FCC gives Broadband Over Power Line a second chance

The FCC, chastened by a court order, is once again suggesting standards 
for Access Broadband Over Power Lines. Can the Commission and BPL's ham 
radio critics meet each other halfway?

By Matthew Lasar
Ars Technica

July 19, 2009 9:00 PM CT

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2009/07/fcc-gives-broadband-over-power-lines-a-second-chance.ars


FCC gives Broadband Over Power Line a second chance

It's once more into the breach for the Federal Communications 
Commission's efforts to authorize Broadband Over Power Line technology. 
On Friday, the agency issued a new Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, asking 
for feedback on the power levels Access BPL systems should operate at so 
that they don't interfere with other services. The American Radio Relay 
League (ARRL) stopped this process dead in its tracks last year, having 
raised concerns about the transparency of the proceeding and BPL's 
potential for messing with ham radio signals and other bands. But the 
Commission is sticking to its guns, arguing that the technical standards 
it has already set may still be sufficient—at least, with a modification 
or two. BPL's critics "do not provide convincing information" that the 
FCC should change course, the NOPR says.


Third pipe dreams

Access BPL boosters say that transmitting broadband along electric power 
lines represents a potential "third pipe" alternative to cable and DSL. 
But the market for it has been slow to develop, and the ARRL took the 
FCC to court over its BPL plans in 2007, warning that the service could 
muck up neighboring transmissions (the League has a video demonstrating 
interference with a licensed ham radio signal from a demonstration 
roadside line along which BPL was active).

In April 2008, the DC Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of 
Columbia agreed with two of ARRL's complaints. First, the agency had 
heavily redacted its studies of potential BPL interference, to the point 
where there was "little doubt that the Commission deliberately attempted 
to 'exclude from the record evidence adverse to its position'," the 
appeals court declared. On top of that, the FCC had not sufficiently 
explained its rationale for the power/interference standards it established.

The redaction that ARRL protested was, well, a bit disturbing (our story 
about it here). The FCC says it touched up various documents "on the 
basis that they represented preliminary or partial results or staff 
opinions that were part of the internal deliberative process."

But that rationale didn't impress the court. For example, somebody at 
the agency whited out from a Powerpoint slide a sentence asserting that 
a tested BPL system was "not a point source." Why is that significant? 
Because BPLs are line sources, and critics charge that interference from 
line sources attenuates (or decays) more slowly than from point sources, 
such as local transmitters.


Power struggles

But now the FCC has dutifully released all its non-redacted BPL-related 
testing materials. And the Commission's NOPR is asking for feedback on 
the power levels it should authorize for Access BPL so that it doesn't 
radiate into other licensed services. Basically the issue here is that 
"extrapolation factor"—how quickly do BPL emissions decay at various 
levels of power strength, and thus pose less of an interference threat. 
A lower level of dB extrapolation per "decade" (distances measured via a 
factor of ten) means a slower rate of decay, meaning that the FCC should 
generally recommend tighter standards of emissions control for the service.

In the past, the Commission suggested using 40 dB per decade as the 
factor for frequencies under 30 MHz. ARRL has recommended cutting that 
number in half (20 dB), backing its arguments with three studies 
produced by the United Kingdom's OFCOM and one by the Comite 
International Special des Perturbations Radioelectriques (CISPER).

But the FCC says it questions the relevance of these studies, suggesting 
that they provide only "anecdotal information," insufficient to support 
"a statistically valid and comprehensive description of how BPL 
emissions attenuate over the short distances at which measurements are 
made." And the agency says more recent experiments validate its 
recommendations.

On the other hand, the Commission says it is willing to meet the public 
halfway and possibly go with 30 dB per decade, even though this could 
"increase the compliance burden for BPL equipment." The question is now 
open for public response. "We request comment on the suitability of an 
extrapolation factor lower than 40 dB per decade" as well as 
recommendations for how to test the technology, the FCC says. 
"Interested parties are invited to suggest alternative values for the 
extrapolation factor that would account for the variability of 
attenuation rates without unfairly burdening manufacturers of users of 
BPL equipment and systems."

It has taken a while for the FCC to return to this issue. The ARRL, in 
fact, filed yet another petition with the DC Court of Appeals in June, 
asking the Commission to get on the dime. Now the ball is back in ARRL's 
court to respond to the Commission's latest proposals. The comment cycle 
starts when the FCC publishes this notice in the Federal Register.


-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to