November 1, 2009

Everybody in the Pool of Green Innovation
By MARY TRIPSAS
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/01/business/01proto.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


A POPULAR children’s song has a refrain — “the more we get together the 
happier we’ll be” — that may sound like a simplistic formula for solving 
the complex challenges of climate change and sustainability. But if any 
area is ripe for sharing and collaboration among organizations, it’s 
green innovation.

“We all want to save the planet, and the problems are bigger than any 
one firm, sector or country,” says Dr. Sarah Slaughter, coordinator of 
the M.I.T. Sloan Sustainability Initiative. In that spirit, several 
major corporations have taken inspiration from the open-source software 
movement and are experimenting with forums for sharing environmentally 
friendly innovations and building communities around them. The first 
such effort, the Eco-Patent Commons, was started in January 2008 by 
I.B.M., Nokia, Pitney Bowes and Sony in collaboration with the World 
Business Council for Sustainable Development.

The concept is straightforward: Companies pledge environmental patents 
to the commons, and anyone can use them — free.

Many patented environmental technologies are not strategic, so sharing 
maximizes the social benefit without sacrificing competitive advantage, 
says Wayne Balta, vice president of corporate environmental affairs and 
product safety at I.B.M. For instance, I.B.M. contributed a recyclable 
cardboard packaging insert that requires less fossil fuel to create and 
transport than the foam inserts that are now commonly used.

Other examples include a DuPont method for better detecting pollution in 
soil, air or water by using a microorganism that produces light when 
exposed to a pollutant. There are also methods from Xerox for removing 
toxic waste from contaminated groundwater, as well as a cleaning 
technique for semiconductor wafers from I.B.M. that uses ozone gas and 
eliminates chemical contaminants that result from other processes.

By assembling these patents in one easily accessible location — anyone 
can search through them on the council’s Web site — the hope is to 
encourage their widespread adoption, particularly in the developing 
world. Since its start, the commons has grown to 100 patents from 31, 
with 11 companies now participating.

Although there are no formal mechanisms for tracking who has used the 
commons, participating companies are sometimes contacted by users. For 
instance, Mr. Balta said that Yale had put into effect an I.B.M. method 
for decreasing the use of hazardous solvents in its quantum computing 
device research.

The Creative Commons, a nonprofit organization that previously developed 
licensing programs to help in sharing creative and scientific content, 
is also planning to branch out into the environmental arena.

In collaboration with Nike and Best Buy, it plans to start a sharing 
initiative, the Green Xchange, in early 2010. The program will include 
both patented technologies and forums for continuing exchange of 
innovations such as Best Buy’s system for rating the sustainability of a 
supply chain. Companies that contribute patents to the Green Xchange 
will have the option of charging users a fixed annual licensing fee and 
can also restrict any licensing by rivals or for competitive use. In 
addition, even if no annual fee is charged, patent users must register 
so there is a record of who is using what technology.

Though more complex than that of Eco-Patent Commons, the structure of 
Green Xchange will yield greater numbers of high-quality inventions, 
says John Wilbanks, GreenXchange coordinator and vice president for 
science at Creative Commons.

“We don’t depend on altruism,” Mr. Wilbanks says. “This system helps the 
environment while enabling a firm to make money from patents in 
applications outside its core business.”

For instance, Nike’s air-bag patent for cushioning shoes is crucial to 
its core shoe business, but may have environmental benefits in other 
industries — perhaps in prolonging the useful life of tires. Green 
Xchange could enable Nike to license the air-bag technology selectively 
to noncompeting companies.

ACCORDING to Kelly Lauber, a global director in Nike’s Sustainable 
Business and Innovation Lab, sharing technology can have tremendous 
environmental impact. By sharing its water-based adhesive technology and 
working with footwear makers, Ms. Lauber estimates that average levels 
of environmentally harmful solvents used by Nike’s suppliers have 
decreased to less than 15 grams per pair of shoes from 350 in 1997.

Perhaps the biggest upside of Green Xchange may come from the 
development of communities that collaborate in innovation and the 
exchange of ideas. To encourage that kind of interaction, Salesforce.com 
will provide a search engine, making it easy to find patents. And 
collaboration platforms from companies like 2degrees and nGenera should 
make it easy to identify companies with common interests.

Despite the obvious advantages, sharing patents isn’t as easy as it 
might sound.

“Numerous features of the intellectual property system, particularly the 
ability of companies to claim large swaths of technology through 
patents, play havoc with collaborative efforts,” says Josh Lerner, a 
professor at Harvard Business School.

Henry Chesbrough, the executive director of the Center for Open 
Innovation at the University of California, Berkeley, says it is 
surprisingly hard to give away technologies. “If it is not done 
carefully,” he said, “the companies that use a donated technology might 
find themselves liable for infringement of another company’s patent.”

Both the Eco-Patent Commons and the Green Xchange pose organizational 
challenges for participating companies.

“Deciding which patents to pledge or license to a commons,” says Andrew 
King, a professor at the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth, “requires 
that the legal counsel, R.& D. staff, business unit and corporate 
sustainability groups all work together, and most organizations just 
aren’t set up for that.”

Weaving corporate togetherness, it seems, isn’t so easy — though green 
innovations offer many more reasons to try.

------------------
Mary Tripsas is an associate professor in the entrepreneurial management 
unit at the Harvard Business School.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to