June 10, 2012

Radio Royalty Deal Offers Hope for Industrywide Pact
By BEN SISARIO
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/11/business/media/radio-royalty-deal-offers-hope-for-industrywide-pact.html


For decades, the recording industry has lobbied Congress to change how 
radio stations pay royalties. The broadcasters have lobbied just as hard 
to preserve the status quo, making an agreement look all but impossible.

But last week, a groundbreaking deal by Clear Channel Communications, 
the country’s largest radio broadcaster, raised the possibility of a 
solution to the standoff through marketplace negotiations instead of 
political head-butting. It also put the spotlight on how federal 
copyright law keeps up with digital media.

The agreement, between Clear Channel and Big Machine, the record label 
behind Taylor Swift and other country acts, will for the first time 
allow a label to collect a royalty when its songs are played on the radio.

In the United States — and almost nowhere else — radio companies pay 
only songwriters and music publishers, not record companies. The system, 
dating back almost a century, is based on the idea that radio play has 
enough promotional value for performers that they do not also need to be 
paid royalties.

The arrangement has long irritated labels and performers; Frank Sinatra 
was a vocal opponent. But with record sales plummeting over the last 
decade, the labels have pursued royalties more urgently as an additional 
revenue stream.

“Terrestrial broadcasters have an inexplicable ‘free ride’ when it comes 
to performance royalties,” Ben Allison, a jazz musician and the governor 
of the New York chapter of the National Academy of Recording Arts and 
Sciences, the organization that produces the Grammys, told a House 
subcommittee last Wednesday at a hearing with music and technology 
executives called “The Future of Audio.”

“They are exempt from paying performers any royalties when they use our 
recordings to fuel their multibillion-dollar industry,” Mr. Allison 
continued. “This makes corporate radio the only business in America that 
can legally use another’s intellectual property without permission or 
compensation.”

So why did Clear Channel change its position, breaking ranks with its 
powerful lobbying group, the National Association of Broadcasters?

The answer apparently has nothing to do with politics; with Republicans 
expected to retain control of the House in this year’s elections, few in 
the industry predict a new Washington battle is likely. Rather, it has 
to do with digital music, and Clear Channel’s desire to reshape its 
business in anticipation of rapid changes in the marketplace.

When the first webcasting laws were passed in the 1990s, labels and 
artists gained the right to performance royalties for online streams. 
But webcasters have long complained about the size and structure of 
these royalties, which are set by federal statute. The more people 
listen, the more the companies have to pay — unlike on radio, where 
stations pay a set percentage of revenue to music publishers. Pandora 
Media pays more than half its revenue in music royalties.

For Clear Channel, digital royalties are a looming problem. Today, 98 
percent of listening to its stations is through its 850 terrestrial 
radio stations, and 2 percent is online, the company said. But that is 
expected to change, which would leave Clear Channel and other 
broadcasters exposed to expanding royalty payments. To limit those 
expenses, Clear Channel struck its deal with Big Machine, bypassing the 
federal “penny rate” for a share of advertising revenue, both online and 
over the air.

As various forms of digital music proliferate, the distribution of 
royalties has become a crucial issue throughout the industry, with 
efforts to reach new agreements, expand existing systems or bypass those 
systems entirely.

Last week, SoundExchange, a nonprofit group in the United States that 
processes online royalties, made five deals, bringing the number of 
foreign countries from which it collects royalties to 22. Yet Sirius XM 
Radio recently has sought ways to avoid SoundExchange through direct 
licensing agreements with record labels, an effort that has proved 
contentious.

For Clear Channel, the Big Machine deal is likely to be a money loser in 
the short run, because it will be paying the label far more for 
terrestrial radio play than it will save online. But if the deal takes 
hold, it could save Clear Channel a great deal of money in the long run 
and change the economics — and politics — of radio.

The Clear Channel deal came up several times at the Congressional 
hearing on Wednesday, and was often characterized as a positive sign 
that the marketplace could solve a problem that high-powered lobbying 
had been unable to settle again and again.

“We’re obviously delighted that the biggest radio group acknowledged 
that something should be done,” said Cary Sherman, the chairman of the 
Recording Industry Association of America.

Media executives used the hearing to air some of their familiar concerns 
and requests, including the need for the government to be tough on 
piracy and the broadcasters’ wish to have radio chips placed in mobile 
phones.

Tim Westergren, the founder of Pandora, called for lower rates for 
streaming services and for equivalent royalty systems across media, 
because Pandora must pay labels millions of dollars in royalties that 
broadcast radio companies are not required to pay.

“It is time for Congress to level the playing field and to approach 
radio royalties in a technology-neutral manner,” Mr. Westergren said. 
“The current rate-setting law is unfair to performing artists, unfair to 
record labels, and unfair to Pandora and Internet radio as we compete 
every day with broadcast radio and satellite radio for listener loyalty 
and advertising and subscription revenue.”

Few companies have the negotiating leverage of Clear Channel to change 
an entrenched royalty system. But its Big Machine agreement at least 
suggests that changes can be made in the industry.

_______________________________________________

Please be sure to include a URL to the article. Reply to the sender with a 
"Thank you" if you like this post.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to