SEPTEMBER 16, 2009 New Online Music Service Drums Up Listeners but Not Many Want to Pay
By PAUL SONNE Wall Street Journal http://online.wsj.com/article/SB125306304997114345.html LONDON -- Since the 1960s "British Invasion," plenty of music-industry success stories have started in the U.K. before hopping the Atlantic to the U.S. Now an online music service based in England wants to join the list -- if it can overcome obstacles that have tripped up similar companies. Spotify Ltd. allows users to listen -- free -- from a catalog of more than six million songs, with a 20- to 30-second audio ad interrupting every 20 minutes. Or, for a small price, paying subscribers can listen to music with higher sound quality and no ads. The service has become available in six European countries since its launch in Sweden 11 months ago. It has registered more than five million users, who tune in for an average 72 minutes a day. Daniel Ek, co-founder of the London-based company, says Spotify's simple user interface has been the key to its success so far. [turn it up] "No matter if you are a 55-year-old or a 15-year-old, Spotify is fast and it's easy, and everyone can understand it," Mr. Ek says. Whereas other companies stream songs over Web sites, Spotify delivers music through a downloadable application that looks and feels a lot like Apple Inc.'s iTunes -- without requiring users buy the music. Listeners can choose any of the available tracks on demand and jump to any point in a song. Now, Spotify hopes to launch by year's end in two huge, but vastly different, markets -- the U.S. and China. But a number of factors are fueling skepticism about its prospects, particularly in the U.S., where it is in the midst of securing licensing deals with the major music labels. Chief among the concerns: Similar services have tried and failed to crack the market for streamed online music, unable to generate either sufficient advertisers to support free content or enough consumers willing to pay a monthly fee. The major labels remain skeptical of Spotify's business model. That said, with CD sales sinking and piracy rampant, music companies have become more willing to partner with ad-supported, free music sites that were once anathema to industry executives. The major record labels in Europe have negotiated rights deals with Spotify, including Sony Corp.'s Sony Music Entertainment, Vivendi SA's Universal Music Group, Warner Music Group Corp. and EMI Group Ltd. Some labels have equity stakes in Spotify, said people familiar with the matter. But in the U.S., Spotify will compete with a more crowded market of companies including Pandora Media Inc., AOL Music, MySpace Music and Imeem Inc., all of which offer streamed digital music, but none of which have had break-out success. Another contender, SpiralFrog Inc., went belly-up in March. (MySpace is owned by News Corp., which also owns The Wall Street Journal.) To make it in the U.S., Spotify must not only find advertisers for its free service, it must migrate between 5% and 10% of its users to the premium service, said Mark Mulligan, vice president of Forrester Research Inc. "A lot of consumers out there don't see this as anything other than a way to get free music," said Russ Crupnick, vice president of research firm NPD Group. So far, the operation is unprofitable and buttressed largely by venture capital, including a recent investment from the foundation of Hong Kong billionaire Li Ka-shing. Spotify says it will turn a profit by early 2010. Despite the buzz around Spotify, most users forage on the free content and are loathe to pay for extras. By most estimates, almost all Spotify listeners stick with the company's free service, and don't pay for the premium offerings. Mark McCormick, 25, a graphic designer from Newcastle, signed up for Spotify's free service about three months ago and now listens about five hours a day at work and at home. "About three minutes after signing up, you are listening to almost anything you want," he said. Though he isn't keen on the advertising, he doesn't want to sign up for the premium service, because he says £120 ($199) per year is a steep price. Mr. Ek hopes that mobility will be the tool that changes users' minds. Last month, Apple approved Spotify's iPhone application -- but only people who sign up for the premium service can use it. For £10 ($16.50) a month in the U.K. and an as-yet undetermined price in the U.S. the application will allow subscribers to stream any of Spotify's songs through their iPhones, organize playlists and cache up to 3,333 tracks for playback when Internet service is unavailable. For now, Spotify has to balance its growth with the fees it pays per song. After a surge in user demand that threatened to trigger massive royalty fees, Spotify last week reverted to an invitation-only model for customers in the U.K., the same model it plans to use initially in the U.S. -- ================================ George Antunes, Political Science Dept University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927 Mail: antunes at uh dot edu *********************************** * POST TO [email protected] * *********************************** Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
