Spontaneous, improvised - would it be allowed to happen now?

By Andrew Orlowski ([email protected])

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/07/22/destination_moon/print.html

It's a temptation, watching many of the 40th Anniversary retrospectives,
to think of the Apollo space program as a triumph of power and
industrial might. The superpowers' space programs were, of course,
political and chauvinistic, designed to showcase national wealth. But
there's a better way of looking at the program, Dennis Wingo reminded me
recently. Masses of money helped put man on the Moon of course, but the
Moon program is really a tale of engineering improvisation and human
organisation.

Space expert and entrepreneur Dennis Wingo put the first webserver - an
Apple Mac - in orbit, for just $7m, and has helped piece together a lot
of historical material that NASA didn't appreciate at the time - and
forgot about, or wiped. There is one piece of kit in particular that
encapsulates two stories: NASA's negligence, and the quite amazing
improvisation of the engineers. It's the Lunar Orbiter, which mapped the
moon's surface prior to manned descent. Wingo painstakingly recovered
and restored much of the imagery it took.

To give us an idea of how much Apollo owed to seat-of-the-pants
ingenuity, it's worth remembering that the story of the Orbiter begins
in 1961 - the year of the first human orbit of the Earth by Yuri
Gagarin. The space pioneers were seeing a high death rate from test
subjects - dogs (the USSR) and chimps (the USA), the latter proving to
be a duff move - the chimps panicked in the claustrophobic conditions.

The US program lagged far behind the Soviets', and NASA's early attempts
to keep up had become a national joke
(http://jokes4all.net/joke_2051.html). The Ranger had been the first
project to photograph the moon, with the modest ambition of crashing a
probe onto the surface. But of the first six Rangers
(http://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/lunar/ranger.html), two failed to
leave the Earth's orbit, one failed en route, two missed the Moon
completely, and although the sixth reached the target, its cameras
failed.

Yet by 1964, much of the technology that eventually put man on the Moon
had been already designed and built. The colossal Apollo expenditures
were on the physical implementation of the program, including the many
test flights. By 1965, the Apollo Lunar Excursion Module (LEM) was
already being prepared as a long-term shelter and accommodation unit.
And as Wingo points out, it was really down to 400 engineers - a
fraction of what Google devotes to inserting advertisements into web
pages - being given the freedom to put Heath Robinson designs into
practice.

The most successful space mission of all time: the Lunar Orbiter

The Lunar Orbiter astonishes even today. It had to take pictures, scan
and develop the film on board, and broadcast it successfully back to
earth. Naturally, the orbiter had to provide its own power, orient
itself without intervention from ground control, and maintain precise
temperature conditions and air pressure for the film processing, and
protect itself from solar radiation and cosmic rays - all within severe
size and weight constraints. This was far beyond the capabilities of the
newest spy satellites, which back then returned the film to earth in a
canister, retrieved by a specially kitted-out plane. The Orbiter
challenge was the Apollo challenge in miniature.

"A bunch of plumbers"

Between 1966 and 1967 the five Orbiters succeeded in mapping 99 per cent
of the moon's surface, sending back the first pictures of the Earth from
lunar orbit. Planning had actually preceded Kennedy's challenge to put
man on the moon. In 1959 a team at the Jet Propulsion Labs under Albert
Hibbs had envisaged a survey craft, winning funds for Congress for a
Surveyor Orbiter and Lander. The design goal was to capture 100m
resolution imagery with an orbiter weight of 950 to 1,100kg (even back
then, NASA was metric). By the time Apollo was created, the project had
got nowhere in fast in four years. The Surveyor project wasn't even
operationally active when Apollo's demanding requirements came through
in the summer of 1962.

For a manned vehicle to land safely, the Apollo directors wanted
stereoscopic images to identify slopes of seven degrees, and obstacles
less than 1m wide or deep. JPL was already over-burdened with existing
projects, and the Langley Research Centre (LRC) took over. The LRC would
choose and manage the contractors, and approve the technical decisions.

This choice didn't impress the experts. "How in the world could the
Langley Research Center, which is nothing more than a bunch of plumbers,
manage this scientific program to the moon?" asked the prominent
Nobel-prize winning scientist Harold Urey, to NASA's administrator James
Webb.

That's an odd question, and reflected the academic snobbery of the time.
The private sector, which came to the rescue of the Apollo program time
and again, had plenty of talent - particularly in the shape of STL
(Space Technology Laboratories).

STL was a division of a company founded in 1953 by Simon Ramo, Hughes'
former director of research, and Dean Wooldridge, another Hughes
executive, after they had become disillusioned by Howard Hughes'
management style. Ramo was the chief engineer on the ICBM missile
program. STL said it could could design and build three orbiters in 22
months - using a spin-scan camera rather than NASA's preferred TV camera
systems, and weighing just 320kg. In the end, STL wasn't the chosen bid,
and the spin-scan was considered too risky.

But the bureaucratic arguments continued. The Apollo requirements were
revised to identifying 15 degree slopes, 3.5m cones by 1965, and eight
degree slopes and 50cm cones in a 1,600m radius area in subsequent
missions. The project directors also needed to identify the nuisance
posed by space dust (micrometeroid flux, in the jargon), cosmic
radation, and solar particles. The twin requirements - high detail over
a limited area, and medium resolution over a wide area, were to result
in two cameras on board the Orbiter. Yet it was another year before a
project office (LOPO) was established under Cliff Nelson, in August
1963.

The Orbiter required three different subsystems - capture, scanning, and
transmission. All three, and everything else to get the Orbiter
launched, were developed in parallel. The engineers and their managers
simply didn't have time to read management theory books. Tech specs were
deliberately kept minimal and open ended. Contractors were encouraged to
"offer approaches which differed from the established specifications but
which would result in substantial gains in the probability of mission
success, reliability, schedule, and economy".

The thinking behind this was that the contractors would have to figure
out what worked - there was no time for religious affiliations with
specific technologies - and the most effective design would win. Of the
five contractors who submitted bids, Boeing won - borrowing an Eastman
Kodak system already used in spy satellites.

But Eastman Kodak had never had to take pictures quite like this before.
The reflection from the Moon's surface is so harsh that everything
appears flat. 

The final subsystem 

(http://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/lunar_orbiter/book/introduction.shtml
) featured two lenses - a high res 610mm lens and a medium resolution
80mm lens, with the output interlaced onto a 70mm strip of film, some
80m long. The slow film permitted high grain resolution and sharp
contrast pictures. It was developed using a dry processing technique
used by Kodak for the spook satellite cameras.

The Orbiter's raster scanned the negatives with a 5 micron wide, 200
line process (later 2 micron, 500 line). Processing the first results
took five hours. Getting the data back to earth was another challenge.

RCA provided the communications subsystem. A 1967 paper available to
IEEE members today describes some of the innovations: "A vestigial
sideband modulation for the transmission of the picture data, a
full-verification command system, a low-gain antenna system whose
pattern approaches that of an isotropic radiator over a large portion of
the radiation sphere, and a dual-power-level transmission system which
does not use RF switching." A lossless analogue compression technique
was invented for transmission.

All five orbiters were eventually crashed into the Moon to avoid bumping
into subsequent orbiters, and the Apollo missions, but not before taking
1,800 photographs.

Back on Earth, the first published photographs were actually captures
from TV sets - it would take 40 years, a lot of perspiration and some
good luck before the high resolution images were widely seen for the
first time - and bureaucratic neglect almost destroyed them.

The result was the most successful project in US space history - the
highest level of operational success. It was the Orbiter that took the
first "whole earth" picture (not Apollo) and provided the first pictures
of the dark side of the Moon. Not bad for a "bunch of plumbers".

Recovering the images

The data languished in a vault with other space program detritus for
years. Taking a call one day in 1986, NASA archivist Nancy Evans
persuaded the JPL to put the tapes in air conditioned dedicated storage.
She also had the forethought to request three Ampex 900 reel-to-reel
tape machines that could read the Orbiter's data. This half-ton machine
was already obsolete - most had been dumped at sea. But unable to find a
federal facility for the readers, she stored them at home, where they
gathered dust for 20 years.

Three years ago Wingo heard the tale, and started a project to restore
the images - suspecting that the best imagery had never been seen, and
that with modern graphic interpolation, they could be restored. Wingo
moved the readers and 48,000 lbs (over 20 tonnes) of tape to NASA Ames.
He hassled for funding, which was necessary to restore the readers to
working order - and a team of volunteers in an abandoned McDonalds,
renamed Pirate McMoon, set to work. (See the links at the end of this
story for a presentation and more information on the Lunar Orbiter Image
Recovery Project.)

The results emerged earlier this year, and Wingo was vindicated by the
results.

"The dynamic range of the images is incredible, it proved our point," he
says. Computer processing allowed them to reveal features never seen
before. Wingo also discovered that the photographs show polar ice extent
(http://www.climateaudit.org/?p=5637) for the period.

But the Orbiter looks even better when you remember the debacles that
preceded it, and consider the achievements of the post-1960s space
efforts.

The legacy of Apollo

The Langley team's success prompted some "What went right?" analysis.
Erasmus Kloman, at the National Academy of Public Administration, was
given the job of finding out. NASA published a redacted version of his
report, Unmanned Space Project Management: Surveyor and Lunar Orbiter,
which found that bureaucracy was kept to a minimum, while keeping
sharply defined goals, and inter-agency turf wars were largely absent.
Over on Apollo, 60 engineers reported directly to a senior manager.

As Wingo puts it: "The refugees from Apollo made up the middle
management of every Silicon Valley hardware company - they gave it the
management and technology backbone."

This was before the era of "corporate re-engineering" - where innovation
came to mean reshuffling the administration, rebranding, and a high
turnover of management fads. It's impossible to conceive how the EU or
the US could achieve such results in a short space of time today. The
modest space programs today take many years to complete.

The nature of science funding today, which has become politicised, also
deters imagination and risk-taking.

Handing over the Presidency to Kennedy, Eisenhower observed that "a
government contract becomes virtually a substitute for intellectual
curiosity" and warned
(http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article5407.htm) of the
"prospect of domination of the nation's scholars by Federal employment,
project allocations, and the power of money", with the danger that
"public policy could itself become the captive of a
scientific-technological elite".

That capture is now complete - scientific "study" merely serves the
political fashion, in the way Pocket Boroughs in England once served a
landowner. Ideas have permanent incumbency.

Saturn V would surely never be completed now - somebody would complain
about its "carbon footprint". With our impoverished idea of human
achievement, pessimism about our scientific and technological
capabilities, and little faith in human organisation, it is hard to
imagine Apollo happening today at all.
***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to