March 23, 2011

Portable, but Not Puny, Speakers
By DAVID POGUE
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/24/technology/personaltech/24pogue.html?_r=1&src=dayp&pagewanted=print


You could argue about what makes a gadget delightful: Simplicity, sleek 
looks or cool materials. But one element doesn’t get nearly enough 
press: magic.

You know it when you see it. Some feature does your bidding in a 
miraculous, baffling way. The remote control. The microwave oven. 
Magnifying a photo by spreading two fingers on a multitouch screen.

Well, there’s a new bit of magic in town: wireless portable speakers.

Show me a portable gadget these days that can play music — iPhone, 
Android phone, tablet, laptop, whatever — and I’ll show you its feeble, 
pathetic built-in speakers. If you want better sound, you could put on 
the earbuds — or get a portable wireless speaker.

These machines range in size from boom boxes to coat-pocketable slabs, 
and in price from $60 to $200. They connect to your phone, tablet or 
laptop wirelessly using Bluetooth, which has a 30-foot range.

Therefore, they set free the music that was previously trapped on your 
phone. You can listen to a playlist as you get dinner ready. You can 
listen to an NPR podcast as you drive — even if your car has no iPod 
inputs. You can enjoy Pandora Internet radio as you move from room to 
room. Thanks to the batteries in these speakers — in most cases, 
eight-hour rechargeables — you can have a day of music on the beach, in 
the woods or anywhere else there’s no place to plug in.

The only setup step (a one-time action) is to pair your phone or laptop 
with the speaker — that is, to introduce one to the other, just as you 
would with one of those Bluetooth earpieces.

You start by putting the speaker in pairing mode. In olden times, this 
was a baffling procedure, in which you pressed goofy button combinations 
on both gadgets simultaneously. On most of the speakers these days, the 
process is far easier.

On the Jawbone Jambox , you press the power switch upward for three 
seconds — and you hear an actual human voice, coming from the speaker, 
say, “Jambox is in pairing mode, waiting for device to connect.” 
Bringing up the rear is the Logitech Z515, which requires you to press 
both the Volume Up and Volume Down buttons on the back panel — for 10 
seconds. Hey, Logitech — you can do better than that.

Once the speaker is ready to pair, you open your Settings or Control 
Panel app on your phone, tablet or laptop. There, on the Bluetooth 
panel, you tap the speaker’s name. Now the music playback from the 
phone, tablet or laptop comes out of the wireless speaker across the room.

It’s a startling effect, for three reasons. First, there’s the 
remote-control aspect: your phone, tablet or Touch becomes a touch 
screen for your portable stereo.

Second, there’s the ventriloquism thing: it’s just freakish to hear the 
music coming from a speaker across the room. And third, if you’re used 
to the tinny bleats of a built-in speaker, the power and richness of the 
sound is a grabber.

(It’s also a startling moment when you forget that you’ve set up things 
this way, and, later in the day, you suddenly hear the sound from your 
phone emerging from another room.)

The features and the sound quality vary widely. Here are six examples, 
from small to smallest. (Bose also makes a Bluetooth wireless speaker, 
but it declined to participate in this review.)

ALTEC-LANSING INMOTION AIR ($200). This speaker resembles a stylish, 
slightly twisted rectangle. It’s expensive, but worth every penny. It’s 
the only Bluetooth speaker with sound quality even remotely resembling a 
proper stereo system, with rich bass, supercrisp highs and solid 
midrange. You could fill a party room with good sound.

As with all of these units, you can also use it as a wired speaker (and 
get better fidelity) by connecting to the miniplug input. But it’s more 
magical to carry it someplace unwired, maybe outdoors, and letting the 
music flow.

It comes with a USB Bluetooth transmitter, in case your lame laptop 
doesn’t have built-in Bluetooth, and a remote control.

CREATIVE LABS D100 ($70). This shoebox-size speaker comes with a choice 
of brightly colored cloth grilles. There’s not much to its design and it 
feels cheap. But it sounds maybe 75 percent as good as the 
Altec-Lansing, at only 35 percent of the price. Four AA batteries power 
it for up to 25 hours.

LOGITECH Z515 ($80). Most of the speakers in this review aim to be 
either bookshelf speakers (like the two above) or pocket speakers (like 
the two below) — but at 13.8 by 3.3 by 5.4 inches, the Logitech sits 
right in between.

The amount of sound this thing pumps out is astonishing for its size; it 
gets really, really loud. The sound just isn’t that good. That’s great 
for background party music — not so great for actively listening. It 
comes with a case and a USB audio for your laptop that tucks into the 
speaker’s back panel for storage.

IHOME IDM12 ($60). Here’s another one whose primary virtues are big 
volume and low price. It’s tiny and plasticky, and the sound isn’t very 
good, but it does pump out the sound. The cover attaches to the front 
magnetically; when you pull it off, it becomes, of all things, an iPad 
stand.

SOUNDMATTERS FOXL V2 ($200). This fascinating, coat-pocketable metal 
speaker oozes quality, and both the audio quality and the power are 
eyebrow-raising for something this small.

It’s plenty of sound to fill the room if you’re doing homework, cooking 
or taking a bath (or all three at once). But party conversation would 
drown it out. It is equipped with a USB cable, miniplug audio cable, 
travel pouch and antislip acoustic mat (which prevents the thing from 
jiggling itself right off a shelf).

JAWBONE JAMBOX ($200). The Jambox is by far the most interesting 
specimen. It’s an upgraded, redesigned version of the Soundmatters 
speaker, so it has pretty much the same audio qualities and wonderful 
pocketable size (6 by 2.2 by 1.6 inches). The design is radical: it’s a 
heavy, solid rectangle, rubber on top and bottom, stainless steel grille 
all the way around the rest. The whole thing is one color: blue, red, 
gray or black.

And it talks to you. A voice guides you through pairing and can announce 
the remaining battery level, for example.

Like the Soundmatters speaker inside, the Jambox is also a speakerphone. 
When a call comes in, your music fades gracefully, a voice announces the 
incoming number, and you tap the round button on top. This is not, alas, 
the Jambox’s shining moment; callers complained that they couldn’t hear 
me well.

The Jambox can also run what Jawbone generously calls apps — the same 
ones available for its stylish Bluetooth earpieces. For example, you can 
choose a different voice for the Jambox’s spoken utterances, or assign a 
speed-dial number to the top button, or activate your iPhone’s 
voice-dialing feature.

The company has big plans for future features, which you install from 
your computer over the speaker’s USB cable.

As you know from watching “The Sorcerer’s Apprentice” (or “Wizards of 
Waverly Place,” for that matter), magic sometimes has a way of going 
wrong; there are some caveats with these speakers. For example, they 
should be fantastic for watching movies on your laptop; for the first 
time, the audio would actually be decent.

Unfortunately, audio transmission by Bluetooth often introduces a small 
delay, making the soundtrack slightly out of sync with the video.

Don’t expect a lot of stereo separation, either; the right and left 
speakers are only a couple of inches apart.

Otherwise, though, these wireless speakers may become one of your 
favorite accessories — especially the Altec-Lansing (if you’re looking 
for boombox size) or the Jambox (pocket size).

These are the most expensive ones, but also by far the most refined and 
best-sounding. And getting that much high-quality sound in such tiny, 
wireless packages — well, that’s quite a trick.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to