February 3, 2011

Court Advised to Permit Viewers Access to Pay-TV From Any Broadcaster
By ERIC PFANNER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/04/technology/04iht-premier04.html?ref=technology&pagewanted=print


PARIS — In a move that could tear down national borders in the European 
television business, an adviser to the top European Union court said 
Thursday that viewers should have the right to buy pay-TV broadcasts 
from any provider within the 27-nation bloc.

European television markets now are divided along national lines, with 
rights to popular programming like professional soccer matches and 
Hollywood movies sold to pay-TV providers country by country. The court 
adviser said such arrangements were incompatible with the European 
Union’s single market in goods and services.

“The exclusivity rights in question have the effect of partitioning the 
internal market into quite separate national markets, something which 
constitutes a serious impairment of the freedom to provide services,” 
the European Court of Justice said in a statement explaining the 
recommendation, by an “advocate general,” Juliane Kokott.

Many people across Europe already watch satellite television from 
foreign providers in homes or pubs, circumventing domestic services with 
the use of decoding devices to unscramble signals. In Britain, some pubs 
buy decoders to show Greek satellite broadcasts of English Premier 
League soccer matches, undercutting Sky, whose broadcasts of the same 
matches cost more.

In a case before the European court, the owner of such a pub, in 
Southsea, England, was sued by the Premier League, which has a 
three-year, £1.78 billion, or $2.89 billion, domestic rights deal with 
British Sky Broadcasting, whose biggest shareholder is News Corp., and 
the ESPN sports network, which is owned by Walt Disney. The league earns 
hundreds of millions of pounds in revenue from international rights 
sales. In a related case, the league sued suppliers of foreign satellite 
decoders in Britain.

The opinions of an advocate general are not binding, but the court 
follows them in the vast majority of cases. If it does this time, the 
implications for rights holders could be significant, said Paul Dixon, a 
lawyer for Karen Murphy, the pub’s owner. “This would make it unlawful 
to partition the European television market into different territories,” 
Mr. Dixon said. “Any citizen of the E.U. could buy any television 
service from any provider in the E.U.”

Such an outcome might please European Union lawmakers in Brussels, who 
want to break down barriers to a single E.U. media market, including 
licensing restrictions. For rights owners, including sports leagues and 
Hollywood studios, however, it could be a big financial blow, because 
selling their rights in individual territories has proved lucrative.

The Premier League reacted with alarm to the advocate general’s opinion.

“If the European Commission wants to create a pan-European licensing 
model for sports, film and music, then it must go through the proper 
consultative and legislative processes to change the law rather than 
attempting to force through legislative changes via the courts,” the 
league said in a statement.

Tim Westcott, an analyst at Screen Digest in London, said that if the 
court went along with the advocate general’s opinion, any liberalization 
of the market might be most relevant to pubs and other public venues, 
which have to pay more for pay-TV subscriptions than individual 
consumers do.

The market for cross-border pay-TV services in the home might be limited 
largely to expatriates, some of whom already receive signals from their 
home countries via so-called gray market solutions, he said. Policing 
this is more difficult than in pubs, because rights holders cannot enter 
homes to see what is on TV.

“Everyone knows that this happens, but it’s hard to stop it,” Mr. 
Westcott said.

Rights holders argue that there is little demand for a pan-European 
television market because viewers want to see programming with local 
cultural relevance, including, for example, sports commentary in their 
own language. Some British pubs that receive Premier League broadcasts 
from foreign broadcasters get around this problem by turning down the 
sound and using local radio broadcasts, instead.

While cross-border competition could hurt rights holders by undermining 
the value of territorial deals, analysts say a pan-European market could 
help broadcasters with a presence in several markets, like News Corp., 
which owns the leading pay-TV company in Italy and also is the largest 
shareholder in the biggest German pay-TV provider. News Corp. wants to 
take over full control of Sky in Britain, but that deal is still under 
review by the government.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to