[These proposed changes could do for broadcasting and the Internet what 
banking deregulation did for the American economy. We have already seen 
what happened to radio when the FCC abolished most ownership rules.]

Conservative think tank: abolish net neutrality, gut FCC powers

By Matthew Lasar
Ars Technica

Feb 3, 2011

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/02/heritage-foundation-says-abolish-key-fcc-powers.ars


One of the nation's top conservative think tanks has issued a report 
urging Congress to review 20 "unnecessary and harmful regulations" that 
the group says should be clipped as soon as possible. Three of the 20 
are administered by the Federal Communications Commission, notes the 
Heritage Foundation's new Rolling Back Red Tape backgrounder, and 
involve oversight over ISPs and media acquisitions.

"This regulatory tide must be reversed," Heritage's Dianne Katz 
concludes. "Policy­makers should not just prevent harmful new 
regulations, but must repeal costly and unnecessary rules already on the 
books."

Here are the three FCC-related powers on the list.
Net neutrality

No surprise that Heritage gives the FCC's new Open Internet Order top 
billing for repeal. The agency released the rules in December, and even 
though they exempt wireless broadband from any unreasonable 
discrimination provisions, Verizon and MetroPCS are suing the FCC anyway.

Rescind them, says Heritage, and block the FCC from spending any 
appropriated money to enforce the provisions.

"The new rules would hobble the ability of network owners to efficiently 
manage traffic flows, as well as chill the investment needed to keep the 
Internet growing," the report warns. "The end result: a slower and less 
dynamic Web. In addition, the rules give the government a role in 
deciding how content is treated on the Web, potentially threatening the 
free flow of information."
Media ownership rules

Over the last 70 years, both Congress and the FCC have enacted rules 
limiting the number of television and radio stations any single entity 
can own. These include a "dual network ban" going back to the World War 
II era that restricted any company to the ownership of one network (the 
target was NBC, which dropped a rib that eventually became ABC).

Companies like Clear Channel have long opposed the Commission's 
provision limiting the number of radio stations an entity can buy in any 
one market. The government's newspaper/TV station cross-ownership rule 
has been a particularly hot topic. The FCC is currently reviewing all 
these regulations, as the agency must every four years.

Heritage says the cross-ownership rule has definitely got to go.

"Most of these rules are decades old, dating back as far as 1941. The 
media world, however, has changed dramatically since that time," the 
report contends. "In such a world, ownership restrictions on media 
outlets make little sense." Competitive problems can be handled via the 
Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission.
FCC merger review authority

Through the long process approving the Comcast/NBC Universal merger, 
conservatives argued that the government was hamstringing the new entity 
with unnecessary public interest conditions. Among them: the merger 
agreement stipulates that the new Comcast can't "exercise corporate 
control over or unreasonably withhold programming from Hulu," which it 
will now partially own.

But the report insists that Comcast and NBCU didn't compete with each 
other. "Congress should restrict the FCC's authority to review license 
transfers to a simple confirmation that the new licensee is eligible to 
hold the license," Heritage concludes.

The Heritage Foundation is not alone in its disdain for the FCC's 
regulatory powers. On the first day of the new Congress, Rep. Marsha 
Blackburn (R-TN) introduced a bill that would bar  the Commission from 
any further regulation of the Internet. With the Democrats still in 
charge of the Senate, prospects for legislation that limits the FCC's 
powers making it to President Obama's desk seem remote.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to