Looking to expand the reach of high-speed Internet, federal regulators 
look to the television.

By Mike Zapler
San Jose Mercury News

Updated: 12/24/2009 08:22:36 PM PST

http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking-news/ci_14066683


WASHINGTON — Looking to pare the shrinking but substantial number of 
Americans without high-speed Internet, federal officials are considering 
taking advantage of a technology that practically everyone has at home: 
the TV.

The Federal Communications Commission wants to revamp the market for 
set-top boxes — the channel-switching devices that cable and satellite 
subscribers typically lease for $5 or $10 a month — and equip the 
machines with Internet-surfing capability.

The thinking is simple: 99 percent of households have a television, and 
76 percent have a personal computer. So why not piggyback on the TV to 
extend the reach of high-speed broadband, which lawmakers and regulators 
see as a necessity for anyone to function in the 21st century economy?

If the commission is successful, it could usher in an era in which 
people use a single gadget to watch cable shows, download movies from 
the Web and surf the Internet — all on their TVs.

"If you had a set-top box that can access traditional cable but also get 
to the Internet, more people could start to see the value of having 
broadband," said Matt Wood, associate director of Media Access Project, 
a public interest law firm.

But beyond pushing high-speed Internet into more homes, advocates say 
the FCC's effort could spark a transformation of the basic set-top cable 
box into a high-tech, multiuse machine, much like the cell phone has 
been revolutionized by the BlackBerry and the iPhone.

"We've seen a steady march of TVs and separate boxes that provide 
Web-based video," such as the TiVo and Roku devices, said Brian 
Markwalter, vice president of technology and standards for the Consumer 
Electronics Association. "When you can integrate that with the other 
pieces you're paying for" — cable or satellite programming — "it will 
spark all sorts of creativity."

The FCC has also signaled that it wants consumers to be able to use the 
same set-top box for any type of TV service — cable, satellite or 
fiber-optic — allowing them to switch from one carrier to another 
without obtaining a major new piece of equipment from the provider. That 
could spur more people to buy set-top boxes instead of leasing them.

"It's time "... to consider if there are better ways to open the set-top 
box market to greater competition and innovation," William Lake, the 
FCC's media bureau chief, said at a public meeting recently. To drive 
that point home, FCC officials pointed out that there currently are 14 
set-top boxes that consumers can buy at stores vs. nearly 900 types of 
mobile phones.

The FCC is a long way from imposing any new rules for set-top boxes; 
this month it sought public comment on ways to spur "video device 
innovation," the initial step in what would be an extensive set of 
proceedings. But it is part of a broader undertaking of the commission 
under its new chairman, Julius Genachowski, to lower barriers for people 
to access video and other offerings over the Internet.

The effort could pick up steam with the commission's expected February 
release of its national broadband plan, which will propose strategies to 
make high-speed Internet available to the roughly one-third of American 
homes that lack it.

This would not be the first time the federal government has gotten 
involved in the set-top box realm. Prodded by Congress and the FCC in 
the mid-90s, the cable industry developed technology that allows 
customers to switch from one cable provider to another using the same 
set-top box. But that effort is widely perceived as a failure, in part 
because of shortcomings in the technology and in part because of the 
emergence over the past decade of noncable video service providers such 
as satellite and fiber-optic.

The stakes for cable and other video service providers of any potential 
FCC initiative are high. Making it easier for consumers to get Web-based 
video presumably would mean one less reason for them to pay for 
expensive channel packages.

In a filing to the FCC this month, the National Cable & 
Telecommunications Association, which represents cable firms, said it 
supports the commission's look at why a vibrant retail market for 
set-top boxes hasn't developed. At the same time, the cable group 
questioned whether a market exists for set-top boxes that could cost 
hundreds of dollars and risk becoming obsolete as technology advances. 
The group cautioned that a mandate to require Web-enabled set-top boxes 
could substantially increase costs for consumers.

"To add full Internet capability to even the newest generation of 
set-top boxes would require more processing power, a browser, PC 
plug-ins (Silverlight, Adobe, etc.), media content protection clients, 
parental controls, virus and malware protection, and a remote keyboard 
and mouse, among other features," the association stated in its filing. 
"Most of the cost would be borne by the millions of (cable, satellite 
and fiber-optic) subscribers who already have a computer and who may 
have no interest in having Internet functionality added to their 
television sets."

Indeed, past attempts to integrate TV and the Internet — including WebTV 
and Apple TV — never gained much traction. Whether an all-in-one device 
that surfs the Web, accesses online video and broadcasts TV programming 
would have more appeal is an open question.

Critics suspect cable companies are raising doubts just to protect their 
turf.

"The incumbents are always going to raise excuses why it can't work," 
said Matthew Zinn, senior vice president and general counsel of 
Alviso-based TiVo. "The cable operators want to maintain a walled garden 
and keep consumers captive."

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to