APRIL 12, 2010 Union Pushes Back on Verizon Sale of Lines in 14 States to Frontier Could Result in Job Cuts, Workers Say
By ROGER CHENG Wall Street Journal http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304846504575177870053373144.html?mod=WSJ_Tech_LEFTTopNews The Communications Workers of America is targeting West Virginia to try to block Frontier's purchase of Verizon local phone lines for $8.6 billion. Verizon Communications Inc.'s move to shed a significant portion of its landline phone system is facing a few bumps. The New York telecommunications giant expects by the middle of the year to close an $8.6 billion deal to sell 4.8 million landlines in 14 states to Frontier Communications Corp. Normally, the company is adept at closing such deals but this time it could face complications. The Communications Workers of America union opposes the transaction because it fears the spinoff will place a heavy financial burden on Frontier, leading to job cuts. While the union said it believes it can block the deal, few believe that will be the outcome. Still, a delay could be costly for Verizon since it would need to keep spending to maintain the phone lines it is selling. Verizon and Frontier don't foresee any changes to their plans. "Everything the union and others have brought up we've been able to shoot down with immediacy," said Steve Crosby, senior vice president for government and regulatory affairs at Frontier. Verizon spokesman Peter Thonis said, "We expect to close by the middle of this year." The CWA has demonstrated in Washington, D.C., in a bid to get the Federal Communications Commission's attention. But it has focused most of its energy in West Virginia. The deal is structured so that if any state involved disapproves the spin-off it will fall through, and the union chose West Virginia because virtually all of the landlines there are owned by either Frontier, which control 147,000 lines, or Verizon, which has 617,000 lines. The spinoff would result in Frontier controlling 98% of the state's local-access lines, which the union argues would be anticompetitive. The CWA also points out that several other assets spun off by Verizon in recent years have ended up in bankruptcy reorganization. As part of the deal, Frontier agreed to pay Verizon shareholders $5.3 billion in stock, and give the company $3.3 billion in cash from a future debt offering. Frontier, based in Stamford, Conn., would more than triple its size through the transaction. Debt offerings have been a problem for past Verizon spinoffs. Verizon's spinoff of its Hawaiian assets to Hawaiian Telcom Communications Inc. ultimately led to the Hawaiian company's bankruptcy in late 2008. Last March, Verizon's phone-directory business, now called SuperMedia Inc., filed for bankruptcy protection after struggling with $9 billion in debt. FairPoint Communications Inc., which acquired New England landline assets of Verizon, entered Chapter 11 reorganization in October. "There's a failing track record," said CWA district vice president Ron Collins. "They leave communities high and dry." Frontier, however, has argued that Verizon's assets will get the company close to an investment-grade debt rating, because its percentage of debt to the total business will fall through the purchase. "It's a really good thing for our company," Mr. Crosby said. He added that Frontier's experience in providing high-speed Internet service will help it in upgrading the Verizon lines. Still, the string of past troubles with Verizon spinoffs led to an Illinois administrative law judge recommending the Illinois Commerce Commission reject the deal. The commission was expected to make a ruling on Wednesday, but pushed back the decision. Officials in Washington, another state needed to approve the deal, have also expressed concern. The West Virginia Public Service Commission has the final say on that state's approval. The commission's staff has recommended against the deal. The commission, which isn't obligated to follow the recommendation, expects to make its ruling later this month or in early May. Verizon has been selling slower-growth businesses that don't fit with its core focus on wireless and FiOS fiber-optic service. The Frontier deal represents the last major transaction that would slim Verizon down to its faster-growing parts. Because of Verizon's history of completing deals few predict a major delay. William Power, an analyst at Robert W. Baird & Co., called the issues in Illinois and West Virginia "a minor hold-up." -- ================================ George Antunes, Political Science Dept University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927 Mail: antunes at uh dot edu _______________________________________________ Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
