The Teachers' Unions' Last Stand

By STEVEN BRILL
The New York Times
May 17, 2010

MICHAEL MULGREW is an affable former Brooklyn vocational-high-school 
teacher who took over last year as head of New York City's United 
Federation of Teachers when his predecessor, Randi Weingarten, moved 
to Washington to run the national American Federation of Teachers. 
Over breakfast in March, we talked about a movement spreading across 
the country to hold public-school teachers accountable by 
compensating, promoting or even removing them according to the 
results they produce in class, as measured in part by student test 
scores. Mulgrew's 165-page union contract takes the opposite 
approach. It not only specifies everything that teachers will do and 
will not do during a six-hour-57 -minute workday but also requires 
that teachers be paid based on how long they have been on the job. 
Once they've been teaching for three years and judged satisfactory in 
a process that invariably judges all but a few of them satisfactory, 
they are ensured lifetime tenure.

Next to Mulgrew was his press aide, Richard Riley. "Suppose you 
decide that Riley is lazy or incompetent," I asked Mulgrew. "Should 
you be able to fire him?"

"He's not a teacher," Mulgrew responded. "And I need to be able to 
pick my own person for a job like that." Then he grinned, adding: "I 
know where you're going, but you don't understand. Teachers are just 
different."

That is the kind of story that makes Jon Schnur smile. Schnur, who 
runs a Manhattan-based school-reform group called New Leaders for New 
Schools, sits informally at the center of a network of self-styled 
reformers dedicated to overhauling public education in the United 
States. They have been building in strength and numbers over the last 
two decades and now seem to be planted everywhere that counts. They 
are working in key positions in school districts and charter-school 
networks, legislating in state capitals, staffing city halls and 
statehouses for reform-minded mayors and governors, writing papers 
for policy groups and dispensing grants from billion-dollar 
philanthropies like the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Bill 
Gates, along with Education Secretary Arne Duncan; Teach for 
America's founder, Wendy Kopp; and the New York City schools 
chancellor Joel Klein could be considered the patron saints of the 
network.

Over the last several months, Schnur and the well-positioned fellow 
travelers on his speed dial have seen the cause of their lives take 
center stage. Why the sudden shift from long-simmering wonk debate to 
political front burner? Because there is now a president who, when it 
comes to school reform, really does seem to be a new kind of Democrat 
- and because of a clever idea Schnur had last year to package what 
might otherwise have been just another federal grant program into a 
media-alluring, if cheesy-sounding, contest called Race to the Top. 
It has turned a relatively modest federal program (the $4.3 billion 
budget represents less than 1 percent of all federal, state and local 
education spending) into high-yield leverage that could end up 
overshadowing health care reform in its impact and that is already 
upending traditional Democratic Party politics. The activity set off 
by the contest has enabled Schnur's network to press as never before 
its frontal challenge to the teachers' unions: they argue that a 
country that spends more per pupil than any other but whose student 
performance ranks in the bottom third among developed nations isn't 
failing its children for lack of resources but for lack of trained, 
motivated, accountable talent at the front of the class.

...

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/23/magazine/23Race-t.html

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to