April 11, 2010

News Sites Rethink Anonymous Online Comments
By RICHARD PÉREZ-PEÑA
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/12/technology/12comments.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


 From the start, Internet users have taken for granted that the 
territory was both a free-for-all and a digital disguise, allowing them 
to revel in their power to address the world while keeping their 
identities concealed.

A New Yorker cartoon from 1993, during the Web’s infancy, with one mutt 
saying to another, “On the Internet, nobody knows you’re a dog,” became 
an emblem of that freedom. For years, it was the magazine’s most 
reproduced cartoon.

When news sites, after years of hanging back, embraced the idea of 
allowing readers to post comments, the near-universal assumption was 
that anyone could weigh in and remain anonymous. But now, that idea is 
under attack from several directions, and journalists, more than ever, 
are questioning whether anonymity should be a given on news sites.

The Washington Post plans to revise its comments policy over the next 
several months, and one of the ideas under consideration is to give 
greater prominence to commenters using real names.

The New York Times, The Post and many other papers have moved in stages 
toward requiring that people register before posting comments, providing 
some information about themselves that is not shown onscreen.

The Huffington Post soon will announce changes, including ranking 
commenters based in part on how well other readers know and trust their 
writing.

“Anonymity is just the way things are done. It’s an accepted part of the 
Internet, but there’s no question that people hide behind anonymity to 
make vile or controversial comments,” said Arianna Huffington, a founder 
of The Huffington Post. “I feel that this is almost like an education 
process. As the rules of the road are changing and the Internet is 
growing up, the trend is away from anonymity.”

The Plain Dealer of Cleveland recently discovered that anonymous 
comments on its site, disparaging a local lawyer, were made using the 
e-mail address of a judge who was presiding over some of that lawyer’s 
cases.

That kind of proxy has been documented before; what was more unusual was 
that The Plain Dealer exposed the connection in an article. The judge, 
Shirley Strickland Saffold, denied sending the messages — her daughter 
took responsibility for some of them. And last week, the judge sued The 
Plain Dealer, claiming it had violated her privacy.

The paper acknowledged that it had broken with the tradition of allowing 
commenters to hide behind screen names, but it served notice that 
anonymity was a habit, not a guarantee. Susan Goldberg, The Plain 
Dealer’s editor, declined to comment for this article. But in an 
interview she gave to her own newspaper, she said that perhaps the paper 
should not have investigated the identity of the person who posted the 
comments, “but once we did, I don’t know how you can pretend you don’t 
know that information.”

Some prominent journalists weighed in on the episode, calling it 
evidence that news sites should do away with anonymous comments. Leonard 
Pitts Jr., a Miami Herald columnist, wrote recently that anonymity has 
made comment streams “havens for a level of crudity, bigotry, meanness 
and plain nastiness that shocks the tattered remnants of our propriety.”

No one doubts that there is a legitimate value in letting people express 
opinions that may get them in trouble at work, or may even offend their 
neighbors, without having to give their names, said William Grueskin, 
dean of academic affairs at Columbia’s journalism school.

“But a lot of comment boards turn into the equivalent of a barroom 
brawl, with most of the participants having blood-alcohol levels of 0.10 
or higher,” he said. “People who might have something useful to say are 
less willing to participate in boards where the tomatoes are being thrown.”

He said news organizations were willing to reconsider anonymity in part 
because comment pages brought in little revenue; advertisers generally 
do not like to buy space next to opinions, especially incendiary ones.

The debate over anonymity is entwined with the question of giving more 
weight to comments from some readers than others, based in part on how 
highly other readers regard them. Some sites already use a version of 
this approach; Wikipedia users can earn increasing editing rights by 
gaining the trust of other editors, and when reviews are posted on 
Amazon.com, those displayed most prominently are those that readers have 
voted “most helpful” — and they are often written under real names.

Hal Straus, interactivity editor of The Washington Post, said, “We want 
to be able to establish user tiers, and display variations based on 
those tiers.” The system is still being planned, but he says it is 
likely that readers will be asked to rate comments, and that people’s 
comments will be ranked in part based on the trust those users have 
earned from other readers — an approach much like the one The Huffington 
Post is set to adopt. Another criterion could be whether they use their 
real names.

But experience has shown that when users help rank things online, sites 
may have to guard against a concerted campaign by a small group of 
people voting one way and skewing the results.

A popular feature on The Wall Street Journal’s site lets readers decide 
whether they want to see only those comments posted by subscribers, on 
the theory that the most dedicated readers might make for a more serious 
conversation.

Few news organizations, including The Times, have someone review every 
comment before it goes online, to weed out personal attacks and bigoted 
comments. Some sites and prominent bloggers, like Andrew Sullivan, 
simply do not allow comments.

Some news sites review comments after they are posted, but most say they 
do not have the resources to do routine policing. Many sites allow 
readers to flag objectionable comments for removal, and make some effort 
to block comments from people who have repeatedly violated the site’s 
standards.

If commenters were asked to provide their real names for display online, 
some would no doubt give false identities, and verifying them would be 
too labor-intensive to be realistic. But news executives say that merely 
making the demand for a name and an e-mail address would weed out much 
of the most offensive commentary.

Several industry executives cited a more fundamental force working in 
favor of identifying commenters. Through blogging and social networking 
sites like Facebook and Twitter, millions of people have grown 
accustomed to posting their opinions — to say nothing of personal 
details — with their names attached, for all to see. Adapting the 
Facebook model, some news sites allow readers to post a picture along 
with a comment, another step away from anonymity.

“There is a younger generation that doesn’t feel the same need for 
privacy,” Ms. Huffington said. “Many people, when you give them other 
choices, they choose not to be anonymous.”


-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to