Racy MySpace pics spark school lawsuit
Summer vacation lingerie-and-lollipop photos were posted on MySpace

The Associated Press

updated 3:39 p.m. CT, Fri., Oct . 30, 2009

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/33554218/ns/us_news-education/


INDIANAPOLIS - Two sophomore girls have sued their school district after 
they were punished for posting sexually suggestive photos on MySpace 
during their summer vacation.

The American Civil Liberties Union, in a federal lawsuit filed last week 
on behalf of the girls, argues that Churubusco High School violated the 
girls' free speech rights when it banned them from extracurricular 
activities for a joke that didn't involve the school. They say the 
district humiliated the girls by requiring them to apologize to an 
all-male coaches' board and undergo counseling.

Some child advocates argue that schools should play a role in monitoring 
students' behavior, especially when dealing with minors. And the U.S. 
Supreme Court has ruled that students can be disciplined for activities 
that happen outside of school, so long as the school can prove the 
activities were disruptive or posed a danger and that it was foreseeable 
the activities would find their way to campus.

But some legal experts say that in this digital era, schools must accept 
that students will engage in some questionable behavior in cyberspace 
and during off hours.

"From the standpoint of young people, there's no real distinction 
between online life and offline life," said John Palfrey, a Harvard 
University law professor and co-director of the Berkman Center for 
Internet and Society. "It's just life."

'Disruptive influence'
In the Indiana case, the ACLU argues that the district and Churubusco 
Principal Austin Couch went too far in banning the two sophomores from 
fall sports, requiring them to apologize to the all-male coaches' board 
and undergo counseling after the photographs were circulated at school.

The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court in Fort Wayne, names Couch, 
the high school and the district as defendants and seeks unspecified 
damages. No hearing has been scheduled.

Erik Weber, an attorney for the Smith-Green school district, said Couch 
was enforcing the northeast Indiana school's athletic code, which allows 
the principal to bar from school activities any student-athlete whose 
behavior in or out of school "creates a disruptive influence on the 
discipline, good order, moral or educational environment at Churubusco 
High School."

Martha McCarthy, who teaches educational law and policy at Indiana 
University, said courts have upheld such policies, but that the issue 
could come to a head as advances in technology bring more out-of-school 
behavior issues to light.

"I think the Supreme Court's going to have to address this," she said.

ACLU legal director Ken Falk insists the Churubusco case doesn't warrant 
the punishment the district handed out.

"We all did things when we were sophomores in high school that can be 
construed as immature or problematic or whatever, but that is not the 
issue here," he said. "The issue is what possible impact this could have 
on the school environment, and the answer is none."

Summer sleepover
The girls, identified only by their initials in the suit, took the 
photos during a sleepover with friends before school started this summer 
and posted them on their MySpace pages, setting the privacy controls so 
only those designated as friends could view them. In the photos, the 
girls wore lingerie and pretended to lick a penis-shaped lollipop. None 
of the photos made any reference to the school.

Weber declined to say how the photos reached Couch, but the suit 
contends that someone copied the pictures and shared them with school 
officials, and they eventually were given to the principal.

Couch initially suspended both girls from all extracurricular activities 
for the year but reduced the penalty to 25 percent of fall semester 
activities after the girls completed three counseling sessions and 
apologized to the coaches board.

Palfrey, the Harvard professor, said privacy on social networking sites 
is an illusion, even if strict privacy controls are set.

Rick Hills, a New York University School of Law professor, said most 
courts have found that simply being able to access questionable material 
on campus is generally not sufficient proof that an activity was 
disruptive. But he acknowledged courts have a long tradition of 
deferring to administrative agencies that make their own rules.

No privacy in cyberspace?
Teens who have done similar things in some states have faced 
prosecution, said Beverly Johnson, an Irvine, Calif., attorney who 
serves on the board of Web Wise Kids, a nonprofit, online safety group. 
A 14-year-old New Jersey girl was arrested on child pornography charges 
in March for posting nude pictures of herself on MySpace. The charges 
were later dropped after she agreed to counseling.

Other students have been expelled from school or lost scholarships, 
Johnson said.

The ACLU argues that the Indiana case is different. They say the photos 
were a joke intended to be shared only with friends. It wants the school 
district to expunge all references to the incident from school records 
and seeks to bar the school from taking similar action in the future.

"The problem is there's a line drawn. And the line is drawn as things 
that disrupt the school. And outside of that, the school has no say," 
Falk said.

"Imagine if everything teens texted back and forth to friends became 
fodder for school discipline."

Palfrey, of Harvard, said schools have a right to regulate students' 
online behavior but said the court will have to decide whether the 
students' First Amendment rights were violated.

"The fact that it took place in cyberspace instead of in a classroom 
doesn't mean you don't enforce the rule," he said.


URL: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/33554218/ns/us_news-education/

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to