Are the Media Turning Sour on Apple's New iPad?

By Phillip Swanni
TVPredictions.com

http://www.tvpredictions.com/backlash031812.htm


Washington, D.C. (March 18, 2012) -- During the week leading up to 
Friday's initial sale of the new Apple iPad, the tech media was nearly 
unanimous in its praise of the new tablet. Reviewers called it 
everything from dazzling to revolutionary.

But over the last few days, a media backlash seems to be brewing, even 
within the newsrooms of the nation's leading tech journalism sites. Some 
reporters are questioning whether the power of the Apple brand has cast 
a spell on an uninformed populace, sending it out to buy something it 
may not really want or need.

For instance, the tech site Gizmodo.com published an article Friday 
detailing how it bamboozled staffers at the celebrity site, Gawker.com, 
into thinking that an iPad 2 was actually the new iPad. A Gizmodo 
staffer passed out a copy of the iPad 2 to unsuspecting Gawkers, telling 
them it was the new tablet.

Calling it the "power of the placebo effect," Gizmodo writes how several 
Gawker staffers gushed over the iPad 2, saying it was "incredible," 
"amazing," and "awesome." Not one staffer correctly noted that the iPad 
2 was actually an iPad 2.

While some Gawker staffers did offer a few cautionary notes -- "It's not 
quite like my Kindle;" "It's not as sharp as my phone." -- most gave the 
"new iPad" glowing reviews.

Writing about the stunt, PC Magazine also chimed in with its own 
skepticism regarding whether the average person truly knows if the new 
iPad is an upgrade over the iPad 2. (And, yes, it is better, by all 
technical measures; the retina, high-res screen is a dramatic 
improvement, etc. etc.)

"They can be told that Apple' new iPad is better than its predecessor 
but, as Gizmodo's experiment shows, it's not as if they have a 
real-world bearing for what a "Retina Display" or "faster processor" 
actually means. At some point, a device meets a person's internal 
threshold of what's "fast," or "good-looking." And unless this person is 
holding two products side-by-side, he or she is seemingly going to enjoy 
an experience with an older, similar-looking device just as much as a 
newer one.," PC Magazine wrote.

Now let's cut over to CNET.com where the granddaddy of tech web sites 
has been overflowing with superlatives about the new iPad. Until yesterday.

Under a headline that reads, "Some people don't have a clue as to why 
they need the new iPad," CNET editor-at-large Brooke Crothers describes 
his visits to two Southern California-area Apple stores on Friday.

"What I witnessed was, while not shocking, pretty fascinating," Crothers 
writes.

The CNET journalist recounts how several shoppers seemed confused over 
how the new iPad was better than the iPad 2.

"One numbingly consistent (as in "here we go again") query to Apple 
staff by prospective buyers--and I'll paraphrase--was: "Hey, I really 
don't see any difference between this new iPad and my iPad 2. Can you 
show me what's different?" Crothers stated.

Crothers added that after Apple employees recited the number of ways the 
new iPad is better, the customers "squinted at text, flipped through 
photos, and scrolled up and down Web sites. And the refrain became 
predictable. 'Hey, I still really can't see any difference.' "

But then Crothers was surprised by something.

"But wait," he writes. "They bought the thing anyway! I witnessed one 
guy whip out $900 in cash (all twenties) after asking cursory (and very 
untechie) questions about the screen. Others were not quite as impulsive 
but were close."

His conclusion: "This confirms my Apple Shiny Slab Theory. In short, 
certain buyers will, zombie-like, march to the Apple store and part with 
their cash. Yeah, they have vague ideas about new cool tech, but it's 
all very vague."

Now it should be noted here that most journalists are still in lock-step 
with the Apple marketing message that the new iPad represents a 
tremendous achievement. And it seems unlikely at this point that some 
good-natured cynicism in the newsroom will dampen sales.

But this mini-media backlash bears watching. If it grows, and consumers 
start to question the validity of buying the new iPad, then Apple may 
have a problem on its hands.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to