Phone, Web Clampdowns in Crises Are Intolerable

By Susan Crawford
Bloomberg Businessweek

September 25, 2011, 8:23 PM EDT

http://www.businessweek.com/news/2011-09-25/phone-web-clampdowns-in-crises-are-intolerable-susan-crawford.html


Sept. 26 (Bloomberg) -- Can U.S. citizens count on using the Internet 
and cell-phone networks to communicate in high-stress situations? The 
Federal Communications Commission is about to examine that question. 
Public interest and the law both require that channels stay open.

At issue is the termination of cell-phone service by San Francisco’s Bay 
Area Rapid Transit system on Aug. 11. It acted to thwart a protest about 
a shooting of a passenger by BART police. A host of consumer advocates 
and digital civil-rights groups have filed an emergency petition, asking 
the FCC to step in.

As far as anyone knows, no government agency in the U.S. had cut off 
general-purpose communications before BART took this step. The question 
before the FCC is whether BART’s action violated the Telecommunications 
Act of 1996, which prohibits discontinuing or impairing service without 
due process.

It is essential that the FCC quickly find BART’s conduct wrong. 
Otherwise, Americans will be in the same situation as Egyptians were 
when former President Hosni Mubarak ordered the squelching of cell-phone 
service in Tahrir Square.

As the advocates’ petition makes clear, U.S. courts have consistently 
ruled against shutting communications services, on the grounds that no 
official has the authority to squelch phone service based only on the 
suspicion of illegal activity.

Suspicion Isn’t Enough

When Earl Warren was California’s attorney general in 1942, he wanted 
the phone company to cut off service to a man suspected of involvement 
with illegal gambling. A California court ruled that disconnection was 
unjustified, saying that a telephone company had no right to refuse 
access to its facilities because of a mere belief that the wires would 
be used for illegal purposes.

The same logic prompted a 1955 Alabama court to rule that Birmingham’s 
public safety commissioner, Eugene “Bull” Connor, couldn’t order the 
phone company to halt service based on mere suspicion. “The 
unconstitutional and extra- judicial enlargement of coercive 
governmental power is a frightening and cancerous growth on our body 
politic,” the court said.

BART had even less cause for its action than Earl Warren or Bull Connor. 
It assumed that people might use cell-phone service in a way that could 
cause discomfort to other passengers. A spokesman for BART, Linton 
Johnson, even suggested that a constitutional right to safety justified 
its decision and trumped any right to speak across public networks.

Travelers’ Safety

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has pointed out that 10 years ago, 
when BART enabled cell-phone access, the airplane hijackings and 
terrorist acts of Sept. 11, 2001, had shown that travelers would be 
safer if they could communicate. Passengers aboard United Airlines 
Flight 93, from Newark to San Francisco, found out via telephone calls 
that the World Trade Center and the Pentagon had been attacked and then 
voted to rush the hijackers. Workers at the World Trade Center were able 
to use phones to let their families know they had survived.

The deep connection between San Francisco and the doomed flight made 
BART’s decision to wire its tunnels a popular one. BART, by blocking all 
cell-phone service last month, forgot its own rationale.

BART’s overreaction to the risk of a protest against police brutality 
triggered a fierce, rapid response from First Amendment scholars, 
communications experts and the media. Meanwhile, protesters mounted even 
more protests.

The FCC’s decision to investigate was accompanied by a cautious 
statement from spokesman Neil Grace. He said the commission was 
gathering information “about the important issues [BART’s] actions 
raised, including protecting public safety and ensuring the availability 
of communications networks.”

If the FCC slow-rolls this one, or accepts BART’s decision and sides 
with those who believe that phone service is a convenience that can be 
banned for any reason, other local officials will undoubtedly adopt 
BART’s tactics. Such a response would undercut the American tradition of 
open communications across public, general- purpose networks.

This petition is about more than avoiding bothersome texting; it deals 
with the future of the digital age in America. Government officials 
around the world have found it very easy to cut off communications when 
times are tense.

Arab Blockages

Mubarak’s sudden decision to block Internet and cell- phone service in 
January is the best-known example. Libya throttled Internet access “to 
the point of uselessness” a couple of months later. Syria cut off access 
in June.

When riots erupted in the U.K. last month, Prime Minister David Cameron 
considered banning people from using Facebook and Twitter. He told 
Parliament he was looking at “whether it would be right to stop people 
communicating via these websites and services when we know they are 
plotting violence, disorder and criminality.” He backed down following a 
public uproar.

It is tempting to avoid disruptions by using the totalitarian tactic of 
silencing speech. When basic Internet connectivity is controlled by so 
few hands, as is true around the world, such decisions can be executed 
with extraordinary ease. Mubarak probably needed to make just seven 
phone calls to cut his country off from the Internet.

The FCC’s examination of the BART fiasco is a positive step. Now the 
commission needs to act quickly and decisively, making clear that local 
law-enforcement officials lack the authority to suspend basic 
communications services.

As the United Nations said in June, the Internet is “an indispensable 
tool for realizing a range of human rights, combating inequality, and 
accelerating development and human progress.” The consequences of 
getting this one wrong are unbearable.

-------------------
Susan Crawford is a Bloomberg View columnist and a professor of law at 
Cardozo School of Law. The opinions expressed are her own.


_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to