[Let's hope there is some patent busting going on. The current software 
patent system is a significant barrier to innovation & progress. Patents 
for non-algorithmic software and so-called "business methods" patents 
have been a big mistake.]

August 6, 2009 8:39 AM PDT

Is Google's open-source advocacy a patent-busting scheme?

By Matt Asay
News.com

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13505_3-10304724-16.html?tag=newsBlogPromoArea.2


Open source means different things to different people. It can be a 
software development methodology, a distribution technique, or a 
marketing gimmick. Could it also be a way to minimize patent 
infringement damages?

Brian Prentice, a research vice president with Gartner's Emerging Trends 
and Technologies Group, speculates that it just might be. Google has 
been actively developing open-source alternatives to leading proprietary 
products, like Google Wave to compete with Microsoft Outlook and 
SharePoint. As Prentice indicates, Google has also been publicly 
advocating passage of the Patent Reform Act of 2009, which might have a 
lot to do with its open-source strategy.

Here's why.

The proposed legislation alters the way damages are calculated in 
infringement suits to be "calculated as the price of licensing a 
'similar non-infringing substitute in the relative market.'" Now if that 
alternative is a free, open-source piece of software, then damages drop 
to zero, as Prentice notes:

    Does that mean that free open source products can now be considered 
substitutes in a relative market? I've been trying to play the scenarios 
out in my head. If Google Wave, hypothetically, infringes a patent that 
IBM holds and they're found guilty of doing so, could they simply claim 
that the relative market value is zero because there are existing free 
OSS mail and IM solutions? Once Google Wave is shipping, can other 
organizations infringe on patents Microsoft holds relative to Exchange 
comfortable in the knowledge that Wave creates a zero dollar relative 
market value for collaboration?

This is incredibly insightful on Prentice's part, and amazingly shrewd 
if, in fact, Google is playing this game. It takes open-source advocacy 
to an entirely new, Sun T'zu-esque plane.

Martin Fink of Hewlett-Packard first started talking about the value of 
using open source to commoditize a competitor's core offering through 
open source back in his 2002 book "The Business and Economics of Open 
Source." But Prentice's idea takes Fink's argument and runs with it...at 
Usain Bolt speeds.

If true, The Register's question--"Is Google spending $106.5m to open 
source a codec?"--calls up a different response than the author of that 
article gives. Maybe $106 million is cheap compared to the cost of 
getting hit with video compression patent suits (from Microsoft, Apple, 
and others), if Google open source's On2's video compression codecs.

Google contributes to open source for a variety of reasons, not the 
least reason being that it recognizes open source is an efficient way to 
create community around its products. But perhaps Google has this more 
subtle, and sophisticated, reason as well?

Brilliant.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to