Report: Piracy a "global pricing problem" with only one solution

By Nate Anderson
Ars Technica

March 14, 20011

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/03/report-piracy-a-global-pricing-problem-with-only-one-solution.ars


A major new report from a consortium of academic researchers concludes 
that media piracy can't be stopped through “three strikes” Internet 
disconnections, Web censorship, more police powers, higher statutory 
damages, or tougher criminal penalties. That's because the piracy of 
movies, music, video games, and software is “better described as a 
global pricing problem.” And the only way to solve it is by changing the 
price.

Over the last three years, 35 researchers contributed to the Media 
Piracy Project, released last week by the Social Science Research 
Council. Their mission was to examine media piracy in emerging 
economies, which account for most of the world's population, and to find 
out just how and why piracy operates in places like Russia, Mexico, and 
India.

Their conclusion is not that citizens of such piratical societies are 
somehow morally deficient or opposed to paying for content. Instead, 
they write that “high prices for media goods, low incomes, and cheap 
digital technologies are the main ingredients of global media piracy. If 
piracy is ubiquitous in most parts of the world, it is because these 
conditions are ubiquitous.”

When legitimate CDs, DVDs, and computer software are five to ten times 
higher (relative to local incomes) than they are in the US and Europe, 
simply ratcheting up copyright enforcement won't do enough to fix the 
problem. In the view of the report's authors, the only real solution is 
the creation of local companies that “actively compete on price and 
services for local customers” as they sell movies, music, and more.

Some markets have local firms that compete on price to offer legitimate 
content (think the US, which has companies like Hulu, Netflix, Apple, 
and Microsoft that compete to offer legal video content). But the 
authors conclude that, in most of the world, legitimate copyrighted 
goods are only distributed by huge multinational corporations whose 
dominant goals are not to service a large part of local markets but to 
“protect the pricing structure in the high-income countries that 
generate most of their profits.”

This might increase profits globally, but it has led to disaster in many 
developing economies, where piracy may run north of 90 percent. Given 
access to cheap digital tools, but charged terrific amounts of money for 
legitimate versions of content, users choose piracy.

In Russia, for instance, researchers noted that legal versions of the 
film The Dark Knight went for $15. That price, akin to what a US buyer 
would pay, might sound reasonable until you realize that Russians make 
less money in a year than US workers. As a percentage of their wages, 
that $15 price is actually equivalent to a US consumer dropping $75 on 
the film. Pirate versions can be had for one-third the price.

Simple crackdowns on pirate behavior won't work in the absence of 
pricing and other reforms, say the report's authors (who also note that 
even "developed" economies routinely pirate TV shows and movies that are 
not made legally available to them for days, weeks, or months after they 
originally appear elsewhere).

Indeed, the authors have seen "little evidence—and indeed few 
claims—that enforcement efforts to date have had any effect whatsoever 
on the overall supply of pirated goods. Our work suggests, rather, that 
piracy has grown dramatically by most measures in the past decade.”

The "strong moralization of the debate” makes it difficult to discuss 
issues beyond enforcement, however, and the authors slam the content 
companies for lacking any credible "endgame" to their constant requests 
for more civil and police powers in the War on Piracy.

Joe Karaganis, who writes the report's opening chapter, "Rethinking 
Piracy," concludes his section with an endorsement of the idea that 
piracy is a “signal of unmet consumer demand.” Many content companies 
and trade organizations have started to embrace this view, but turning a 
ship this large takes years.

In the meantime, says Karaganis:

Our studies raise concerns that it may be a long time before such 
accommodations to reality reach the international policy arena. Hardline 
enforcement positions may be futile at stemming the tide of piracy, but 
the United States bears few of the costs of such efforts, and US 
companies reap most of the modest benefits. This is a recipe for 
continued US pressure on developing countries, very possibly long after 
media business models in the United States and other high-income 
countries have changed.

Footnote: The study itself uses an interesting "Consumer’s Dilemma" 
license, which charges $8 for the report to residents of high-income 
countries and offers it free for noncommercial use to everyone else 
(including Canada, which is not "high income." Who knew?)

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to