February 5, 2011

Online Courses, Still Lacking That Third Dimension
By RANDALL STROSS
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/06/business/06digi.html?ref=business&src=me&pagewanted=print


WHEN colleges and universities finally decide to make full use of the 
Internet, most professors will lose their jobs.

That includes me. I’m not worried, though, at least for the moment. Amid 
acute budget crises, state universities like mine can’t afford to take 
that very big step — adopting the technology that renders human 
instructors obsolete.

I began teaching classes online 10 years ago, but the term “online” is 
misleading. What I really mean is that I teach a hybrid course: part 
software, part hovering human. A genuine online course would be nothing 
but the software and would handle all the grading, too. No living, 
breathing instructor would be needed for oversight.

“We should focus on having at least one great course online for each 
subject rather than lots of mediocre courses,” Bill Gates suggested in 
his 2010 annual letter for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Developing that best-in-the-world online course — in which students 
would learn as much, or more, than in an ordinary classroom or a hybrid 
online class — requires significant investment. The Open Learning 
Initiative at Carnegie Mellon University, which has developed about 15 
sophisticated online courses, mostly in the sciences, spent $500,000 to 
$1 million to write software for each. But neither Carnegie Mellon nor 
other institutions, which are invited to use its online courses, dares 
to use them without having a human instructor, too.

For at least 50 years, the computer has been experimentally employed as 
the unflaggingly patient, attentive teaching assistant. In 1960, the 
University of Illinois created Plato, pioneering courseware whose 
offerings would eventually span the elementary-school through college 
levels. It and its software successors have supplied individualized 
pacing, frequent quizzing and help that is tailored to each student’s 
needs. Computer-aided instruction, however, has lacked a human touch.

Separately, many universities have put free videos online featuring 
their best lecturers. And Academic Earth, an aggregator Web site founded 
in 2009, makes the lectures easy to navigate. It says it offers 150 full 
university courses.

But even when lectures are accompanied with syllabuses, handouts, sample 
problem sets and other aids that Academic Earth has for some of its 
courses, is the experience really complete? The Massachusetts Institute 
of Technology also shares the raw materials of courses in its 
OpenCourseWare program. For the benefit of autodidacts who aren’t M.I.T. 
students, it strives to publish materials online for every M.I.T. 
course. But students cannot interact and do not receive vital feedback 
about their own progress that an instructor or software provides.

“Unlocking the Gates,” by Taylor Walsh (Princeton University Press) is a 
recently published history of M.I.T.’s online venture, as well as those 
of Columbia, Harvard, Yale, the University of California, Berkeley, and 
others. Comparing the book’s case studies, I found that Carnegie Mellon 
seems to have made the most progress in developing fully self-contained 
online courses. Anyone can use them free, with the proviso that Carnegie 
Mellon doesn’t offer credit.

But course credit can be earned at other institutions if instructors 
send their students to the site. Students pay nominal course 
registration fees, generally $15 to $60, and Carnegie Mellon sends data 
about each student’s progress to the instructor at the student’s home 
institution.

Carnegie Mellon, however, does not use these online courses as 
replacements for its own humanoid instructors. “Any tuition-driven, 
private university would have a hard time being the first one to make a 
change as drastic as offering an entirely automated course,” Ms. Walsh 
told me recently.

Candace Thille, the director of Carnegie Mellon’s program, put it this 
way: “There is something motivating about the student’s relationship 
with the instructor — and with the student’s relationship with other 
students in the class — that would be absent if each took the course in 
a software-only environment.”

Those relationships — with humans in the flesh — help students to 
persevere. Online courses are notorious for high dropout rates.

Much, of course, depends on the subject being taught. An introductory 
statistics class taught to 600 students in a lecture hall won’t offer 
much of a relationship with the professor. Moving it into a 
self-contained, adaptive software package — Carnegie Mellon’s online 
program offers two statistics classes — would arguably offer a superior 
learning experience. But in this case, the subject matter is distillable 
into a handful of concepts, and the exams use questions with only a 
single correct answer. That’s not an option for just about all of the 
humanities and vast swaths of the social sciences.

LAST year, the Regents of the University of California approved a 
proposal to test the viability of offering a bachelor’s degree that 
could be earned entirely online.

Wendy Brown, the Heller professor of political science at the Berkeley 
campus, spoke witheringly of the idea at a campus forum in October: 
“What is sacrificed when classrooms disappear, the place where good 
teachers do not merely ‘deliver content’ to students but wake them up, 
throw them on their feet and pull the chair away? Where ideas can become 
intoxicating, where an instructor’s ardor for a subject or a dimension 
of the world can be contagious? Where scientific, literary, ethical or 
political passions are ignited?”

If administrators at many state universities ever secure the funds to 
make capital investments again, they may be ready to look anew at the 
shelf where those wholly self-contained courses now sit. My job is safe, 
I think. Carnegie Mellon hasn’t yet developed software for the courses I 
teach — thank goodness.

-------------------------
Randall Stross is an author based in Silicon Valley and a professor of 
business at San Jose State University.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to