Feb 13, 2011

Paying for cell phone spam

By Jeff Gelles
Philadelphia Inquirer Business Columnist


http://www.philly.com/philly/business/columnists/20110213_Consumer_10_0__Paying_for_cell_phone_spam.html


The messages read like the thousands of spam e-mails many of us have 
gotten for years on our computers - or would get if we didn't have 
elaborate spam filters standing in their way.

"Get $1500 in Extra Cash Sent Immediately!" said one, directing 
recipients to a website to follow through on the fabulous offer.

"Confirmation," began the other, with that classic spam ruse that 
suggests you're hearing from a company you've already contacted. "Please 
Call 877-803-XXXX" - I'm hiding the last four digits to protect the 
guilty - "For your Walmart and Visa Gift Cards."

Len Weinstein didn't bite, of course. Rather, he felt bitten. These 
weren't the usual spams to his e-mail address. They were texts on his 
mobile phone, and as such they were costing him cash.

What happened next made matters worse. Hoping to stem the texts at their 
source, lest the 20-cent fees start multiplying, he tried reaching the 
senders - and got billed $4 or $5 each for international calls. Although 
they had ordinary-looking numbers, both were based in Canada.

Nor was AT&T Mobility much help - at least till he complained to the 
Federal Communications Commission and got his concerns bumped up to the 
executive level.

The first Customer Care reps all outlined three lousy choices. The 
common thread: All dumped cost or hassle back on him.

Weinstein could change his number, an inconvenience that would work only 
till the spammers found him again. He could block all texts, and lose a 
useful tool for in-a-pinch communications with his wife and daughters. 
Or he could buy a monthly texting plan.

I didn't do much better when I first got hold of AT&T. The only other 
option that spokeswoman Brandy Bell mentioned was signing up for "Smart 
Limits for Wireless," a program that allows subscribers to block texts 
from particular numbers. The cost: $4.99 a month - the same as 200 texts.

To Weinstein, the issue was about principle, not money. Why should he 
pay anything for unwanted telemarketing - and more if the floodgates 
ever open?

"It's not a function of the dollar amount. That's not a big deal," he 
says. "The big deal is that somebody has sold this phone number, and 
it's just going to spread."

What the law says
Cell phone spam may fly largely under the radar, but it's long been seen 
as a problem - like e-mail spam, but with a price tag for consumers who 
pay by the text.

In a 2003 order, the FCC said unsolicited commercial texts were barred 
by the same law, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, that prohibits 
voice telemarketing to cell phones.

The only exceptions, the FCC says, are texts sent for emergency 
purposes, or if the receiving party "has given prior express consent to 
the caller." There's not even an exception for texters who can claim an 
"established business relationship," one of the larger loopholes under 
the rules limiting marketing calls to land lines listed on the federal 
Do Not Call list.

As with many spam and telemarketing issues, a key problem is what 
consumers can do about it. And that's where consumers such as Weinstein 
are stymied.

AT&T and its competitors seem to downplay the problem.

"We do see customers' complaints about spam periodically," Verizon 
Wireless' Sheldon Jones said via e-mail. But he said such complaints 
were "a small percentage of the total customer service 'hot buttons' we 
deal with."

AT&T's Bell was more emphatic.

"This is a rare situation, but we do understand his frustration," Bell 
told me. "It's not something we're hearing about on a regular basis as a 
customer complaint."

Nor is there evidence that federal regulators have done much about it - 
including the FCC and the Federal Trade Commission, which has filed more 
than 60 cases against large-scale violators of the do-not-call rules but 
which hasn't decided whether being on the do-not-call list should 
protect you from unwelcome marketing texts.

But that could - and should - change.

How to raise awareness
Unwanted texts are probably a low-level annoyance to most of us, much 
like spam e-mail and illegal telemarketing - something to grouse about 
but ignore unless it reaches unbearable levels.

If your e-mail filters miss the occasional "herbal Viagra" ad, or you 
get an illegal marketing robocall, chances are that you grin and bear 
it. But if you paid by the pitch, you'd probably take notice, as 
Weinstein did. The question is, what could you do?

Right now, the FCC's answer is to file a complaint, which you can do 
online at www.fcc.gov or by calling 1-888-225-5322 - a number whose 
voice tree mentions "unwanted faxes and unwanted telephone calls" but 
doesn't say a word about unwanted texts.

But there's another approach, like the one the FTC took a dozen years 
ago when it asked e-mail users to start forwarding spam to it. You can 
still do that: About 44 million e-mails were forwarded last year to 
"[email protected]," an FTC spokeswoman says.

Can you forward illegal text messages to the FCC or FTC? Not now, both 
agencies say - unless you can manage to cut and paste them into a 
complaint, an unwieldy process.

Ironically, AT&T Mobility does allow its customers to forward unwanted 
commercial texts to a short-code address: SPAM, or 7726. Weinstein 
talked to three AT&T service reps before someone finally brought it up. 
And Bell, albeit a new employee, didn't mention it either until I asked.

It's a dirty job to set up a repository to track unwanted, illegal 
texts. But somebody has to do it.


Find this article at:
http://www.philly.com/philly/business/columnists/20110213_Consumer_10_0__Paying_for_cell_phone_spam.html

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to