OCTOBER 30, 2009, 2:07 P.M. ET Beware of Comcast's Appetite for NBC Universal
By MARTIN PEERS Wall Street Journal http://online.wsj.com/article/SB125692190161618957.html?ru=yahoo&mod=yahoo_hs Beware of media CEOs bearing deals. Comcast shareholders should brace themselves for the likelihood that the cable operator will strike a deal in coming weeks to buy control of NBC Universal. Comcast has its work cut out to convince investors it's a good idea. After all, there are no significant synergies available from combining control of a cable operator and an entertainment empire. And it will be difficult for Comcast to use NBCU to advance its own strategic priorities such as changing movie-release patterns in favor of cable video-on-demand (VOD) services. Getting Universal Studios to make its movies available on VOD earlier won't do much to help Comcast's service unless other studios join in. If it makes business sense, they will -- and they have already given some ground on this issue. Meanwhile, anything Comcast does that favors its cable operations at the expense of NBCU would likely be resisted by GE, which is expected to retain a 49% stake in NBCU for several years. Theoretically, Comcast could try and improve NBC's financial fortunes by agreeing to pay to carry the broadcaster's signal on its cable systems. But that would make little sense. Comcast only serves about a quarter of TV subscribers. The other cable operators won't agree to pay just because of Comcast. What's more, because Comcast will only own 51% of NBCU initially, it would enjoy only half the value uplift for NBCU resulting from any fees it pays. And if it starts paying NBC, it will face pressure from the other broadcast networks for similar deals -- escalating the cost. Without synergies, deal price is even more crucial. Yet reports suggest the deal would value NBCU at around $28 billion. If that holds true, it would be roughly a 27% premium to the $21-23 billion value put on NBCU by Sanford Bernstein in mid-September, using publicly-traded comparables. Comcast would get its stake partly by contributing assets at inflated prices, of course, but it would also put up cash. Still unclear are the terms under which GE would sell its remaining 49%. Comcast shareholders should hope it isn't a fixed-price put option but one based on future market values. What's more, the deal could prove a distraction for management, weakening Comcast's focus on its core business. On top of everything, regulators are likely to load conditions onto approval. Comcast CEO Brian Roberts is undoubtedly aware of all this. Even without synergies, NBCU's lucrative cable channel business has attractions. The deal would reduce Comcast's exposure to pure distribution. But perhaps the NBCU adventure demonstrates a divergence of shareholder interests. If outside investors want to diversify they can simply buy stock in entertainment companies. For the Roberts family, such a goal requires diversifying Comcast itself. -- ================================ George Antunes, Political Science Dept University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927 Mail: antunes at uh dot edu *********************************** * POST TO [email protected] * *********************************** Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
