November 14, 2009

Terms of Digital Book Deal With Google Revised
By BRAD STONE and MIGUEL HELFT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/14/technology/internet/14books.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


SAN FRANCISCO — Google and groups representing book publishers and 
authors filed a modified version of their controversial books settlement 
with a federal court on Friday. The changes would pave the way for other 
companies to license Google’s vast digital collection of copyrighted 
out-of-print books, and might resolve Google’s conflicts with European 
governments.

The settlement, for a 2005 lawsuit over Google’s ambitious plan to 
digitize books from major American libraries, outlined a plan to create 
a comprehensive database of in-print and out-of-print works. But the 
original agreement, primarily between Google, the Authors Guild and the 
Association of American Publishers, drew much criticism.

The Justice Department and others said Google was potentially violating 
copyright law, setting itself up to unfairly control access to 
electronic versions of older books and depriving authors and their heirs 
of proper compensation.

The revisions to the settlement primarily address the handling of 
so-called orphan works, the millions of books whose rights holders are 
unknown or cannot be found. The changes call for the appointment of an 
independent fiduciary, or trustee, who will be solely responsible for 
decisions regarding orphan works.

The trustee, with Congressional approval, can grant licenses to other 
companies who also want to sell these books, and will oversee the pool 
of unclaimed funds that they generate. If the money goes unclaimed for 
10 years, according to the revised settlement, it will go to 
philanthropy and to an effort to locate rights holders. In the original 
settlement, unclaimed funds reverted to known rights holders after five 
years.

The changes also restrict the Google catalog to books published in the 
United States, Britain, Australia or Canada. That move is intended to 
resolve objections from the French and German governments, which 
complained that the settlement did not abide by copyright law in those 
countries.

The revised settlement could make it easier for other companies to 
compete with Google in offering their own digitized versions of older 
library books because it drops a provision that was widely interpreted 
as ensuring that no other company could get a better deal with authors 
and publishers than the one Google had struck.

“We’re disappointed that we won’t be able to provide access to as many 
books from as many countries through the settlement as a result of our 
modifications, but we look forward to continuing to work with 
rightsholders from around the world to fulfill our longstanding mission 
of increasing access to all the world’s books,” the engineering director 
for Google Book Search, Dan Clancy, wrote in a blog post on the 
company’s Web site.

In the next week, Judge Denny Chin of the United States District Court 
for the Southern District of New York is expected to set a date for a 
fairness hearing, where arguments from both sides will be heard about 
whether or not to approve the settlement.

The changes have not placated all opponents of the original settlement. 
In a blog post on Friday night, the Open Book Alliance, a coalition 
whose members include Yahoo, Microsoft and Amazon, referred to the 
changes as a “sleight of hand” and said they did not address the 
“fundamental flaws” addressed by critics.

“This settlement remains a set-piece designed to serve the private 
commercial interests of Google and its partners,” wrote Peter Brantley, 
co-founder of the alliance.

But the parties are hoping they will placate the concerns raised by the 
Justice Department, which in September asked a federal judge to reject 
the original $125 million agreement. While the decision on whether to 
approve the deal will be in the hands of Judge Chin, the Justice 
Department’s opinion is an important factor.

Gina Talamona, a spokeswoman for the Justice Department, said that the 
department would review the filing, and that its investigation into 
possible anticompetitive practices involving the rights to digital books 
was continuing.

Google and its partners had hailed the original agreement, signed in 
October 2008, as a public good. They said it would allow Google to 
create an immense digital library that would expand access to millions 
of out-of-print books, while creating new ways for authors and 
publishers to profit from digital versions of their works.

Google’s library would be searchable online, and users would have free 
access to 20 percent of the text in each book. Google would also sell 
subscriptions to the entire collection to universities and other 
institutions. Every public library in the United States would be able to 
offer its patrons free access to the full collection at one terminal. 
Users would be able to buy access to full texts at home. Google, authors 
and publishers would split all revenue generated through the system.

As part of the settlement, Google would pay to establish a Books Rights 
Registry, to be run by representatives of authors and publishers, that 
would administer payments.

But earlier this year, academics, legal scholars and some librarians 
expressed concern that the settlement would grant Google a virtual 
monopoly over orphan works, making it nearly impossible for anyone else 
to build a comprehensive digital library. Some librarians feared that 
without competition, Google would be free to raise prices arbitrarily.

Other critics said the agreement turned copyright law on its head by 
granting Google the license to profit from works unless rights holders 
objected. Some argued that orphan works authors and foreign authors were 
not properly represented by the Authors Guild. The proposed settlement 
prompted several hundred filings with the court, the vast majority 
opposing all or parts of the deal.

In a Sept. 18 filling, the Justice Department echoed many of the 
concerns. While saying that the settlement provided many benefits, it 
urged Judge Chin to reject it, saying it raised antitrust, class-action 
and copyright issues. But the Justice Department also encouraged the 
parties to work to modify the agreement to salvage its benefits and 
overcome its problems.

The Justice Department filing prompted the parties to withdraw the 
original agreement and revise it.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to