[Nice photo of the small pub that fought
the good fight. Note the satellite dish on the 2nd floor red
brick.]
Pub landlady wins landmark court ruling to show Premier League
footie on the cheap
Scottish Daily Record
Oct 4, 2011
PUB landlady Karen Murphy has won her legal battle at the
European Court of Justice against the Premier League over the
screening of games in her pub using a "foreign" television
decoder.
The Premier League could be forced into a major change to how
they sell their lucrative television rights following the landmark
European ruling going against them.
Portsmouth pub landlady Murphy was prosecuted for using a Greek
satellite decoder to show live matches at 3pm on Saturdays.
She appealed, arguing that she should have the right to access
any service in the European Union, and in February the ECJ's
advocate general Juliane Kokott issued an opinion backing Murphy's
position.
Today's confirmation of that decision may mean selling sports TV
broadcast rights on an exclusive territory-by-territory basis
within the EU may no longer be possible.
Kokott stated: "The exclusivity agreement relating to
transmission of football matches are contrary to European Union
law.
"[The] exclusivity rights in question have the effect of
partitioning the internal market into quite separate national
markets, something which constitutes a serious impairment of the
freedom to provide services."
Premier League chiefs had already anticipated that the ruling
would go against them to some extent. But insiders insisted this
does not necessarily mean a drop in television income from
mainland Europe, which is around £130million, or less than 10% of
their total £1.4billion overseas rights deal.
One option will be for the Premier League to sell their domestic
rights and European rights as one giant package, and another to
have their own Premier League subscription TV channel available
across Europe.
The implications of the ruling could not just affect the Premier
League but every sport that sells broadcast rights on a
country-by-country basis.
It is also how UEFA, for example, sell the rights for the
Champions League. It could also affect the sale of TV programmes
generally across Europe.
The ECJ also ruled that only the opening video sequence, the
Premier League anthem, and pre-recorded clips showing highlights
of recent Premier League matches and various graphics could be
protected by copyright.
"By contrast, the matches themselves are not works enjoying such
protection," says the ruling.
Pubs would have to obtain permission to broadcast those opening
sequences, said the ruling, but not the match itself.
The ECJ ruling has been criticised by Tory MP Damian Collins, a
member of the culture, media and sport select committee.
Collins said: "I think that there should be some Parliamentary
scrutiny of this ruling and consideration of its wider
implications for copyright, sports rights and the money that goes
from those rights back into sport.
"It also seems to be ridiculous that the Premier League anthem is
copyright protected but not the match footage. This is another
unwelcome intervention in our national life from the ECJ."
But Brigid Simmonds, chief executive of the British Beer &
Pub Association, welcomed the news saying: "At last, the end is
now in sight to years of uncertainty surrounding this issue.
"The UK authorities should now very quickly clarify the position
in UK law so pubs know exactly where they stand.
"Perhaps now football will become more affordable for pubs, as
live sport is a key ingredient of a great pub for millions of
customers.
"The underlying driver of the problem has been the big price
hikes that Sky have levied, with a 20% rise last year alone."
A European Commission spokesman also welcomed the verdict, saying
the judges had backed the Commission's arguments during the court
hearing.
"The court follows the Commission's belief that EU citizens
should have the right to use pay-TV subscriptions across borders."
North of the border, SFA chief executive Stewart Regan admitted
today's ruling was a "big issue for football".
Via Twitter he said: "If broadcasters cannot protect markets and
outlaw decoder cards then payments to governing bodies are at
risk."