Only a matter of time before most books are read digitally

By Larry Magid
San Jose Mercury News

Posted: 07/17/2009 12:00:00 PM PDT

http://www.siliconvalley.com/opinion/ci_12852476


A day will come when only institutions and rich people buy new books. 
The rest of us will read them on some type of electronic device, like an 
Amazon Kindle, Sony Reader Digital Book or — more likely — a smart-phone.

I'm not sure when this day will come but when it does, it will be driven 
largely by economic and environmental concerns. But there is debate 
about why eBooks are better than paper ones.

To me, the biggest downside of eBooks isn't nostalgia for the feel and 
smell of paper. It's that — for now at least — it's not possible for 
Kindle owners to sell, give away or lend the books they purchase. And 
once almost all books are electronic, what will be the role of 
libraries? Will they be in a position to "lend" you copies of books to 
read on your electronic device?

For the most part, I'm bullish on Kindle. I've bought and read several 
books on an Amazon Kindle and both an iPhone and iPod touch using 
Amazon's free Kindle for iPhone app. In fact, the same book that you buy 
for one device can be read from another as long as you sign in from the 
same account. Better yet, if I start reading a book on the Kindle and 
later pick it up on the iPhone, the Kindle service knows where I left 
off and takes me to the right spot. And if you lose the device, the 
books are still there to download when you replace it.

The Kindle, whose price was just reduced from $359 to $299, is a 
book-like device with clear black text against a bright white 
background. Because you can change the size of the type, insert 
electronic bookmarks and search through the book, it's arguably a better 
experience than reading a paper book.

But I'm also pleased with reading books on an iPhone or iPod touch. Some 
people would argue that the iPhone screen is too small, but once I'm 
immersed in a book, I don't really care about the size of the screen, 
especially because it's so easy to go from page to page by just flicking 
the screen with your finger. Unlike the Kindle, the iPhone and iPod 
touch have a backlit screen that is readable in bright sunlight as well 
as in the dark. That's an advantage if you share a bedroom with someone 
who wants to sleep while you want to read.

The biggest advantage of any portable reading device is that you can 
have hundreds or even thousands of books with you at all times. Paper 
books are heavy but a Kindle is light and fits easily into a purse or 
briefcase. An iPhone or iPod fits into a pocket, and the big advantage 
to reading on an iPhone is that you have it with you at all times. That 
means you're never without reading material, even when you didn't expect 
to have a few minutes to read a book, like when you're sitting in a 
doctor's waiting room.

I'm bothered that Kindle books can't be loaned out or sold, but that is 
a solvable problem. The Northern California Digital Library 
(http://ncdl.lib.overdrive.com) has solved the lending problem for books 
that can be read on PCs and Macs, or audio books that can be listened to 
on computers or iPods.

Participating libraries purchase a limited number of "copies" that can 
be checked out for a specific period of time. If all are checked out, 
users put a hold on the next available copy just as they would do with 
physical media.

As far as I know there's no way to lend a Kindle book, although Brigham 
Young University experimented with lending out Kindle book readers with 
books on them. Unfortunately, BYU suspended the program until it hears 
from Amazon as to whether that's OK. "Being a library, we will follow 
the rules and until the rules are clear we will wait," university 
spokesman Rogen Layden told the Chronicle of Higher Education.

The University of Nebraska at Omaha has nine Kindles that it loans out 
to patrons. For awhile, there were funds to purchase books for patrons 
but the money ran out. Patrons can still borrow Kindles, but if the 
title they want isn't on it, they're out of luck.

It seems to me that libraries should be able to buy licenses for Kindle 
books and loan those out to patrons to read on borrowed Kindles or their 
own devices. And consumers should have the right to sell, lend or give 
away books or other media that they buy for the Kindle or any other device.

Technology is not the obstacle. It would be relatively easy for Amazon 
to come up with a way to let people transfer access to media from one 
account to another. But just because it can be done doesn't mean it will 
be done. As with all aspects of digital media, there are commercial 
interests to consider and powerful forces — like publishing companies 
and author groups — to be heard from.

As an author myself, I'm all for protecting the rights of copyright 
holders. But as a consumer I want the right to do whatever I want with 
the media I purchase.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to