December 24, 2009

Loan Program May Stir Dormant Nuclear Industry
By MATTHEW L. WALD
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/24/business/energy-environment/24nuke.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


WASHINGTON — When experts on power grid reliability asked themselves 
recently how a cleaner energy future would look, seven of eight regional 
councils imagined how their systems would work with 10 percent wind power.

Only one, representing the southeastern United States, chose a radically 
different option: doubling nuclear power capacity.

Thirty years after the American nuclear industry abandoned scores of 
half-built plants because of soaring costs and operating problems like 
the Three Mile Island accident, skepticism persists over whether the 
technology is worth investing in.

Yet the pendulum may be swinging back. The 104 plants now running have 
sharply raised their output, emboldening utilities across the country to 
make a case for building new ones.

And the industry is about to get a big boost. In the next few days, the 
Energy Department plans to announce the first of $18.5 billion in loan 
guarantees for building new reactors.

The guarantees were authorized in a bill passed by Congress in 2005.

It has taken four years for the department to set up a system to 
evaluate applications and determine how much the borrowers will be 
charged for the guarantees to compensate the government for taking the risk.

Industry experts think the first guarantee will go to the Southern 
Company to build two units at its Vogtle nuclear plant near Augusta, Ga.

The money will flow amid a national credit squeeze and intense jockeying 
among the nation’s wind, solar, geothermal and nuclear sectors. Each is 
trying to cast itself as an ideal “clean” energy option as the nation 
moves toward reining in the carbon dioxide emissions linked to global 
warming.

All of these sources could potentially benefit under a cap-and-trade 
system that is being considered in Congress as part of climate change 
legislation. Such a system would set a ceiling on carbon dioxide 
emissions and allow trading of pollution permits, handicapping the 
carbon-intensive coal and natural gas sectors.

Historically Republicans have been more enthusiastic than Democrats 
about nuclear power. So as the climate bill winds its way through the 
Senate, some Democratic members are seeking to add to the $18.5 billion 
in loan guarantees for the nuclear industry to attract Republicans and 
some industrial-state Democrats. (The House version passed in June, 219 
to 212.)

Some of the foremost Congressional climate change campaigners are 
unenthusiastic.

Representative Edward Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat who has hounded 
the nuclear industry for decades over safety questions and who is a 
sponsor of the House bill, does not favor direct aid to the nuclear 
industry. He argues that a cap-and-trade system would give the nuclear 
sector the only boost it deserves.

If that system goes into effect, he said, nuclear power “will be able to 
compete more effectively in a new marketplace. How effectively they can 
compete is going to be the question.”

Others see combining a cap-and-trade system with a nuclear aid package 
as a sensible tactic to get Congress to address environmental problems.

“One can argue it certainly is bringing about an unusual marriage of 
interests here,” said Philip R. Sharp, an Indiana Democrat who served in 
the House of Representatives from 1975 to 1995 and led a House committee 
with jurisdiction over the electric system.

“It is one of the potential paths for actually getting real action and 
real legislation,” said Mr. Sharp, who now heads the nonpartisan group 
Resources for the Future.

Economic issues have helped scramble alliances on the state and local 
level, too. Because new reactors create so many jobs and big tax 
revenue, the Democratic governors of Maryland and Ohio are working hard 
to get them built in their states.

State legislatures from Louisiana to South Dakota and local governments 
from Port Gibson, Miss., to Oswego, N.Y., are also on record favoring 
new reactors.

Peter A. Bradford, a former member of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission 
who is now vice chairman of the Union of Concerned Scientists, questions 
the wisdom of direct aid to the industry.

Unlike cap and trade, in which industries buy and sell the right to 
release carbon dioxide in a market-oriented system, he said, the loan 
guarantees finance projects that the private sector deems too risky.

The government would be “picking some winners and bestowing a lot of 
taxpayer support on them,” he said.

By Mr. Bradford’s count, of 28 reactors that the Nuclear Regulatory 
Commission now lists as planned, half have had major delays, large 
increases in estimated cost or have been canceled.

If new plants built with government guarantees prove to be a commercial 
success, the program costs taxpayers nothing; if they prove too 
expensive to finish or are completed but cannot earn enough to repay the 
loans, the taxpayer is on the hook.

Complicating the challenge, the forthcoming loan guarantees amount to 
only $18.5 billion, and the nuclear industry says it needs tens of 
billions more.

President Obama’s energy secretary, Steven Chu, acknowledged that the 
sum was small. He said it could finance at most perhaps one plant for 
each new reactor design, making it hard to determine which design was 
most practical.

“If I were a power company, maybe one of each would not be helpful,” he 
said. He suggested that the nuclear industry would need to build two or 
three of each.

But Dr. Chu insists that nuclear power will be an important piece of any 
climate solution.

“We have a dormant nuclear industry,” he said. “We have to start it up 
in a way that gives the people who are going to make investments the 
confidence that this is economically viable.”

Mindful of the challenges posed by global warming, some 
environmentalists are cautiously evaluating their positions on nuclear 
power.

“There is an increasing number of people who have spent their lives as 
environmental advocates who believe that carbon is such an urgent 
problem that they have to rethink their skepticism about nuclear power,” 
said Jonathan Lash, the president of the World Resources Institute, who 
puts himself in that category.

“But there are many people who are passionate environmentalists who are 
also passionate opponents of nuclear power, and remain so,” he said.

Among the foes is Karen Hadden, executive director of the Sustainable 
Energy and Economic Development Coalition in Austin, Tex., which is 
fighting a nuclear project there that is in line for a loan guarantee. 
While she strongly favors carbon limits, she said, she opposes 
construction of reactors.

She warned that money for solar, wind and geothermal projects could get 
siphoned off “in these multibillion-dollar projects that may or may not 
ever get built.”

Daniel L. Roderick, senior vice president for nuclear plant projects at 
GE-Hitachi Nuclear Energy, a partnership between General Electric and 
Hitachi of Japan, said that a year and a half ago, there were 
expectations that more than 20 units would be under construction by now 
in the United States. “That number is currently zero,” he said.

Nonetheless, G.E. and other companies have invested tens of millions of 
dollars in plans for reactors they hope to build around the world, 
including dozens in the United States.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to