WiMAX throttling lawsuit: Clearwire can't deliver the goods

By Jacqui Cheng
Ars Technica

March 10, 2011

http://arstechnica.com/telecom/news/2011/03/wimax-throttling-lawsuit-clearwire-cant-deliver-the-goods.ars


Wireless operator Clearwire has had a bumpy few months, and now things 
are getting worse. A lawsuit has been filed by 15 users over the 
company's throttling practices, accusing Clearwire of not delivering 
advertised "high-speed Internet" services to customers and charging them 
termination fees when they walk away unsatisfied. The group even says 
that Clearwire is engaging in a Ponzi scheme by selling service that it 
can't deliver in hopes of raking in enough money later to build out its 
network.

Customers began complaining in mid-2010 that Clearwire had begun to 
throttle their home Internet connections, sometimes as slow as 256Kbps. 
It wasn't clear (ba-dum ching) at the time as to what standard Clearwire 
was using in order to trigger the throttling—some users were told about 
monthly usage caps while others were simply told that there were certain 
times of day in which the network would be congested. Customers were 
frustrated at this lack of transparency, and complaints began piling up 
all over the Web.

In October, Clearwire finally began clarifying how and when it decides 
to throttle the network, with one spokesperson saying that Clearwire 
tries to relieve network congestion by throttling. He added that the 
carrier treats everyone equally and that it doesn't target specific 
applications, but it didn't offer details on the triggers or how long 
the throttling sessions last.

Clearwire's customers are now taking the carrier to task over its 
ambiguity. The complaint, filed earlier this month, focuses heavily on 
Clearwire's advertising, which not only highlights the speed of the 
connection ("all but two of Clearwire's plans propose a minimum Internet 
speed of 1.0Mbps"), but also the fact that there are no limits on data 
usage.

"Usage is unlimited—believe it. You can upload, download, and surf as 
much as you want for one low price with any of the CLEAR Internet plans. 
We don't slow down your connection—the way some Internet providers do—if 
we think you are using too much bandwidth," the complaint quotes from 
Clearwire's website. (That text appears to have been removed at the time 
of publication).

The complaint goes on to theorize why Clearwire would purposely mislead 
its customers, and the conclusion is that it wanted to grow its network 
"in the face of well-publicized financial pressure." (Clearwire revealed 
in November of last year that it will likely run out of cash by 
mid-2011.) "Thus, rather than limiting its subscribers to a number that 
its broadband infrastructure can accommodate—such that Clearwire can 
make good on its representations regarding high-speed service and 
capacity—Clearwire signed up many more subscribers than it could handle 
so as to maximize revenue and profit," allege the Plaintiffs.

That's where the supposed Ponzi scheme comes in. The Plaintiffs accuse 
Clearwire of selling subscriptions it can't support in hopes of building 
out its network sometime in the future to "make good on its promises." 
(That's not exactly the traditional definition of a Ponzi scheme, as 
each customer would have to be considered an investor who recruits other 
investors to pay into the scheme, but we get the point.) As a result, 
Clearwire is accused of violating advertising and fair trade practices 
in six separate states with possibly more on the way, as the Plaintiffs 
are looking to get the suit elevated to class-action status.

The whole drama gives us flashbacks to the Comcast throttling debacle, 
which itself generated a class-action suit that was eventually settled 
for $16 million. The difference, however, is that Comcast was found to 
be specifically targeting Bittorrent when it began throttling back 
customers' connections, whereas Clearwire maintains that it is content- 
and application-neutral.

That's largely within the FCC's latest net neutrality rules, though 
Clearwire has done a poor job of transparency. By comparison, Verizon 
also began throttling its wireless data connections this year, but made 
a point of offering specific details on the kinds of users and content 
that it targets, as well as what it does to "optimize" content flowing 
through its network. Verizon users have not been thrilled about the 
change, but the uproar has been kept to a minimum in part due to 
Verizon's being proactive in informing customers.


_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to