April 11, 2010

An Internet for Everybody
By SUSAN CRAWFORD
NY Times Op-Ed Contributor

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/11/opinion/11crawford.html?pagewanted=print


Ann Arbor, Mich.

LAST week, a federal appeals court in Washington ruled that the Federal 
Communications Commission lacks the legal authority to tell Comcast not 
to block certain uses of its Internet access services. This decision has 
become a rip-the-Band-Aid-off moment for the regulatory agency, forcing 
it to reconsider its effort to impose “network neutrality” by requiring 
that Internet access providers treat all content equally.

It also puts a substantial roadblock in the path of the commission’s 
National Broadband Plan, which proposes to spend billions of dollars to 
help provide Internet access, rather than phone access, for people in 
rural areas.

But the F.C.C. needn’t change either strategy. It can regain its 
authority to pursue both network neutrality and widespread access to 
broadband by formally relabeling Internet access services as 
“telecommunications services,” rather than “information services,” as 
they are called now. All the commission needs to do is prove it has a 
good reason.

It wouldn’t be the first time that the F.C.C. relabeled Internet access 
services — and certainly not the first time it addressed the need for 
equal access. Until August 2005, the commission required that companies 
providing high-speed access to the Internet over telephone lines not 
discriminate among Web sites. This allowed innumerable online businesses 
— eBay, Google, Amazon, your local knitter — to start up without asking 
permission from phone and cable companies. There was nothing unusual 
about this legal requirement; for more than 100 years, federal 
regulators had treated telegraph and telephone service providers as 
"common carriers," obligated to serve everyone equally.

But under the Bush administration the F.C.C. deregulated high-speed 
Internet providers, arguing that cable Internet access was different 
from the kind of high-speed Internet access provided by phone companies. 
Cable Internet access providers, the commission said, really offered an 
integrated bundle of services — not just Internet connection but also 
e-mail, Web hosting, news groups and other services. So the F.C.C. 
declared that high-speed Internet access would no longer be considered a 
“telecommunications service” but rather an “information service.” This 
removed all high-speed Internet access services — phone as well as cable 
— from regulation under the common-carrier section of the Communications 
Act.

This was a radical move, because it reversed the long-held assumption 
that a nondiscriminatory communications network was essential to 
economic growth, civic welfare and innovation. At the same time, the 
F.C.C. said that it would retain the power to regulate Internet access 
providers if the need arose, under another section of the Communications 
Act.

The Bush F.C.C. hoped that deregulation would prompt greater competition 
in Internet access services. But a wave of mergers instead reduced it. 
Prices stayed high and speeds slow. And eventually the carriers started 
saying that they wanted to be gatekeepers — creating fast lanes for some 
Web sites and applications and slow lanes for others.

In its decision last week, the appeals court said that the “information 
services” label given to high-speed Internet access providers means the 
F.C.C. cannot prohibit companies like Comcast from engaging in 
discriminatory activities. But if the F.C.C.’s labeling of high-speed 
Internet access providers undermines its ability to tell them what to 
do, how can it ensure that consumers get the information they need about 
real speeds and prices? How can it ensure that basic communications 
services — which, these days, means Internet access — are widely available?

The F.C.C. has the legal authority to change the label, as long as it 
can provide a good reason. And that reason is obvious: Americans buy an 
Internet access service based on its speed and price — and not on 
whether an e-mail address is included as part of a bundle. The 
commission should state its case, relabel high-speed Internet access as 
a “telecommunications service,” and take back the power to protect 
American consumers.

------------------
Susan Crawford, a former special assistant to President Obama for 
science, technology and innovation policy, is a professor at the 
University of Michigan Law School.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to