[It's time to recycle those tinfoil hats. Or use them to wrap sandwiches.]

June 11, 2012

Debunking Rumors of an Internet Takeover
By ERIC PFANNER
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/11/technology/debunking-rumors-of-an-internet-takeover.html


PARIS — This just in from Geneva: The United Nations has no plans to 
seize control of the Internet. The Web-snatching black helicopters have 
not left the hangar.

Internet conspiracy theorists will be disappointed. The latest one, 
fueled by “open Internet” groups, Internet companies like Google and 
some U.S. lawmakers, was that mouse-clicking bureaucrats at U.N. 
headquarters in Geneva, supported by governments suspicious of the 
United States, were scheming to take over the Internet itself.

The plot went something like this: At a meeting in December of an 
obscure U.N. agency called the International Telecommunication Union, 
Russia, China and their ilk would try to wrest oversight of the Internet 
away from the loose collection of public and private organizations that 
do the job now, handing this responsibility to the I.T.U. All sorts of 
bad things, from censorship to the breakup of the Internet, would ensue.

By last month these fears had grown so fevered that U.S. lawmakers 
introduced a resolution calling on the government to block proposals 
that “would justify under international law increased government control 
over the Internet and would reject the current multistakeholder model 
that has enabled the Internet to flourish.”

Vinton G. Cerf, the “chief Internet evangelist” at Google, warned during 
congressional hearings: “The open Internet has never been at higher risk 
than it is now. A new international battle is brewing — a battle that 
will determine the future of the Internet.”

The alarmist talk gave rise to wire service and blog headlines like 
“U.N. takeover of the Internet must be stopped, U.S. warned” and “U.S. 
reiterates resistance to I.T.U.-U.N. Internet land grab.”

Time for a reality check. Documents prepared for the December meeting, 
which leaked out last week — yes, on the Internet — show that there are 
no proposals to hand governance of the Net to the I.T.U. The union 
insists that it has no desire to play such a role. And even if some 
governments would like to give the agency increased regulatory powers, 
the United States and other like-minded countries could easily block them.

“It would be wrong, and a bit silly, to talk about the I.T.U. ‘taking 
over’ the Internet,” Milton L. Mueller, a Syracuse University professor 
who is the author of “Ruling the Root: Internet Governance and the 
Taming of Cyberspace,” wrote in a blog post. “It is, rather, the 
Internet that is taking over the world of telecommunications, setting 
more and more of the terms and conditions under which the I.T.U. and its 
operating entities function.”

Campaigners for an open Internet say this does not mean there are no 
grounds for concern as the December meeting, called the World Conference 
on International Telecommunications, draws near. The meeting was 
convened by the I.T.U., whose members include more than 190 countries 
and hundreds of telecommunications and technology companies, to update 
an international telecommunications treaty that deals with technical 
matters like how to connect cross-border calls.

“While I don’t think this represents a U.N. takeover of the Internet in 
the way you may have read in the blogosphere, some of the proposals go 
to the heart of how information travels on the Internet,” said Sally 
Shipman Wentworth, senior manager of public policy at the Internet 
Society. “Even small wording changes could have a considerable impact.”

The existing pact dates to 1988, when the Internet was in its infancy 
and telecommunications, in many countries, was still the preserve of 
government-controlled monopolies. The draft being prepared for the 
meeting, set to take place in Dubai, includes several Internet-related 
provisions, including measures to counter spam and bolster cybersecurity.

But the draft includes no proposals to change the Internet’s core 
governance functions, which are handled by groups like the Internet 
Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, the Internet Engineering 
Task Force and the World Wide Web Consortium. Icann, for example, 
oversees the domain name system while the later groups develop and 
maintain technical standards.

“It’s unfortunate that the Congress is spending so much valuable time on 
something that isn’t even on the table,” said Hamadoun Touré, secretary 
general of the I.T.U. “There is no single reference to Internet 
governance in the preparation document.”

That is not to say that some governments would not like to change the 
way the Internet is governed. China, Russia and some developing 
countries chafe at what they see as U.S. control over the Net, pointing 
to the fact that Icann operates under a mandate from the U.S. Commerce 
Department.

Icann has irked governments around the world, including Washington, with 
moves to expand the range of Internet addresses available. It recently 
created a new “top level domain” for pornography, using an .xxx suffix. 
This week the organization is set to disclose the applicants for 
hundreds of new domain extensions. The project greatly increases the 
range of addresses on offer, but critics say it could lead to trademark 
violations.

Last year, Vladimir V. Putin, then the prime minister and now the 
president of Russia, fueled fears of a power grab when he said during a 
meeting with Mr. Touré that his goal was to establish “international 
control over the Internet, using the monitoring and supervisory 
capabilities of the International Telecommunication Union.”

Dozens of governments have submitted proposals for the new treaty. For 
the most part, they have not released these to the public, a lack of 
transparency that has fueled fears about what might be discussed in 
December. Some of the proposed regulations, as outlined in the draft 
treaty, are indeed alarming to Internet freedom groups. One proposal 
would give governments the right to control the routing of international 
telecommunications traffic that originates within their borders. Critics 
say this could facilitate censorship by repressive regimes, even though 
existing I.T.U. rules, endorsed by the United States, already permit 
censorship.

In any case, analysts say it is extremely unlikely that the 
administration of President Barack Obama, which has repeatedly pledged a 
commitment to an open Internet, would endorse a treaty that permitted a 
crackdown on Internet communications or an expansion of the U.N.’s 
governance role.

“The majority of I.T.U. members agree with us in this regard,” Philip L. 
Verveer, coordinator for international communications and information 
policy at the State Department, said in Congressional testimony. “There 
are no pending proposals to vest the I.T.U. with direct Internet 
governance authority.”

What is really at stake, some analysts say, is money.

Robert M. McDowell, a member of the Federal Communications Commission, 
told a U.S. House committee last month that he was aware of treaty 
proposals that could enable foreign telecommunications companies to levy 
fees on Google, Facebook, Netflix and other U.S. Internet companies that 
are heavy users of bandwidth. This would be “devastating to global 
economic activity,” he said.

The European Telecommunications Network Operators’ Association, a 
lobbying group based in Brussels, has called for the treaty to permit 
the management of telecommunications traffic. Internet companies 
generally oppose this idea, calling instead for “network neutrality” — 
the idea that all traffic, from simple voice calls to bandwidth-heavy 
video, should be given equal priority.

The treaty “should acknowledge the challenges of the new Internet 
economy and the principles that fair compensation is received for 
carried traffic and operators’ revenues should not be disconnected from 
the investment needs caused by rapid Internet traffic growth,” the 
operators’ association said in a submission to the I.T.U.

Thus the real conflict is not over governance of the Internet, some 
analysts say, but over the division of the spoils, with international 
telecommunications operators trying to use the I.T.U. to extract revenue 
from American Internet companies.

“It’s very clever of open Internet people to play this as a U.N. 
takeover attempt,” wrote Mr. Mueller, who has done contract work for the 
I.T.U. and a variety of telecommunications companies and Internet 
organizations. “Maybe the whole thing would be better framed as a 
retrograde attack on liberalization in international telecommunications.”

_______________________________________________

Please be sure to include a URL to the article. Reply to the sender with a 
"Thank you" if you like this post.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to