http://www.suntimes.com/technology/ihnatko/1606282,ihnatko-google-wave-060309.article

July 22, 2009
By ANDY IHNATKO [email protected]

Five days is an eon in Internet time. Given the huge amounts of discussion that 
Google Wave has earned online since the company unveiled it in an 80-minute 
live demo last week (as I write this, it’s the top of the 15th inning and 
Excitement and Skepticism are still tied at 7-7) I could be a little bit 
embarrassed for waiting so long to talk about it.

But I had to let it simmer. The demo was too good, too exciting. Any 
well-planned demonstration of an upcoming technology sends you out of the 
auditorium all riled-up, ready to grab a rifle with one hand and a banner with 
the other and God help anybody who stands between you … and … and … um …

And then it’s a day later and you’ve had a shower and a hot meal. You realize 
that this new thing is largely like many other demos you’ve seen. Most of those 
never lived up to the hype. Some never shipped at all.

“Only time will tell,” you muse.

Okay. Well, it’s been a few days now and I’m just as amped-up about Wave as I 
was on the 28th.

I imagine that there are as many pitfalls to defining and explaining Wave as 
Westinghouse and Edison found when trying explaining the concept of the 
electrical grid to the masses. You plug a light bulb into the socket and the 
crowd oohs and aahs and assumes that Electricity is all about illumination; 
it’s a marvelous way of producing light without the open flames or soot of 
candles and oil lamps. Technically that’s true, but it misses the point.

The full-length video of the developer demo is above and you can check out the 
official site (http://wave.google.com/) where you can also sign up to be 
notified when it’s ready for the public. A cursory viewing could leave you with 
the impression that Wave is a replacement for email and chat. But email and 
chat are just the light bulb and the toaster. In truth, Wave is an ambitious, 
brand-new infrastructure for communication in general.

Take this very column that I’m writing. Moving thoughts from my head to your 
eyeballs requires three or four different communications systems. I write the 
column here in my word processor (1). I email it to an editor (2). He or she 
makes some changes and if they’re big enough, I get a phone call or a separate 
email and we talk them over as I make changes (3). It then goes from my 
editor’s desk to the Sun-Times’ webserver and the mysterious part of the 
operation that publishes it on paper (4).



The Sun-Times Twitter (@suntimes http://www.twitter.com/suntimes) account 
broadcasts a link to the article when it’s been posted. I’ll probably re-Tweet 
it to my own 20,000 followers (@ihnatko, http://www.twitter.com/ihnatko) which 
we’ll call 5.

It would indeed be possible for me to use Wave the same way that I use email. 
But then I’d be just as clueless as the middle-manager who uses email like 
handwritten letters … printing them out on paper, adding some handwritten 
notes, and then mailing or faxing it back to the sender.

No, here’s how this column would be produced using Wave:

I have a browser window open that looks almost identical to my Google Mail 
window. I have an “inbox” of fresh Waves (well, if you must think of them as 
“messages” then go ahead … but I want my objection noted).

Just as with a conventional Inbox, the newest Waves are at the top. Waves with 
unread contents are highlighted in bold.

I click a button and create a new Wave. An empty editing pane opens on the side 
of the window, looking almost exactly like a new email message.

But it’s a rich-text editor that supports media and fancy formatting. I write 
my column. When I’m finally ready to give it to my editor — or at least ready 
for him to stop worrying that I’m only an hour from deadline and I still 
haven’t filed yet — I quietly drag his icon into the Wave.

Over at the Sun-Times, the Wave of this column appears in my editor’s Inbox, 
highlighted in bold. He clicks it to take a look.

Oh, damn. Technically, the Google Wave demo is only 80 minutes, not 90. I 
should have caught that error.

Before my editor’s very eyes, the “90” changes to “80.” The Wave is a “live” 
communication that I’m sharing with my editor any anybody else we choose to 
bring in. I’m still free to edit it. Finally satisfied that I have indeed 
crafted a Perfect Gem of flawless Truth, Beauty and Wisdom, I head over to the 
kitchen to fetch a celebratory Diet Dr. Pepper.

My editor quickly spots at least one line that causes grave concern: a sentence 
in which I intimate that Lars Rasmussen, Google Wave’s Software Engineering 
Manager has often been seen tramping out of a secluded wooded area carrying a 
shovel and a filthy empty burlap sack roughly large enough to stuff a whole 
human body in. He adds an instant message-like note: “It this true? Or are we 
going to get sued over a bad joke?”

I return to my office, beverage in hand. I note that the Wave containing this 
column is now in bold and at the top of my Inbox. I click and see his note. I 
add a threaded reply, also IM-style, sheepishly acknowledging that I was just 
having a bit of fun.

I see her typing him response to me, letter for letter. Good, he handled that 
well. Then I see the offending paragraph vanish.

(But how do you keep on top of all of these little conversations and changes? 
Each Wave has a timeline at the top. You can “reverse” or “fast-forward” 
through the timeline as though it was a YouTube video, witnessing the Wave 
change and evolve.)

My column has now been edited. My editor drags another participant into the 
Wave. This new guy is actually a little piece of software called a “robot,” 
located on a central server. The robot can now share in the process. This 
particular bot adds this article to the front page of the SunTimes.com site, 
without any of the private comments between me and my editor.

What?

Oh. Did I say that this software is called a “Widget”? No, no: it’s a “Robot.” 
Damn and blast. Well, I mean, it’s a day later and I’m at lunch with somebody 
besides. What can I do about it?



Well, I can get out my iPhone, open up my Wave client on the phone’s built-in 
web browser, and make the change. And come to think of it, I now have a really 
great screenshot of Wave in action. I drag it into the Wave right where I want 
it to appear.

My editor — who is still part of this particular Wave — sees it immediately in 
his Inbox.

Oh, and remember: the “put this on SunTimes.com” robot is part of the Wave. He 
sees that change, too. So my edits immediately reflected on the website. In 
fact, anybody who happened to have been reading the column at the time could 
see each of those changes being applied, at the very instant that I was making 
them, one at a time.

They can’t change the article themselves, of course (anarchy!) but there’s an 
unbroken pipeline between myself, my editor, and SunTimes.com.

Wave defines the standards, the architecture, and the mechanisms for making the 
above example happen. In fact, even the “Google Mail-like window” I described 
isn’t Wave. It’s merely the way that Google has implemented its own standards 
into something useful.

Once again: Wave is electricity, not illumination. It’s “communication” and not 
any one specific way of communicating anything to anybody.

I should mention that nothing in the above example was speculative, either. 
Everything you saw was stolen directly from Google’s presentation. In the demo, 
these features supported a very email-ey type of conversation between three 
people who were trying to pick a movie to see later that night, and a project 
team that needed to collaboratively write and assemble a company report. The 
fact that these same features and user interface could just as easily put 
content on the news site of a major newspaper shows you something about the 
scope of Wave.

It even forces you to adjust your definition of “communication.” While watching 
the presentation, I suddenly came to think of a chess game as nothing more than 
an interactive communication between two players which could easily be 
articulated as a Wave.

And almost as soon as I completed that thought, Google demonstrated a chess 
gadget. The wave contains a standard chess board. The game software is a bit of 
code located on a remote server; neither player needs to download and install 
anything. If the two players are both online at the same time, they can see 
pieces moving and react immediately. And if not? Well, when Sheldon gets back 
from lunch he sees that the Chess Game With Raj wave is now at the top of his 
Inbox, in bold … meaning that after three hours, Raj has finally made his next 
move.

Wave is hugely ambitious. Which means that it’s bound to fail.

But I’m betting that it’ll thrive. Wave is open and infinitely-extensible, and 
those are the two things it most needs to be.

Google says that they’re open-sourcing “the lion’s share” of the code that 
makes Wave services work, and they’re keeping no secrets about its standards.

Google will provide Google Wave services to everybody in much the same way they 
provide people with free Google Mail today. But just as you don’t need to rely 
on Google for email, you don’t need to rely on them for Wave services. If 
Yahoo! wants to add Wave services to their offerings, they’re be perfectly 
welcome to do so. If the Sun-Times wanted to have their own private Wave 
server, hosted by one of their own computers in their own office, that’s no 
problem, either. That would have been a stumbling block for many companies.

Communications between me and my editor — each of us with accounts on the 
Sun-Times’ Wave server — would never leave the building. And yet I’d still be 
able to communicate interactively with every other Wave user on the planet.

All of the mechanisms for expanding and enhancing Wave are also free and open. 
There aren’t any limits on what a web-based or Desktop client app can do. 
Conventional email, Twitter, Facebook, the responses you leave on blogs, and 
even voice mail can all be integrated into the Wave experience with the right 
third-party extensions. Your Aunt Estelle won’t have a clue that the email she 
sent you from her AOL account was read and replied to via Wave.

Mind you, integrating Wave with other communications services is just the dull 
stuff. Some of the real fire of the Google Wave demo video — the “grab the gun 
and the banner” moments — comes at the end. A guy is sharing a Wave with 
someone and having a live text conversation. A robot is automatically 
translating all of the text so that the English speaker and the French-speaker 
are seeing their own native languages. And the translation is happening while 
they type.

Onward, sons and daughters of the Motherland! Arise! Take arms, and … onward to 
… to …

(Sorry.)

Of course no one can say what will become of Wave when it’s rolled out to users 
sometime around the end of the summer. It could prove to be much less than the 
demo. Let’s not forget that the humans are a baffling and unpredictable species 
that doesn’t always know what’s best for itself.

Tuesday evening, NBC dropped the Stanley Cup finals for “I’m A Celebrity … Get 
Me Out Of Here!” to name but one example.

But all of the elements of success are here. Google isn’t the only company with 
the smarts to conceive of Wave, but it’s certainly the only company that can 
possibly pull off a revolution of this scale.

Microsoft could have thought of it. But they’d have argued internally about 
ways to monetize it. Apple could certainly have thought of it. But then they’d 
have argued internally about the need to keep the technology proprietary and to 
control and limit everything, including the future of the standard and the 
scope of what people are allowed to do with it.

Both companies would have ruined it. Google seems to be doing everything right. 
They’re defining Wave, but then they’re more or less letting go of it. The sole 
benefit that they seem to be retaining is their 18-month headstart on the rest 
of the developer community.

My hopes are high. Wave has the potential to be as familiar and well-known to 
the common user as TCP/IP, IMAP, or Java. These are technologies that you use 
each and every day in a hundred different ways even though you may never have 
heard those actual names before. All you know is that your email and your 
Amazon shopping cart and your Twitter feed are up and running. Why should you 
care about the underlying technology?

That’s exactly as it should be. Sophistication isn’t about a million beeping 
lights and the audible grinding of thick gears. It’s a system that Simply 
Works, and which makes you wonder just how the Humanity managed to get along 
for so many years without it.
***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to