April 11, 2010

Aerospace Business Has Its Doubts About Plans to Revamp NASA
By KENNETH CHANG
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/12/science/space/12rocket.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


Boeing and Lockheed Martin, the aerospace giants with decades of 
experience working on America’s space program, will happily sell rockets 
to carry astronauts into space, but the companies are leery about taking 
a leading role in President Obama’s vision for a revamped National 
Aeronautics and Space Administration.

The prospect of NASA relying on smaller companies — unproven upstarts in 
the view of critics — could create yet another hurdle in convincing an 
already skeptical Congress of the idea of relying on commercial 
companies to provide taxi transportation to the International Space Station.

“I don’t think there is a business case for us,” John Karas, vice 
president and general manager of human spaceflight at Lockheed Martin, 
said about space taxis.

Publicly, Boeing has been enthusiastic. “We have a vested interest in 
the International Space Station,” Brewster H. Shaw, vice president and 
general manager of Boeing’s NASA Systems business unit, said in February 
after NASA awarded the company $18 million to draw up a preliminary 
design of a capsule that could serve as the basis of a commercial crew 
system. “We want to see I.S.S. live up to its potential by having a 
robust logistics for the delivery of cargo and crew.”

But Loren B. Thompson, an analyst at the Lexington Institute, a policy 
group financed by military contractors, said Boeing is more skeptical in 
private.

In 1995, Boeing began pursuing the commercial space business through an 
international partnership called Sea Launch; it also developed the Delta 
IV rocket to launch both military and commercial satellites. The company 
lost money in both efforts, with Sea Launch filing for bankruptcy in 
2009. To stem the Delta IV losses, Boeing and Lockheed Martin, which was 
also losing money with its Atlas V rocket, set up a joint venture called 
the United Launch Alliance in 2006.

“Senior Boeing executives have told me that they are skeptical about new 
launch opportunities, given the losses they incurred on previous 
initiatives such as Sea Launch and the Pentagon’s expendable launcher 
program,” Dr. Thompson said. “They are unlikely to invest large amounts 
of money on the new NASA vision.”

Mr. Obama has called for the cancellation of NASA’s current 
Constellation program to send astronauts back to the Moon. In its place, 
the administration would like to spend $6 billion over five years to 
finance the development of rockets and crew capsules by commercial 
companies.

NASA officials have said the program would be set up to attract new and 
established companies. The money would most likely be split between two 
or more companies.

In pitching the idea, administration officials have said that commercial 
companies have always built the rockets and spacecraft that carried 
American astronauts and that it would not be a radical shift to turn to 
aerospace companies with decades of experience. They also contend that 
competition would spur innovation and drive down the launching costs, 
which, in turn, would open vibrant new markets.

NASA has not described details of the planned competition, and the 
companies said they would take a look at what the agency proposes.

“Assuming the business case is right, we’re all in,” said Keith Reiley, 
program manager for Boeing’s capsule development.

The business case depends on how much money NASA will be asking the 
companies to invest. In traditional “cost plus” development, NASA pays 
for everything. In that case, Mr. Reilly said, “of course, we’d be happy 
to do that.”

If NASA were to ask the companies to shoulder all of the financial risk, 
however, Boeing would certainly not participate. The key would be how 
the $6 billion would be divided. “Hopefully,” Mr. Reilly said, “those 
issues will get resolved.”

Both Boeing and Lockheed were stung during the last burst of optimism 
for the commercial space business about a decade ago. They invested 
several billion dollars — Lockheed to develop its Atlas V, Boeing for 
the Delta IV — in the hopes that the huge market for commercial 
satellites would supplement their traditional business of launching 
American military spy satellites.

The market did not materialize, and what business there was went to 
European and Russian rockets that were cheaper. With the United Launch 
Alliance, Boeing and Lockheed Martin share costs and profits equally. 
The joint venture now operates in the black, but the companies did not 
recoup their original investments, and much of the infrastructure they 
built remains underused.

“I think people who have been in the launcher business for many years 
find it hard to take the president’s plan seriously,” Dr. Thompson said. 
“They think it sounds like an elaborate wake for the human spaceflight 
program more than a plan for moving forward.”

The hoped-for commercial market for space taxis hinges on one small 
company, Bigelow Aerospace of Las Vegas, which is teaming up with Boeing 
on its capsule design.

Founded by Robert T. Bigelow, a real estate investor who made a fortune 
with the Budget Suites hotel chain, Bigelow Aerospace is developing 
inflatable space habitats that it hopes to market as research facilities 
to companies and foreign nations looking to establish a space program.

The company’s plans are ambitious. It is already negotiating with United 
Launch Alliance for seven Atlas V launches in 2014.

“That nearly doubles the output of the Atlas V in any given year,” said 
Michael N. Gold, director of Bigelow’s Washington office. “It’s really a 
snowball effect here,” he said, with economies of scale expected to 
drive down the costs.

The result of the launches in 2014 would be a private space station that 
could house 12 astronauts — twice as many as the International Space 
Station. Plans call for a second, even larger Bigelow station two years 
later, with room for 24 astronauts. The company projected 148 to 176 
launches between 2014 and 2022.

“We’re extremely confident in the market,” Mr. Gold said. The only 
missing pieces, he said, are the rockets to carry people to and from the 
Bigelow stations.

But if Bigelow’s plans do not unfold as the company projects, and if 
NASA were the only customer, the space taxi business might be too small 
— perhaps just two flights a year to the International Space Station — 
and too risky for Boeing or Lockheed Martin to invest much time and money.

James McAleese, a defense consultant in McLean, Va., said that large 
aerospace firms like Boeing and Lockheed typically generate returns of 
11 percent or 12 percent on their investments, and that for riskier 
enterprises like space, the companies would be looking for even higher 
returns. “I don’t believe there’s a burning desire to get into the 
spacecraft piece of the business,” he said.

If a commercial market developed, that could still be a lucrative 
business, said Mr. Karas, of Lockheed Martin, who once led the company’s 
expendable rockets business. But he added, “Personally, this is exactly 
the same rhetoric as last time.”

Still, even if Boeing and Lockheed declined to bid directly on NASA’s 
plans, at least some of the astronauts would probably be traveling in 
Atlas Vs or Delta IVs built by those companies.

The NASA competition may seek proposals solely for spacecraft — the crew 
capsules or winged craft atop the rockets — rather than the rockets 
themselves. The spacecraft makers would specify which rocket a craft 
would launch on.

One likely bidder, Space Exploration Technologies Corporation of 
Hawthorne, Calif., is developing both a crew capsule, the Dragon, and 
its own rocket, the Falcon 9. Other possible competitors, like Blue 
Origin, a start-up by Jeff Bezos, the founder of Amazon.com, would build 
only the capsule and put it on top of an existing rocket, with the most 
likely choice being United Launch Alliance’s Atlas V.

The joint venture would sell rockets — the lower-end versions of the 
Atlas V cost about $150 million each — to the spacecraft makers. Thus, 
the alliance — and, indirectly, Boeing and Lockheed Martin — would 
continue their involvement with NASA’s space program, but in a secondary 
role.

Michael C. Gass, president and chief executive of United Launch 
Alliance, has said that upgrading the low-end version of the Atlas V for 
astronauts — adding a monitoring system to alert controllers of problems 
with the rocket and modifying the launching pad to handle astronauts — 
would cost $400 million.

“When you start getting into a heavier crew transfer vehicle and a 
dedicated launch facility, it’s over a billion dollars, but less than 
two,” Mr. Gass said. Those improvements “should be funded by the U.S. 
government” without additional investment from Boeing and Lockheed, he said.

Even with Bigelow already negotiating launches, Mr. Gass said, he did 
not yet see a definite commercial market. “The commercial market could 
develop,” he said. “Right now, we’re approaching it as incremental.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to