February 13, 2011

Goal in Europe Is Unified Broadcast-Rights Market
By ERIC PFANNER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/14/business/media/14cache.html?ref=technology&pagewanted=print


LONDON — In 1995, a Belgian soccer player named Jean-Marc Bosman set off 
a revolution in the European game despite being only a modest performer 
on the playing field.

When his Belgian club, Liège, blocked him from moving to a French team 
that wanted to hire him, Mr. Bosman went to court. In a case that made 
its way to the European Court of Justice, the highest tribunal in the 
European Union, Mr. Bosman won the right to switch. The court also 
struck down quotas requiring that clubs field a minimum number of 
domestic players, clearing the way for the polyglot squads that dominate 
today.

Now a British pub owner named Karen Murphy may have started another 
soccer revolution, one with broader implications for the media industry. 
In another case before the European court, pitting her against the 
English Premier League, Ms. Murphy this month received the support of an 
“advocate general,” or legal expert.

The league pursued legal action against Ms. Murphy after she showed 
televised soccer matches in her pub in Portsmouth from a Greek satellite 
broadcaster, rather than from the authorized local rights holder.

Ms. Murphy argues that British Sky Broadcasting, the pay-television 
company that shares Premier League rights in Britain with ESPN, charges 
too much. She says she should be able to turn to less expensive 
alternatives within the European Union, just as online shoppers in 
Britain can buy less costly shoes from Web sites in Italy.

The advocate general, Juliane Kokott, agreed with her and said other 
barriers that now balkanize the European television landscape should be 
torn down, too. Geographical licensing restrictions, which grant 
broadcasters exclusive rights to show soccer, television shows, movies 
or other programming within a certain country, are incompatible with 
E.U. law, she wrote.

If the court goes along with the advocate general, as it usually does, 
the potential implications are huge.

Rights holders, including sports leagues and Hollywood studios, benefit 
from the current system in Europe, in which they sell their content 
through separate agreements with broadcasters in as many of the 27 E.U. 
countries as possible. The sum of the parts is greater than the whole. 
Broadcasters are willing to pay a premium if they know they have 
geographical exclusivity.

“The value of any television product depends on exclusivity,” said James 
Pickles, editor of TV Sports Markets, a newsletter. “If you can’t 
guarantee that exclusivity, you significantly undermine the value.”

That explains why the Premier League weighed in angrily after Ms. 
Kokott’s opinion was published. It also explains why the Motion Picture 
Association of America, which represents Hollywood studios, and a number 
of European pay-TV companies previously made representations in the case.

On the other hand, the European Commission, on a mission to break down 
barriers to a single E.U. market, weighed in on Ms. Murphy’s side.

A truly borderless E.U. media market may never be more than the stuff of 
Brussels fantasies. Cultural barriers like language could be more 
difficult to surmount than legal restrictions. Another limitation is the 
lack of television companies with pan-European scale.

Aside from RTL, which is controlled by Bertelsmann, and News Corp., 
which owns Sky Italia and controls BSkyB and Sky Deutschland, there are 
few border-straddling television companies in Europe. And RTL, which has 
broadcasting affiliates in Germany, France, the Netherlands and 
elsewhere, recently scaled back its pan-European presence, selling its 
British channel, called Five.

European public broadcasters cooperate across borders, via the European 
Broadcasting Union, which buys the rights to sporting events like the 
World Cup soccer tournament and makes them available to its members.

If the court sides with Ms. Murphy, commercial television companies 
might have to start thinking in more “European” terms, too.

You can already hear the cheers from British pubs.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to