November 15, 2009

At Bloomberg, Modest Strategy to Rule the World
By STEPHANIE CLIFFORD and JULIE CRESWELL
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/15/business/media/15bloom.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


PLOPPED in a white leather chair in a small office in Bloomberg L.P.’s 
Manhattan headquarters, Andrew Lack knows exactly how to articulate the 
aspirations of this 28-year-old media and technology company.

“We want to be the world’s most influential news organization,” says Mr. 
Lack, who oversees Bloomberg’s television, radio and dot-com endeavors.

Very clear. The most influential. On the planet.

It’s a goal several other Bloomberg executives have already mentioned to 
a pair of visitors. And when Mr. Lack, 62, a former head of NBC News, 
hears his guests wonder if something funny is in his company’s coffee — 
a special sauce that keeps all Bloombergians marching so efficiently and 
effectively to the same tune — he looks a tad chagrined.

“Oh, my! I don’t want to sound as if I’m on message,” he says, laughing 
apprehensively while also sending a “help me” look to a Bloomberg 
spokeswoman nearby.

These days, truth be told, the entire company is on message. That’s 
because the data behemoth that Michael R. Bloomberg created and named 
after himself in 1981, long before he became mayor of New York, finally 
has the reach, resources and appetites to try snaring the mantle of Most 
Influential — at least in the rarefied world of business news.

After years of being an underdog pushing its troops to be better and 
faster, Bloomberg now has an upper hand. Publishing giants like Condé 
Nast, Time Inc. and The New York Times, with their veteran scribes and 
rich histories, have laid off people and scaled back. Bloomberg may lack 
the pedigree and gloss of some of its rivals, but it has one thing they 
don’t right now: money to throw around.

This year alone, Bloomberg, deploying the cash spouting from its data 
business, has recruited refugees from The Wall Street Journal and 
Fortune and opened bureaus in places like Ecuador and Abu Dhabi. Its 
editorial staff (which includes radio, TV and Web site workers) now 
numbers 2,200, compared with 1,250 journalists at The Times and 1,900 at 
Dow Jones (a figure that includes the newswires and the Journal staff).

When the 80-year-old BusinessWeek went on the block, Bloomberg opened 
its wallet and snatched it away from circling private equity firms in 
October for just $5 million in cash — a relatively small sum that still 
represents a big change. For the last decade, Bloomberg has barely 
bothered to venture outside the realm of high finance; its news was 
produced to help subscribers to its terminals make more money for 
themselves.

With BusinessWeek, likely to be renamed Bloomberg BusinessWeek, the 
company is setting its sights on a much broader audience. That includes 
Main Street readers and, much more important for Bloomberg, senior 
executives, government leaders and other global movers and shakers. It’s 
also trying to revamp its Web site and television programming — long 
neglected inside the company — into services that appeal to people who 
don’t trade securities for a living.

At a time when most media companies can barely pay for cake at 
going-away parties, Bloomberg appears to be rolling in dough.

Its headquarters, on the East Side, has the crystalline look and smooth 
textures of an airport terminal from the 22nd century. It has sleek, 
elegantly curved glass walls, outdoor patios, art installations hanging 
over escalators, fish tanks filled with exotic species and digital 
screens overhead that display the weather — with lightning flashes — and 
trading levels for the Nasdaq. Employees snack on free kiwis and 
pomegranates and gulp fancy sodas. The company even employs full-time 
bathroom attendants to wipe up errant droplets of water on the countertops.

Although Bloomberg, which is privately held, draws attention for its 
media ambitions, a vast majority of the company’s projected $6.3 billion 
in revenue — and nearly all of its profit — derives from financial 
information systems. These software packages, still known as “terminals” 
from when Bloomberg made the hardware, can be found on virtually all 
Wall Street trading desks, housing huge amounts of data and analytics, 
from price quotations for fixed-income and derivative products to 
complex risk analysis — making Bloomberg a live-on-Wall-Street, 
die-on-Wall-Street enterprise.

During the financial boom of the last two decades, Bloomberg terminals 
flew out the door. This year, for the first time in the company’s 
history, the number of installed terminals will fall, albeit modestly. 
Some analysts wonder whether the company’s fast-growth days could be 
behind it, spurring it to seek new ways to make money on Wall Street 
while upping the ante in its media game.

The time has come, company officials say, to move beyond a hard-core 
clientele of financial information hounds.

“We need a broader audience,” says Daniel L. Doctoroff, Bloomberg’s 
president. “The history of this company is you do the counterintuitive, 
countercyclical thing. It’s part of our DNA.”

IN an odd way, for all of Bloomberg’s new-media savvy, the company now 
finds itself trying to wedge old-media acquisitions and culture into a 
company built on speed, efficiency and digital technology.

Since emerging out of nowhere in 1981, Bloomberg now controls a third of 
the $16 billion global financial data market, according to year-end 2008 
numbers from Inside Market Data Reference, a research firm. (Thomson 
Reuters Markets controls another third, and a handful of smaller players 
jockey for the rest.)

Bloomberg got a strong hold on Wall Street in the ’90s, in part through 
its messaging capabilities, which allowed traders, long before e-mail 
was prevalent, to swap price information for securities that traded 
privately between brokers and buyers.

That was just the simple stuff. Wall Street gurus now use Bloomberg’s 
whiz-bang systems to graphically map their portfolios or to assess 
counterparty risk.

This operation accounts for 85 percent of Bloomberg’s revenue, and the 
focus is helping roughly 280,000 customers who each pay about $20,000 
annually to get millisecond head starts on pricing or market-moving 
headlines, as well as in-depth financial analysis.

During the recent, bubbly boom on Wall Street, from 2004 to 2007, 
Bloomberg’s revenue climbed an average of 13 percent annually, according 
to the company. But the financial crisis and the collapse of several 
companies that were large Bloomberg customers — Lehman Brothers alone 
had 3,500 terminals — has translated into a slowdown.

Revenue at Bloomberg is expected to grow around 3 percent this year, but 
the firm’s installed base of terminals will most likely be down about 2 
percent, says Mr. Doctoroff.

It’s unlikely that Bloomberg will have the same robust levels of growth 
it did during Wall Street’s boom years, Mr. Doctoroff acknowledges. “But 
the growth will still be meaningful,” he added. “We should see 
single-digit percentage growth in terminal units.”

These days, for instance, Bloomberg is looking for new revenue streams 
from trading and internal risk-management programs for Wall Street 
firms, says Thomas F. Secunda, who oversees Bloomberg’s financial products.

A slightly rumpled figure who liberally sprinkles the term “killer app” 
into conversations, Mr. Secunda met Mr. Bloomberg at Salomon Brothers, 
the onetime Wall Street bond-trading powerhouse, in the 1970s. (Mr. 
Bloomberg started his company with a $10 million severance check he 
received when he left Salomon.)

Though Mr. Bloomberg stepped back from the company when he became mayor 
in 2002, his fingerprints are still all over it. Mr. Doctoroff worked 
for him as a deputy mayor before joining the company, and Peter T. 
Grauer, the company’s chairman, met Mr. Bloomberg through their 
daughters’ horse-jumping competitions. Mr. Bloomberg, who owns 85 
percent of the company, was consulted on and approved the Merrill Lynch 
and BusinessWeek deals, Mr. Grauer says, as is allowed under the city’s 
conflict-of-interest guidelines.

Inside the company’s sleek headquarters is a buzzing collection of 
worker bees and brainiacs. Although Ph.D.’s in physics and math are 
hired to develop quantitative programs for the terminals, one of 
Bloomberg’s biggest challenges is getting customers to use those myriad 
applications. Many customers use only a small fraction of the machines’ 
30,146 functions.

On the hunt for new customers, Bloomberg is testing a Web-based product 
aimed at law firms. Executives are also looking at the sports arena, 
sussing out interest among team owners or even fantasy leagues for a 
system to analyze sports statistics.

Shoveling money into research for corporate customers thirsty for more 
information may prove to be a winning growth formula. But heads are 
definitely being scratched as Bloomberg invests more money in news — an 
industry that, by and large, is struggling mightily to merely stay 
afloat, much less find financial growth.

BLOOMBERG’S newsroom is so Sam’s-Club-warehouse-big that it needs 
guideposts for what each long aisle of editors and reporters covers: 
“Stocks,” “Emerging Markets,” Corporate Finance” and so on. On a recent 
morning, it was surprisingly quiet, with reporters speaking on their 
headsets and clacking away at multiple Bloomberg screens spreading 
horizontally across their desks.

In one corner, a signpost designates the “Speed Desk.” The members of 
this department — 200 people worldwide — spend their days spitting out 
headlines, in an effort to give subscribers a three-second lead that can 
mean a better price on a commodity or a stock.

Former employees complain that they often felt surveilled in the 
newsroom, and the place can still come across as something of a 
white-collar, digital sweatshop — terminals and ID cards, for example, 
closely monitor employees’ comings and goings. Still, that same rigid 
culture and disciplinary zeal have produced a formidable enterprise.

“We started with nothing when Bloomberg News began in 1990,” says 
Matthew Winkler, who, as editor in chief, has overseen the news 
operation from the beginning. “There was no pedigree, no platform, no 
reputation to speak of.”

For many years, Bloomberg viewed news as little more than an added 
service for Wall Street traders. To that end, Mr. Winkler demanded 
short, direct articles. He ordered reporters to avoid adverbs and 
adjectives, along with “but” and “however,” which he said muddled the 
clarity of sentences.

“I could write a Bloomberg earnings story in my sleep, because it’s the 
same formula for every single story,” says Chris Roush, a business 
journalism professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 
who worked at Bloomberg News in the late 1990s. “To a certain degree, 
the reporters there feel like their creativity is stifled because of that.”

Mr. Winkler’s reputation as a volatile manager also made recruiting 
more- seasoned talent a challenge. Nowadays, in interviews at least, he 
makes efforts to check his high-horsepower persona. Although he manages 
more journalists than almost any other editor in the business, Mr. 
Winkler, 54, still seems to think like an underdog. He uses verbs like 
“prove” and “aspire” when discussing Bloomberg News. After he leaves the 
interview — in which he doesn’t say a single inappropriate word — Mr. 
Winkler e-mails his media-relations chief to ask: “WAS I OKAY?”

Two floors above the sprawling newsroom, wedged in the corner of the 
corporate department — take a right at “Philanthropy” — is a recent 
arrival to Bloomberg, a longtime newsman. At 67, Norman Pearlstine has 
already held two of the biggest jobs in old media: managing editor of 
The Journal and editor in chief of Time Inc.

“Norm Pearlstine comes to Bloomberg, he provides instant credibility for 
people who wonder what is Bloomberg up to,” Mr. Winkler says.

So last year, Mr. Pearlstine was recruited from the Carlyle Group, the 
private equity firm, and named chief content officer. The role has him 
playing media consigliere to Mr. Doctoroff and Mr. Grauer, advising on 
Web, television and news operations.

Mr. Pearlstine didn’t expect his role to be hugely taxing when he signed 
on, and his responsibilities, by design, have been relatively 
open-ended. “I actually came in with what I thought was the perfect 
job,” he says. “I had two desks and no one reporting to me. I thought I 
deserved this after all this time.”

Despite Mr. Pearlstine’s years of experience as an editing maestro, he 
has largely stayed away from Mr. Winkler’s news operation.

“I’ve seen him around,” says Christine Harper, chief financial 
correspondent, of Mr. Pearlstine, but “he doesn’t seem to be as directly 
involved in the news.”

The ambitions for Bloomberg’s news operation were changing even before 
Mr. Pearlstine arrived. Bloomberg has used the cash spraying from its 
terminal business to hire an astounding number of journalists in recent 
years, becoming something of a haven in a downsizing industry. Top 
writers or editors from Fortune, Forbes and The Journal land there 
seemingly weekly. (Six of the company’s 11 executive editors have worked 
at The Journal.)

Bloomberg now has 142 journalists in Washington, 196 in Tokyo and 30 in 
Paris. It recently opened bureaus in Nigeria, Ghana and Cyprus. It has 
won numerous journalism awards and, to cite just one example, has 
offered some of the shrewdest coverage of the financial crisis over the 
last couple of years.

The problem is that all of this work is largely distributed through its 
280,000 Bloomberg machines, so its audience is confined mostly to those 
who subscribe to its terminals. Bloomberg essentially has a giant army 
of reporters with no route to the broader media sea.

TO reach that broader audience and to have its name and its brand 
distributed beyond its terminals, Bloomberg has been dependent on 
newspapers to carry its reports.

Newspapers like The Florida Times-Union in Jacksonville use a lot of 
Bloomberg articles. More significantly, Bloomberg is collaborating with 
The Washington Post on a newswire service set to start in January. 
Bloomberg is also planning a host of new charges for newspapers to use 
its content.

To carve out its own destiny in print while also reaching a new audience 
of decision-makers, Bloomberg snapped up BusinessWeek. Mr. Pearlstine 
had been sniffing around other media properties, including Congressional 
Quarterly, when BusinessWeek came on the block this summer. 
BusinessWeek’s parent company, McGraw-Hill, was under pressure to sell 
the magazine, which lost more than $43 million last year.

What attracted Bloomberg was BusinessWeek’s audience. With a circulation 
of more than 900,000, and about 11 million Web site visitors a month, 
BusinessWeek potentially expands Bloomberg’s readership — and sources — 
well beyond its trading-floor customers.

Executives hope BusinessWeek will become a place where President Obama 
or Jeffrey R. Immelt of General Electric will go to for the kind of 
exclusive interviews they have traditionally given more established news 
publications. (Although Bloomberg has some arts and culture coverage, 
the company says it has no interest in moving substantially beyond its 
core offering of business information and news.)

BusinessWeek employees are interviewing to keep their jobs and have to 
submit essays outlining goals for themselves and the magazine, along 
with fresh résumés. Mr. Pearlstine is leaning on old-media hands to 
advise him on the integration, including the former Time editor Jim 
Kelly and Stephen B. Shepard, who edited BusinessWeek for 20 years 
before being succeeded by Stephen J. Adler in 2005. (Mr. Adler resigned 
from the magazine after Bloomberg acquired it.)

Mr. Pearlstine says Bloomberg will maintain the magazine as a weekly, 
improve the paper quality and expand globally, with The Economist as a 
model. A culture clash might emerge in bringing a magazine, with its 
individualistic writers, into Bloomberg’s monochrome culture.

“The company isn’t in the business of building stars — I think that 
they’re based on teamwork and contribution,” says Andrew Leckey, 
president of the Donald W. Reynolds National Center for Business 
Journalism. “How the magazine fits in there is a little tricky.” One 
early antistar move: on Friday, Bloomberg ended the BusinessWeek column 
of CNBC’s Maria Bartiromo. (Jack and Suzy Welch also announced that 
they’re ending their column in the magazine.)

Although Mr. Pearlstine and Mr. Winkler both report directly to Mr. 
Doctoroff, Mr. Pearlstine will have to report through Mr. Winkler on 
BusinessWeek matters “because it’s editorial,” Mr. Winkler says.

Other media players, meanwhile, are watching what Bloomberg does with 
the existing BusinessWeek and Bloomberg Web sites. Will it combine them? 
Will they charge readers for content? And — more important — does 
Bloomberg care if any of its media properties actually make money?

“BusinessWeek we expect will be profitable, but it doesn’t have to be 
profitable a year or two years from now,” Mr. Doctoroff says.

OTHER Bloomberg media holdings have not been under much, if any, 
pressure over the years to make money and for the most part have seemed 
like second thoughts at the company. Consider Bloomberg Markets, a 
magazine free to terminal subscribers that was introduced in 1992 and is 
not profitable. Its first cover featured a drawing of the terminal.

“It was basically a monthly users’ manual,” says Ron Henkoff, the 
current editor. “There were no sections. There were no photos.” Although 
the magazine looks and reads a lot better today, it’s still 
terminal-focused. Articles run first on the terminal, and even the most 
ambitious pieces, like “Street of Broken Dreams,” a report in May about 
laid-off financial employees, carry terminal tip boxes. (“Type UKWILOMA 
<Index> GP <Go> to graph changes in payrolls.”)

Likewise, when Bloomberg Television was introduced in 1994, Mr. Lack, 
then at NBC, was unimpressed. Bloomberg covered most of the screen with 
an L-shaped box jammed with market information. “Bloomberg basically 
said: ‘We don’t care if you like us or not. Just look at this. Isn’t it 
amazing?’” recalls Mr. Lack. “You almost felt as though you were choked 
by all that data.”

When Mr. Pearlstine recruited him last year to run the multimedia 
business — television, radio and Web — what Mr. Lack found was alarming. 
“I thought it was going to be a turnaround,” he says. “Then I found that 
it felt more like a start-up. There wasn’t an infrastructure here to 
produce a professional cable television channel.”

Mr. Lack has made some changes, including decluttering on-screen 
graphics, pulling anchors from a dark studio into a newsroom setting, 
and adding shows like day-after repeats of “Charlie Rose” at night. 
Still, Bloomberg’s cable audience in the United States is much smaller 
than CNBC’s.

“We’ll make this into a business, don’t get me wrong,” Mr. Lack says. 
“Four or five years from now, this will be a business.”

As recently as a year ago, when Bloomberg tried to hire Mr. Lack, he 
thought that executives’ talk of being “most influential” was absurd. 
“I, of course, completely dismissed it.”

Now, he says, he’s a convert. “This is not an old-media company,” Mr. 
Lack says. “We’re a new kid on the block in a new world order.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to