Supreme Court: No royalties with Internet music downloads
Songwriters appealed ruling, say tens of millions of dollars at stake

Reuters

updated 10/3/2011 3:29:49 PM ET

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/44761240/ns/technology_and_science-tech_and_gadgets/#.Topd0WGYGH0


The Supreme Court let stand on Monday a ruling that a traditional 
Internet download of sound recording does not constitute a public 
performance of the recorded musical work under federal copyright law.

The justices refused to review a ruling by an appeals court in New York 
that the download itself of a musical work does not fall within the 
law's definition of a public performance of that work.

The not-for-profit American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers 
(ASCAP) appealed to the Supreme Court. It said the ruling has profound 
implications for the nation's music industry, costing its members tens 
of millions of dollars in potential royalties each year.

ASCAP says more than 390,000 composers, songwriters, lyricists and music 
publishers in the United States exclusively license their music through 
the organization. It licenses nearly half of all of the musical works 
played online, according to the court record in the case.

The federal government opposed the appeal. U.S. Solicitor General Donald 
Verrilli said the appeals court's ruling was correct and comported with 
common understanding and sound copyright policy.

ASCAP argued that digital downloads were also public performances for 
which the copyright owners must be compensated. But a federal judge and 
the appeals court rejected that argument.

At issue was a section of the Copyright Act stating that to perform a 
work means to recite, render, play, dance or act it either directly or 
by means of any device or process.

"Music is neither recited, rendered, nor played when a recording 
(electronic or otherwise) is simply delivered to a potential listener," 
the appeals court ruled.

Verrilli agreed. He said that the downloading itself was not a 
performance of the work and the musical work was not played during the 
transfer.

Washington attorney Theodore Olson, a Bush administration solicitor 
general, represented ASCAP in the appeal.

He said the appeals court ruling improperly narrowed the right to 
perform copyrighted musical works publicly and placed the United States 
in violation of intellectual property treaties and other international 
agreements.

The Supreme Court denied the appeal without comment.

The appeals court also ruled that fees paid by Yahoo Inc and 
RealNetworks Inc for licenses to play music on the Internet should be 
recalculated. That part of the ruling was not at issue before the 
Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court case is ASCAP v. United States, No. 10-1337.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to