http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/17/us-courts-voirdire-idUSTRE71G4
VW20110217

Feb 17 (Reuters Legal) - When picking a jury, lawyers always try to
stack the panel with people likely to take their side. Now, some are
taking the vetting process to a new level: they're quietly trawling
social networks and other sites to ferret out the most intimate details
of potential jurors' lives, from their sexual orientation to their
income level and politics.

In essence, the traditional question-and-answer session known as "voir
dire" is being transformed into "voir Google," sparking concerns about
privacy and about whether courts are adequately supervising the process.

Often hidden from judicial scrutiny and unknown to the jurors'
themselves, lawyers conduct extensive online searches about dozens of
members of a prospective pool and compile them into elaborate
spreadsheets. Some of this plays out in courtrooms in real time, as
lawyers and jury consultants, armed with laptops and smart-phones, seek
clues about whether a would-be juror would side with a homeowner in a
product-liability case, say, or with a cop in a police-brutality suit.

"Jurors are like icebergs -- only 10 percent of them is what you see in
court," said Dallas-based jury consultant Jason Bloom. "But you go
online and sometimes you can see the rest of the juror iceberg that's
below the water line."

In Columbia, Missouri, criminal-defense attorney Jennifer Bukowsky
builds Excel spreadsheets about prospective jurors using Facebook,
MySpace, Google Inc and a state database of civil and criminal actions
called Case.net. During a trial in Circuit Court for Boone County,
Missouri, late last year in which her client, a black male, was charged
with sexual assault, Bukowsky hoped to keep a white female juror on the
panel because the woman's Facebook page included several pictures of her
with a black man -- which Bukowsky took as a sign the woman was not
racist. "Internet research affected our decision with respect to whether
to keep or strike a juror," Bukowsky said. The prosecution struck the
woman from the jury pool, and the trial ended in a hung jury.

ERIN BROCKOVICH FAN

Trial consultant Jill Huntley Taylor said that during a
product-liability case last year in which her client was representing
the defendant, she discovered through online vetting that a juror had
posted on Facebook that one of her heroes was Erin Brockovich, the
crusading paralegal known for her work for plaintiffs in environmental
cases. Taylor, of Dispute Dynamics in Philadelphia, declined to disclose
more details about the case, but said her research helped attorneys in
the case decide to remove the juror from the panel.

The purpose of voir dire -- derived from an Anglo-Norman phrase meaning
"to speak the truth" -- is to help ensure a fair and impartial tribunal.
But the process has its limits. Jury questionnaires, which are typically
distributed to the lawyers in most jurisdictions at the onset of jury
selection, often contain only superficial information, such as name,
age, and marital status. Moreover, there are restrictions on the
questions attorneys can ask prospective jurors, reflecting in part a
growing concern within the courts over protecting jurors' privacy. Some
courts do not allow lawyers to ask about a prospective juror's political
affiliations, for example. Online vetting, therefore, can serve as a way
to bypass court-imposed restrictions on voir dire.

To be sure, lawyers, not to mention an entire industry of jury
consultants, have long tried to devise psychological profiles of jurors
in order to gain an edge -- using private investigators to scan public
records or to drive by jurors' homes to see how affluent they may be.
But in an era in which people are revealing their unvarnished selves on
Facebook and other sites, online vetting can serve as an invaluable
reality check on jurors who may not be completely forthcoming during
voir dire.

"THE WILD WEST"

While interviews suggest that Internet vetting of jurors is catching on
in courtrooms across the nation, lawyers are skittish about discussing
the practice, in part because court rules on the subject are murky or
nonexistent in most jurisdictions. Ten law firms and five jury
consultants declined requests from Reuters Legal to observe them
building juror profiles, many saying they weren't sure judges would
approve. "Lawyers don't know the rules yet," said John Nadolenco, a
partner at Mayer Brown in Los Angeles. "It's like the Wild West."

One law firm that was open about its online vetting of jurors is the
Wooten Law Firm in Auburn, Alabama. Earlier this month, plaintiffs'
lawyer Nick Wooten allowed Reuters Legal to watch as he and his team
combed through a roster of 280 citizens who comprise the jury pool for
two of Wooten's upcoming cases in Circuit Court in rural Chambers
County. One client is suing an insurance company that allegedly declined
to replace a roof damaged in a storm; the other is suing a gas company
over a gas log heating system that allegedly sparked a fire.

After the jury list was culled by eliminating former Wooten clients and
others who would be knocked out of the pool anyway, a paralegal began
assembling profiles based on each would-be juror's online persona. The
paralegal scanned Facebook, MySpace and Twitter, and used Google
searches to find jurors' names on the websites of government agencies,
school boards, local companies, and sites that contain property records.
Links to each site were assembled in a spreadsheet.

The online review quickly produced useful insights for Wooten to take to
voir dire. For example, the Facebook page of Juror 115 contained, in
Wooten's estimation, both positive indicators and red flags. Wooten was
pleased to discover that the 32-year-old white male is Facebook friends
with three people from Wooten's high school class and with one of his
clients. Also, the juror "likes" the Chambers County Sheriff's
Department; one of Wooten's grandfathers was a police officer in the
area. "We have a lot in common," Wooten said.

On the other hand, the online review found that the man is the owner of
two small businesses, his favorite book is the Bible, and his Facebook
account links to the websites of Republican politicians Newt Gingrich
and Sarah Palin. These indications that the man is conservative troubled
Wooten because it could mean he's inclined to consider lawsuits against
companies to be frivolous. "The information is at least enough to guide
my questions on what I have to pull out of this cat," Wooten said. "This
helps me make the ultimate decision: Can he stay on the jury or does he
have to go?"

"F*** MCDONALD'S!"

Lawyers for food company Conagra used online jury vetting to great
effect in a product-liability case last year. The plaintiff, Elaine
Khoury, claimed she contracted a rare lung disease from preparing and
consuming large amounts of microwave popcorn containing the chemical
diacetyl, which is made by Conagra Foods Inc. After the jury was sworn
in Circuit Court for Jackson County, Missouri, a ConAgra lawyer
discovered that one juror's Facebook page linked to numerous websites
that are highly critical of big corporations and to a petition to
boycott oil giant BP.

According to the transcript, the juror, 24-year-old University of
Missouri-Kansas City student Jonathan Piedimonte, also was found to have
a personal blog -- called "The Insane Citizen: Ramblings of a Political
Madman." The blog consists of poetry and short essays, and included
statements such as "F--- McDonald's. I hate your commercials. I'm not
'lovin' it.'"

ConAgra's lawyer Jerry Blackwell, a partner at Blackwell Burke in
Minneapolis, argued that Piedimonte should be removed from the jury
because he had hidden his antibusiness sentiments during jury selection,
and the judge agreed. "I'm going to err on the side of anybody that
stinks at all of prejudice is not going to sit on the damn jury," Judge
Jack Grate said, according to a transcript. In August, the jury ruled
nine-to-three in favor of Conagra.

Blackwell told Reuters Legal he believes that if Piedimonte had remained
on the jury, the outcome might have been different because Piedimonte
could have influenced other jurors. The plaintiff's attorney, Kenneth
McClain, said he plans to appeal, in part because he believes Piedimonte
should not have been removed once he was seated. Piedimonte, for his
part, said in an interview that while he understands why ConAgra's
lawyers viewed his online activities as evidence of bias, he doesn't
believe they should have been taken so seriously. "This is the
Internet," he said. "It's a different realm. It's like a playground."

LEVEL PLAYING FIELD?

The federal courts so far have not addressed the issue of online vetting
of jurors, and just two states, Missouri and New Jersey, have said it's
acceptable in some forms. But judges and lawyers, even in those states,
still seem to be grappling with the practice.

In May 2009, attorney Mitchell Makowicz represented Joseph Carino in a
medical malpractice lawsuit in New Jersey Superior Court against Dr.
Christopher Muenzen, alleging that the doctor's improper diagnosis of a
brain hemorrhage caused the death of Carino's wife. During jury
selection, Makowicz used his laptop in the courtroom to check out jurors
online.

A transcript reviewed by Reuters Legal shows Superior Court Judge David
Rand was surprised and annoyed by Makowicz's online research.

"Are you Googling these (prospective jurors)?" said Rand. "Your Honor,
there's no code law that says I'm not allowed to do that," responded
Makowicz.

"Is that what you're doing?" said Rand.

"I'm getting information on jurors. We've done it all the time, everyone
does it," said Makowicz. "No, no, here is the rule. The rule is it's my
courtroom and I control it," responded Rand.

Judge Rand then barred Makowicz from Googling jurors, citing the fact
that defense attorneys in the case had not brought their own laptops to
court. Makowicz's use of the Internet, the judge ruled, provided "an
inherent advantage regarding the jury selection process." The jury went
on to rule unanimously in favor of Dr. Muenzen, and the decision was
upheld by a state appellate court.

At the same time, though, the appellate judges held that the trial judge
had improperly prohibited Makowicz's online research. "The 'playing
field' was, in fact, already 'level,'" the court ruled, "because
Internet access was open to both counsel -- even if only one of them
chose to utilize it."

(Reporting by Brian Grow of Reuters Legal; Research assistance by Leah
Hauge of Westlaw; Editing by Eric Effron and Amy Stevens)
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to