http://www.boston.com/business/technology/innoeco/2009/08/does_harry_potter_belong_at_bo.html

Events
Does Harry Potter Belong at Boston's Museum of Science?

Posted by skirsner August 17, 2009 09:48 PM

At the Museum of Science on Sunday evening, I overheard a family 
talking excitedly about the "Harry Potter" exhibit that's coming in 
October. They were from California, and they joked that they might 
have to plan another trip to Boston to see it.

Clearly, the Museum of Science has struck a pop culture chord by 
inviting the young wizard and his friends to the Hub for a four-month 
stay.

J.K. Rowling's books have done a great deal: they've motivated and 
inspired millions of young readers, and they've created a fantasy 
world that plenty of adults have wanted to enter. Many of the Warner 
Brothers-made Harry Potter movies have been extremely well done, and 
I'm looking forward to the opening of a vast theme park experience at 
Universal Studios in Orlando next year.

But there's something about spells and potions, witchcraft and 
wizardry, Philosopher's stones and dark arts, that feels retrograde 
and anti-science to me.

I want to be clear: I'm not against Harry in any way, or the idea 
that fantasy is an important part of our culture. But what does magic 
have to do with science?

Magic is about incantations and wand-waving that summon supernatural 
forces to make something mysterious and amazing happen. Science is 
about understanding the rules of the natural world, and how they can 
be used to make amazing things happen. My air conditioning this 
morning is not powered by magical incantations: there is a power 
plant somewhere, and an electrical distribution infrastructure, that 
is powering the fans and compressors that blow cool air in and hot 
air out.

I called up Paul Fontaine, the museum's vice president of education, 
to find out how much educational value there will be in the exhibit.

Fontaine told me that there was "huge competition for this exhibit," 
which is now on display at Chicago's venerable Museum of Science & 
Industry, and will only come to about a half-dozen U.S. cities. 
"Boston is the northeast premiere," he said, sounding a bit like a 
movie mogul.

"There's no escaping that popular culture is popular," Fontaine said, 
arguing that the exhibit will attract people to the museum from a 
wide range of backgrounds, some of whom may never have visited before.

I asked Fontaine if he'd seen the comments on this Boston.com blog 
post about the exhibit. (Among them: "The only science behind this is 
economics" and "Could a creationist or intelligent design exhibit be 
far behind?") He acknowledged that they contained "some real concern 
about why is this at a science museum."

Fontaine noted that they've done lots of exhibits linked to pop 
culture, from "Star Wars" to "CSI" to superheroes to "Lord of the 
Rings." The museum designed the "Star Wars" exhibit itself, which 
focused on the science of magnetic levitation vehicles and the 
engineering that goes into robots and prosthetic devices. The "Lord 
of the Rings" exhibit came from a New Zealand museum, and delved into 
the ways digital imagery was used to create the realistic-looking 
fantasy realms of those films. The "CSI" exhibit came from the Fort 
Worth Science Museum, and explored how forensic science is used to 
solve crimes.

The Harry Potter exhibit, on the other hand, was created by Warner 
Bros. Consumer Products and Becker Group, an "experiential marketing 
company" in Baltimore that "turns incredible brands into 
unforgettable experiences."

Fontaine said the exhibit will focus on what it takes to tranfer J.K. 
Rowling's fantasy world from the pages of a book onto the silver 
screen. The exhibit includes lots of costumes and props and models 
that were used to make the movies' monsters. But when I asked 
Fontaine if the exhibit gets into the process of computer-generated 
special effects, he said it doesn't. "It's weighted more towards the 
artifacts from the films, but there's a good dose of answers about 
how they created a character that looked a certain way, or a scene 
that looked a certain way."

According to the exhibit's elaborate official Web site, "guests will 
get an up close and personal look at the artistry and craftsmanship 
that went into creating the iconic props and costumes that appeared 
throughout the Harry Potter films."

But Fontaine said that the exhibit will be supplemented with live 
presentations and lectures about how movie magic is made, as well as 
introductions to the live animals that are featured in the films, 
from owls to rats to ferrets.

Tickets to the Harry Potter exhibit will cost $26 for adults and $23 
for kids (an audio tour is an additional $5), but the price includes 
admission to the rest of the museum which visitors can use on the 
same day -- or anytime within the next six months.

Yes, Fontaine told me, "it's fair to say we're expecting some lines."

Fontaine said he hopes that skeptics will "give us the benefit of the 
doubt and come experience [the exhibit]." The museum "takes its 
mission seriously, and we think you can take pop culture and make it 
relevant to science and technology and engineering."

What do you think?

Is the magical world of Harry Potter compatible with what we're 
trying to teach at a science museum? Is the exhibit simply a powerful 
way to get people into the museum, at which point they might be 
exposed to other exhibits? Or is it an economic necessity that will 
buoy the museum's finances in challenging economic times?

(One more note: it's interesting that there's another Harry Potter 
exhibit, this one developed by the National Library of Medicine [part 
of the National Institutes of Health], that seems much more 
science-oriented, if not nearly as flashy. This exhibit points out 
that "...the magic in the Harry Potter books is partially based on 
Renaissance traditions that played an important role in the 
development of Western science, including alchemy, astrology, and 
natural philosophy.")


***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to