Screwed if by Sea
A 90-year-old maritime law gets BP off the hook for workers killed on the 
Deepwater rig.

By Stephanie Mencimer
Slate.com

Posted Wednesday, June 16, 2010, at 1:43 PM ET

http://www.slate.com/id/2257213/



After a BP refinery in Texas exploded in 2005, killing 15 workers and 
injuring scores more, the oil giant paid $1.6 billion in settlements to 
employees and their families. But the families of the workers killed on 
BP's Deepwater Horizon rig in the Gulf of Mexico probably won't receive a 
similar windfall. That's because the Deepwater rig is legally considered an 
oceangoing vessel and was more three nautical miles offshore at the time of 
the accident. As a result, the families of the dead workers can only sue BP 
and its contractors under a 90-year-old maritime law, the Death on the High 
Seas Act, which severely limits liability. In some cases, BP could get away 
with shelling out sums as paltry as $1,000.

Gordon Jones, a mud engineer killed on the Deepwater rig, left behind a 
pregnant wife who had quit her job to stay home with their 2-year-old son. 
But thanks to DOHSA, the most BP could owe them is the equivalent of 
Gordon's salary over his working life, minus what he would have paid out in 
taxes and personal expenses. So if Gordon made $60,000 a year for the next 
30 years, BP could owe the family less than a million dollars.

The math works out even worse for workers without dependents. Jones' 
brother Chris testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee that one of 
the other Deepwater workers who was killed was single and childless. That 
means his family would only be entitled to recover funeral expenses under 
DOHSA. But because his body was never recovered after the explosion, the 
funeral costs will be lower. BP could end up paying his family as little as 
$1,000 for their loss.

Chris and his father Keith have pleaded with Congress to fix the law so 
that any employer can be held accountable for negligence—regardless of 
whether an employee dies on land or at sea. Last week, Senate Judiciary 
chair Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., introduced legislation that would do just that.

But Leahy's bill faces an ugly political fight. And giant oil 
corporations—the most obvious potential opponents of such legislation—may 
not even have to flex their lobbying muscle. There's another powerful 
industry with an interest in doing BP's dirty work to preserve the status 
quo. That would be cruise line operators—and when it comes to Beltway 
battles, the cruise lobby is no Love Boat.

Just ask Son Michael Pham, the vice president of the International Cruise 
Victims Association. In 2005, his parents went on a Caribbean cruise and 
never came back. Carnival Cruise Line, one of the world's largest cruise 
operators, never offered any explanation for what had happened, and has 
refused to discuss the incident with Pham and his family since then. That 
was how Pham discovered the horrible divide in the way the law treats 
people killed through negligence at sea. "We couldn't take legal action to 
get justice," he says. Long before the BP explosion, his group was lobbying 
Congress for DOHSA to be overhauled.

DOHSA was created in 1920 to ensure that the widows and children of seamen 
could get a share of their husbands' or fathers' salaries if they were 
killed at sea. The law was rather progressive for its time: Previously, the 
corporations didn't have to pay the widows anything at all. But DOHSA 
didn't change with the times. And because it's a federal law, it trumps 
state tort laws that allow injured people to recover all sorts of damages 
in personal injury cases, including punitive damages for truly egregious 
corporate behavior, compensation for grief or the loss of companionship, 
and even the pre-death pain and suffering of the victim.

DOHSA has been updated once, in 2000, when TWA Flight 800 crashed off the 
coast of New York, killing a host of children. Their families had had no 
legal rights to force the airline to pay out, because the kids didn't have 
income. That year, Congress amended DOHSA, but only to allow commercial 
airline victims to sue for noneconomic damages. The families of other folks 
killed at sea were still out in the cold.

Finally, in 2009, the cruise ship victims succeeded in getting legislation 
introduced with help from Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., that would have updated 
DOHSA in just the way Leahy has proposed. That change would have allowed 
families of cruise ship victims to sue for noneconomic damages—a huge deal 
for cruise-goers, because so many are retired and have no salaries that 
would provide the basis of a legal award under the current law. It also 
would have saved the Jones family a trip to Washington, D.C., to plead 
their case on behalf of Gordon's widow and children.

But the cruise industry spent $2.2 million fighting these changes. The 
Carnival cruise line company alone has donated more than $400,000 since 
2007 to members of Congress from both parties, according to the Center for 
Responsive Politics. The offending provision was eventually removed from 
the cruise-ship safety bill.

The Cruise Lines International Association did not return requests for 
comment. But Pham says he has no doubt that the DOHSA revision will not 
slip by without the lobbyists' notice. "Cruise lines absolutely didn't want 
DOHSA to be part of that [2009 bill] at all," he says, noting that the 
industry would suddenly become liable for all sorts of incidents that it's 
currently able to dodge legal responsibility for—everything from onboard 
murders to rapes to mysterious disappearances like that of Pham's parents. 
"It's an industry that self-polices. When there's an incident on board, 
there's nobody but themselves investigating themselves. You're not going to 
turn yourself in."

Pham suggests that perhaps his group should join forces with the families 
of the deceased Deepwater workers. "Hopefully the current issue with BP 
will keep this issue in front and create more public awareness," he says. 
But, as he points, it's unfortunate that it "takes a tragic incident like 
[the Gulf spill] for people to realize they've been taking this for granted."


Article URL: http://www.slate.com/id/2257213/


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to