[One for the weird file.]

Just say no ... to robot marriage?

Robert Broadus of Protect Marriage Maryland used the "Star Trek" 
argument in his testimony against gay-marriage legislation.

By Alan Boyle
MSNBC.COM Science Editor

Feb 11, 2011

http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/02/11/6034141-just-say-no-to-robot-marriage


In a case of life imitating "Futurama," Maryland's gay-marriage debate 
has somehow morphed into worries about robot-human marriages.

The rant against robosexuals came during Robert Broadus' testimony 
against the gay-marriage legislation currently before Maryland 
legislature. "If you pass this bill, you will set the groundwork, that 
one day when artificial intelligence is that advanced, we will be 
considering whether or not people can marry their androids. ... If you 
say that any two people who love each other can get married, then you 
set that precedent," said Broadus, who heads Protect Marriage Maryland.

To make his case, Broadus referred to Lieutenant Commander Data's 
ability to feel emotion and shed a tear in "Star Trek: Generations," a 
science-fiction movie. "You laugh, but it's true," Broadus said.

For better or worse, sex with robots is already a reality, although the 
robots in question are really just glorified blow-up dolls. Researchers 
have long discussed whether there might come a day (maybe 2050?) when 
true love could exist between humans and artificially intelligent 
machines. In recent years, however, the idea of building robots that 
look and think like humans isn't as, um, sexy as it once was.

"The robotics field is away from that approach and geared toward 
specific applications," said Anne Foerst, a computer science professor 
at St. Bonaventure University in New York who has been dubbed "the robot 
theologian." (And yes, she does hold a degree in theology as well as 
computer science and philosophy.)

In the old days, roboticists could build cute-eyed machines like Cog, 
Kismet and Leonardo to test the boundaries between biological and 
mechanical beings. MIT's Leonardo, an Ewok-like robot, could even pass 
some of the psychological tests aimed at studying social cognition in 
children.

That kind of research "is pretty much dead right now, which is very 
sad,"  Foerst told me.

"You basically get applications, and applications which in my opinion 
are much less interesting," she said. "Those machines do not raise any 
questions of personhood, because they don't have anywhere to go. ... The 
reason why is that the funding has changed."

For better or worse, it seems that the folks funding the research are 
more interested in real-world results rather than the prospects for 
robot romance. Who knows? Maybe the academic debate over sex and 
marriage with robots will be revived in 2050, or more likely 2150. But 
in any case, Broadus needn't worry about robosexuals anytime soon.

"Gay relationships obviously consist of mutual give and take," Foerst 
observed. "They're equal partners, and that's completely different from 
robotics. To apply human-android research to gay marriage is, in my 
opinion ridiculous."

Foerst is apparently not the only person who feels that way. 
Lezgetreal's Bridgette P. LaVictoire reports that Maryland state Sen. 
James Brochin changed his mind and decided to vote for the gay-marriage 
legislation after hearing the "appalling and disgusting" testimony 
against it.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to