BBC case fuels debate over aging faces on TV

By THOMAS WAGNER
The Associated Press

Feb 12, 2011 11:58PM

http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/money/51230562-79/age-discrimination-bbc-employment.html


London (AP) One colleague offered her hair dye. Another told her “it’s 
time for botox.” A third said her wrinkles could be a problem in this 
new era of high-definition TV.

Veteran TV presenter Miriam O’Reilly was eventually taken off air, and 
she decided to fight back — challenging the venerable BBC in a closely 
watched age-discrimination case. Last month, a British employment 
tribunal ruled in her favor in a decision that provides fodder in a 
growing debate about age-discrimination in TV and film.

“The worldwide trend is to move away from age-based decisions in 
employment,” said Martin Levine, a professor of law and gerontology at 
the University of Southern California, especially as many countries end 
mandatory retirement ages.

“I don’t think any industry, even TV and film, are strong enough to 
stand up to these trends,” he said.

—

New expectations on age

Some media experts believe rapidly aging societies and rising retirement 
ages in the developed world may slowly start reshaping expectations 
about the kinds of faces people expect to see on the screen, opening the 
door to more roles for older people in visual media.

“Age has long been a blind spot because of the cult of youth surrounding 
TV,” said Charlie Beckett, director of the London School of Economics’ 
media think tank, adding the O’Reilly case is just the kind of “wake-up 
call” TV companies need regarding the age of the audience they serve and 
its expectations.

Shifting demographics will change how TV companies such as the BBC 
interpret their markets, their identity and their brand, he said — the 
only question is when.

On Jan. 14, the Employment Tribunal in London found that O’Reilly, a 
BBC-TV veteran, had been the victim of age discrimination when she was 
dropped in March 2009 from “Countryfile,” a rural affairs TV show the 
British Broadcasting Corp. was redesigning and moving to prime time. 
Most, but not all, of the presenters who replaced O’Reilly, then 51, 
were younger than she was.

During the case, witnesses testified about TV’s relentless demand for 
“refreshing faces” and “spring chickens.” O’Reilly told the tribunal she 
was stung by her colleagues’ offhand comments about her need for fixers 
such as hair dye and botox.

The BBC apologized to O’Reilly and offered to discuss future job 
opportunities with her, but the tribunal did not order it to pay damages.

In its judgment, the tribunal said: “The wish to appeal to a prime time 
audience, including younger viewers, is a legitimate aim. However, we do 
not accept that it has been established that choosing younger presenters 
is required to appeal to such an audience. It is not a means of 
achieving that aim.

“Even if it was ... it would not be proportionate to do away with older 
presenters simply to pander the assumed prejudices of some younger viewers.”

—

Age legislation

The U.S. passed its Age Discrimination in Employment Act in 1967. 
Britain didn’t follow suit until 2006. The European Commission has its 
own directive on age and employment, but EU countries normally handle 
discrimination claims according to national law.

In general, such laws bar discrimination based on age in hiring, 
promotions, wages, termination of employment, layoffs and benefits. The 
U.N. says the number of people 65 and older is expected to more than 
double worldwide by 2050.

But age-related employment laws also can work the other way. The United 
States has set mandatory retirement ages for jobs such as commercial 
airline pilots, air traffic controllers and police officers because of 
the skills the jobs require and the safety of the people they serve.

As societies age, debates also have emerged in the United States about 
whether judges and doctors should have mandatory retirement ages, too, 
or even regular cognitive and physical screening, to make sure they 
retain their skills and sharpness of mind into their 70s and beyond.

But in most professions, a 50-something can’t be hired or fired, or 
rejected as a job applicant, simply because the boss would like someone 
younger, as Hollywood recently discovered.

—

Other cases

Last year, 17 TV networks and production studios, and seven talent 
agencies, reached an out-of-court settlement in class-action age 
discrimination lawsuit brought by 165 TV writers.

The companies — including major TV networks and talent agencies — denied 
ever using age discrimination while deciding whether to hire or 
represent the writers. But the settlement, regarding cases dating back 
nearly 10 years, paid the claimants a total of $70 million.

Another U.S. TV personality also has an age discrimination court case 
pending in New York.

In October, Sal Marchiano, a veteran TV sportscaster, filed suit in a 
federal court, accusing a former general manager of WPIX-TV/Channel 11 — 
owned by the Tribune Company — of age discrimination when she did not 
renew his contract in 2008. Marchiano — who is 69, and had worked at the 
station for 14 years — is seeking his job back and damages.

Richard Wald, the Fred Friendly professor of Media and Society at 
Columbia University in New York, says that evolving social attitudes 
have vastly improved the roles and influence that women have in visual 
media in countries such as Britain — and that can be expected to carry 
over to the elderly.

“The truth is that 50-60 years ago, the BBC did not think that a woman’s 
voice carried authority. Therefore no woman, young or old, could become 
a news presenter on an important program,” he said.

Today, age for the intelligent woman is becoming an indicator of 
experience, wisdom, competence, as it is for the intelligent man, he said.

“I believe the changing roles of women will enhance the perception that 
competence is a value in both genders, that competence in news 
presentation — in a world beset with problems — is a great value and so 
perceptions of age will become more nuanced,” Wald said.

-- 
========================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to