November 14, 2009

More Than Ever, You Can Say That on Television
By EDWARD WYATT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/14/business/media/14vulgar.html?_r=1&hp=&pagewanted=print


LOS ANGELES — On many nights this fall, it has been possible to tune in 
to broadcast network television during prime time and hear a character 
call someone else a “douche.”

In just the last several weeks, it has happened on CBS’s “The New 
Adventures of Old Christine” and the CW’s “The Vampire Diaries,” which 
are broadcast at 8 p.m., during what used to be known as the family 
hour. It has been heard this fall on Fox’s new series “The Cleveland 
Show,” which begins at 8:30, and on ABC’s “Grey’s Anatomy.” On NBC, its 
use has spanned the old and the new, blurted out on the freshman comedy 
“Community” and the seasoned drama “Law & Order: Special Victims Unit.”

In total, the word has surfaced at least 76 times already this year on 
26 prime-time network series, according to research by the Parents 
Television Council, which compiled the statistics at the request of The 
New York Times. That is up from 30 uses on 15 shows in all of 2007 and 
just six instances on four programs in 2005.

Ever since George Carlin laid out the “Seven Words You Can Never Say on 
Television” in 1972, television writers and broadcasters have been 
digging more deeply into the thesaurus, seizing on new ways to 
titillate, if not offend. And while the word “douche” is neither obscene 
nor profane — although this usage is certainly offensive to many people 
— it seems to represent the latest of broadcast television’s continuing 
efforts to expand the boundaries of taste, in part to stem the tide of 
defections by its audience to largely unregulated cable television.

As a result, words that previously were rarely heard on television 
suddenly turn up everywhere, while once unspeakable slurs become passé 
from overuse. The use of the word, “bitch,” for example, tripled in the 
last decade alone, growing to 1,277 uses on 685 shows in 2007 from 431 
uses on 103 prime-time episodes in 1998.

The Parents Television Council is a conservative interest group that 
monitors (and opposes) profanity on television, but television writers 
themselves acknowledge that the language on networks has changed.

“As a writer, you’re always reaching for a more potent way to call 
somebody a jerk,” Dan Harmon, the creator of “Community,” said about the 
word “douche.” “This is a word that has evolved in the last couple of 
years — a thing that sounds like a thing you can’t say.”

It is not simply that the language is becoming more raw on broadcast 
networks but that the language, violence and sex that formerly was 
restricted to the 10 p.m. hour has migrated to earlier time slots.

Recent research by Barbara K. Kaye of the University of Tennessee and 
Barry S. Sapolsky of Florida State University found that in 2005 
television viewers were more likely to hear offensive language during 
the 8 p.m. and 9 p.m. hours than at 10 p.m. Technically, there has not 
been a “family hour” since 1976, when the United States Supreme Court 
struck down the imposition of such a policy by the Federal 
Communications Commission. But broadcast networks observed the practice 
long after that.

No more, it seems. At a symposium sponsored last summer by a group of 40 
national advertisers known as the Alliance for Family Entertainment, the 
heads of the major networks said the idea of a family hour was 
antiquated and did not fit how families consume television today. Nina 
Tassler, the president of CBS Entertainment, commented that shows like 
her network’s “Old Christine” “merely reflect a different family dynamic.”

That dynamic includes the frequent use of profanities — broadly defined 
as anything from sexual and excretory words to milder words like “hell.” 
Ms. Kaye and Mr. Sapolsky found that their use on broadcast prime-time 
television jumped from a rate of 5.5 times an hour in 1990 to 7.6 in 
2001 and 9.8 in 2005.

While the fastest growth was in the use of the stronger words, the term 
“jackass” has gained favor recently, appearing in 34 family-hour shows 
so far this year, up from 31 in 2007 and 27 in 2005. Other words have 
come in and out of favor: “sucks,” for example, appeared in 226 
family-hour episodes in 2005, fell to 120 in 2007 and rose again to 232 
so far this year, according to the council’s research.

The only time in recent years that the instance of profanity briefly 
declined, Ms. Kaye said, was in 1997, shortly after television ratings 
were put into place. Network officials say they continue to pay great 
attention to broadcast standards.

“We are still in the line-drawing business,” said Martin D. Franks, 
executive vice president for planning, policy and government relations 
at the CBS Corporation. “We may not have a formal family hour at 8 
o’clock, but we are trying to be respectful of our audience and who 
makes up our audience at a particular time of day.”

Not everyone in the business agrees. Neal Baer, an executive producer of 
“Law & Order: Special Victims Unit,” said that because the series was 
repeated in syndication and on cable at all times of the day, the 
producers could not worry about what time something was going to be 
viewed. “It’s hypocritical to say that you have to have shows on 
broadcast networks at 10 but they run at 3 or 4 or 5 in the afternoon on 
cable,” Mr. Baer said. “Kids have access to cable.”

Users of the recently popular word “douche” defend its use, noting that 
it was invoked, usually with the suffix “bag,” in the 1990s by the 
character Andy Sipowicz on “NYPD Blue,” an ABC series that frequently 
pushed the boundaries of network acceptability.

Timothy Jay, a psychology professor at the Massachusetts College of 
Liberal Arts and the author of “Cursing in America,” said the word has 
evolved to the point where it has lost much of its offensiveness. 
“Vulgar slang has a way of waxing and waning, where we become 
desensitized to a word’s earlier meanings,” he said. “I would bet most 
kids today couldn’t tell you what a douche bag is.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to