefits for executives, such as life insurance.

The ability to delay paying payroll taxes on compensation, something 
that generally is available only to highly paid employees, is in itself 
an economic benefit that ultimately boosts paychecks.

Lawmakers over the years have introduced bills to raise the taxable wage 
ceiling, or eliminate it, as was done for the Medicare portion in 1993. 
During the presidential campaign, Barack Obama proposed extending 
payroll taxes on households with incomes above $250,000, but the 
administration isn't pursuing any change as it focuses on proposals for 
tax increases on wealthy households to help finance a health-care program.

Lifting the earnings ceiling could result in higher Social Security 
benefits payments to higher-income individuals, since benefits are based 
on a worker's highest 35 years of earnings. But the additional tax 
revenue would have decades to earn a return, thus offsetting the cost of 
the additional payments.

Social Security Administration actuaries estimate removing the earnings 
ceiling could eliminate the trust fund's deficit altogether for the next 
75 years, or nearly eliminate it if credit toward benefits was provided 
for the additional taxable earnings.

Employers oppose changes that would increase their share of payroll tax. 
In addition, eliminating the ceiling would prevent employers from using 
a controversial but common technique, based on payroll taxes, to award 
additional benefits to executives who participate in rank-and-file 
pension and 401(k) plans.

For example, health insurer Humana Inc. contributes 4% of pay to 
employees' retirement accounts on salary up to the taxable-earnings wage 
base -- and 8% above it. Thanks to the richer contribution, Humana Chief 
Executive Michael B. McCallister received a total contribution of 
$22,370 under the plan in 2008. (He also received $314,790 in company 
contributions to his supplemental executive retirement and savings plan.)

Typically, employers can't discriminate in favor of high-paid employees 
who participate in taxpayer-subsidized retirement plans. But a 
"permitted disparity" exception enables them to provide additional 
benefits on the portion of pay that isn't subject to payroll taxes, 
ostensibly to replace the Social Security benefits executives won't 
receive on the portion of their pay that is exempt from payroll taxes.

Humana declined to comment.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to