Lost Spectrum Could Be Cable’s Gain
Upsides Could Include Billions in New Revenue, Possible Retrans Shift

by John Eggerton
Multichannel News

11/16/2009 2:00:00 AM

http://www.multichannel.com/article/389084-Lost_Spectrum_Could_Be_Cable_s_Gain.php


Washington — Most of the attention in the big push to reclaim 
broadcast-TV spectrum has been given to TV stations, their owners and 
the private-equity firms involved that could be looking for an exit 
strategy — but cable operators have plenty of skin in the game as well.

That includes billions of potential dollars from new subscribers and a 
possible new model for retransmission-consent negotiations that could 
give multichannel TV providers more leverage.

According to a source familiar with the conversations, Federal 
Communications Commission staffers have been talking to cable-industry 
representatives about spectrum reclamation, but those conversations have 
been about technology rather than broader policy issues.

“Staff has talked to cable operators, asking them technical questions, 
but there have not been the broad conversations they have had with 
broadcasters,” the source said.

According to broadcast sources, one such conversation the FCC will need 
to have is on extending the must-carry rules to signals no longer 
delivered over the air, or now transmitted in a different format.

“The historic legal justification for must-carry was … to preserve an 
over-the-air service for the non-cable home,” said cable attorney Daniel 
Brenner of Hogan & Hartson. “But if you eliminate that service, then 
that justification goes away.”

According to broadcast sources, one take on the spectrum-reclamation 
proposal being floated by FCC broadband adviser Blair Levin in talks 
with broadcasters and others would have the stations maintain at least a 
standard-definition over-the-air signal, with cable operators required 
to carry an HD feed of that station to their customers.

Under another scenario, outlined by economist Coleman Bazelon in an FCC 
filing, broadcasters would give back all their spectrum, becoming 
essentially another cable or satellite channel.

Cable would find upside in Bazelon’s proposal that the government 
subsidize multichannel video service to the 10 million or so households 
that still rely on over-the-air TV. “You are offering them 10 million 
new customers, so that’s worth something,” Bazelon pointed out. Such 
lifeline service would be subsidized for life, he said.

But is that worth enough for cable operators to accept a continued 
must-carry regime, perhaps for stations that don’t even deliver an 
over-the-air signal? “Maybe not, but must-carry is going to be in the 
bargain,” he said. Bazelon figures that subsidized service would mean an 
additional $9.3 billion in cable subscriptions (see box).

The industry has long argued that forced carriage of stations that 
actually deliver a signal over the air is an unconstitutional taking of 
property and a violation of their First Amendment right to have 
editorial control over their own networks. Trying to extend that to 
stations no longer on the air could, as Brenner points out, be tough 
sledding.

Comcast executive vice president David Cohen would not comment directly 
on any of the proposals, but told reporters at a briefing two weeks ago 
that any attempt to extend must-carry would almost certainly wind up in 
court. (Comcast and the FCC are already locked in court battles over the 
agency’s retention of rules capping a pay TV provider’s footprint at 30% 
of the U.S. multichannel market, as well as the BitTorrent decision 
finding Comcast in violation of agency network-openness guidelines).

For pay TV providers, the advantage of a spectrum-free system of local 
TV stations goes beyond the additional 10 million or so homes that would 
sign up for subsidized service, said one veteran cable attorney who 
asked not to be identified. It would also give operators a leg up in 
terms of retransmission consent.

What is now a system that benefits a few broadcasters at the expense of 
cable operators, the attorney said, could become one in which an MSO 
could cut out the TV-station “gatekeepers” and deal directly with such 
broadcast networks as NBC, ABC or Univision, as they do with national 
cable networks.

If an affiliate-station owner such as Sinclair Broadcast Group has only 
local news to offer an MSO such as Mediacom Communications, said the 
attorney, “the affiliate loses a lot of its influence.”


-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to