FCC should keep pressing for network neutrality among Internet providers: editorial
By The Cleveland Plain Dealer Editorial Board April 18, 2010, 4:29AM http://www.cleveland.com/opinion/index.ssf/2010/04/fcc_should_keep_pressing_for_n.html A federal appeals court recently dug a deep pothole in the Internet's freedom of the road, with a ruling that should have the Federal Communications Commission rushing to amend the standard by which it polices some commercial aspects of the Web. Specifically, the April 6 ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit handicaps the commission in its bid to require "network neutrality" of Internet service providers. The court decided federal law doesn't give the FCC specific power to police "network management" by Internet service providers -- that is, when ISPs tweak the Internet's speed or clarity or content to give the Internet provider commercial advantages. Ostensibly on principle, but in fact for financial reasons, the ISPs oppose network neutrality. They surely welcomed the court ruling, which The New York Times reported, "will let Internet service companies . . . block or slow specific sites and charge video sites such as YouTube to deliver their content faster to users." At issue was a dispute between Comcast Corp. and the FCC. Subscribers to Comcast high-speed Internet service discovered Comcast had slowed their access to a peer-to-peer application named BitTorrent. The FCC has said it "received 22,284 e-mail complaints about Comcast's practices," which, the commission claimed, breached an FCC "Internet Policy Statement." The appeals court said the Internet Policy Statement says "consumers are entitled to access the lawful Internet content of their choice . . . [and] to run applications and use services of their choice." Comcast complied with a 2008 FCC order to make network-management disclosures to consumers. But Comcast also asked the circuit court to review the legal bases for the FCC's action. A three-judge panel ruled unanimously that the FCC didn't have any -- at least none strong enough. Comcast said in a press statement it was "gratified by the court's decision." The FCC, however, correctly notes that the judges did not "close the door to other methods" of ensuring an open Internet. Indeed, seemingly anticipating the adverse ruling, the FCC unveiled a draft"" of new network-neutrality rules on Oct. 22 -- a draft that is still pending. Network neutrality is very much like the "common carrier" standards applied to telephone service: If the content or origin of a message is otherwise legal, its "carrier" may not (based on content alone) choose to send it slower or faster than another message (by, for instance, letting a Web site or online service the ISP itself owns cut in line). A network neutrality standard is the correct standard, a standard the FCC should shape to meet any legal challenge. Net neutrality is the right standard for the same reason that the 1927 Radio Act -- which led to today's FCC -- defined a public interest in broadcasting: "To stake out the public's claims," one historian said, "before private interests could induce the courts to post 'no trespass' signs." -- ================================ George Antunes, Political Science Dept University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927 Mail: antunes at uh dot edu _______________________________________________ Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
