http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-ct-spectrum13-2010apr13,0,6551342.story

An offer TV station owners can't refuse?
Broadcasters fear that an FCC plan for them to give up some of their 
rights to the public airwaves would cost them future revenue.

By Joe Flint
Los Angeles Times

April 13, 2010



For decades, owning television stations, with their fat profit margins, 
was a license to print money.

But the growth of cable and now broadband has lured away TV viewers and 
made stations less profitable. Finding new sources of revenue is 
crucial, and broadcasters are counting on -- and jealously guarding -- 
their slice of the public airwaves as the conduit for that future 
revenue via new channels and services. Any loss of that spectrum, they 
fear, would cost them potential income.

That fear will be on full display Tuesday as broadcasters, gathering in 
Las Vegas for their annual convention, hear Federal Communications 
Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski outline his plans for a broadband 
future. It's a future they feel might not include them.

Specifically, the FCC says it needs 120 megahertz of spectrum currently 
allocated to TV stations to allow for faster mobile devices and better 
broadband service. It wants TV stations to voluntarily hand over the 
rights to some of their airwaves, which the FCC would then auction to 
telecommunications firms, sharing the proceeds with the broadcasters.

If stations don't voluntarily give up the bandwidth, the FCC is prepared 
to recover it through other methods, though Genachowski has been vague 
about just how the agency would go about it.

Genachowski's plan for a faster Internet and better smart phones -- and 
with it the suggestion that TV stations surrender some of their spectrum 
to make that happen -- reminds the industry's top lobbyist of Vito 
Corleone's definition of "voluntary."

"Either your signature or your brains will be on the contract," said 
National Assn. of Broadcasters President Gordon Smith, paraphrasing the 
"Godfather" mafia don, when talking about Genachowski's pitch.

Hyperbole for sure, but the TV industry insists that it needs those 
airwaves for its long-term survival and that, contrary to what the FCC 
says, there's no shortage of spectrum for broadband and mobile services.

Critics have long contended that broadcasters already fall short of 
their public-service mandate. Local news is largely driven by 
sensational coverage of crime and celebrities, they say, and stations 
have largely abandoned children's and educational programming.

A chunk of broadcasters' spectrum is used to transmit high-definition TV 
signals, which require more bandwidth than standard signals. Some 
stations also use their spectrum for channels featuring 24-hour weather, 
foreign language programming or reruns. And down the road, TV stations 
hope to offer content for mobile phones, laptops and even screens 
embedded in automobile seat backs, using even more spectrum.

"We're very active on all these fronts," said Alan Frank, president of 
Post-Newsweek Stations, which uses some of its spectrum to carry a 
Spanish-language channel on its Florida and Texas stations and recently 
started offering mobile television in Detroit.

A top FCC official says that the agency's request is totally voluntary, 
and that comparing it to mob persuasion is overwrought.

"There are some myths with respect to what is being proposed. . . . 
Participating is entirely the decision of the station owner," said Colin 
Crowell, senior counsel to Genachowski.

The agency clearly wants to boost broadband and mobile as more people 
turn to devices that use those technologies. Crowell noted that "a 
hundred million people are actively using Facebook from their mobile 
devices . . . [so] there is no question of the demand on mobile networks 
and need for more spectrum."

In a speech to the New America Foundation in February, Genachowski said 
spectrum "is the oxygen of mobile broadband" and warned there is a 
danger of starving it of the "nourishment it needs to thrive as a 
platform for innovation, job creation and economic growth," repeating 
the assertion that broadcasters were not currently using all the 
spectrum available to them anyway.

Broadcasters interpreted Genachowski's comments as code for them being 
forced to play second fiddle to the phone companies, which, they say, 
would not better society. The TV industry, when asked about how it uses 
its spectrum, often points to the public-service mandate, noting that 
local stations provide news and weather and have to meet regulatory 
guidelines that others do not.

"I'm not sure that the iPhone has the public requirements and all the 
things that are layered onto broadcasters because we are using the 
public airwaves," said Perry Sook, chief executive of Nexstar 
Broadcasting, which owns or operates 62 local TV stations. 
Post-Newsweek's Frank complained that the government wants the spectrum 
to speed up the delivery of the latest video games to "some teenage boy 
locked in his room."

Genachowski submitted his broadband plan last month to Congress, which 
will decide whether broadcasters should return some spectrum.

A former broadcaster himself, Genachowski probably will choose his words 
carefully in his address Tuesday. But even that seemingly benign word 
"voluntary" can be a lightning rod.

"I was in the Army," said Post-Newsweek's Frank. "I understand 
'voluntary' very well."

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to