South Carolina passes bill against municipal broadband
Broadband policy analysts decry pressure from AT&T and a conservative group.

by Cyrus Farivar
Ars Technica

June 29 2012, 7:00am MDT




South Carolina has become the latest state in the union to pass a
state-level bill that effectively makes it difficult, if not impossible,
for municipalities to create their own publicly owned Internet service
provider that could compete with private corporations. The bill passed the
South Carolina General Assembly and Senate on Wednesday and awaits the
signature of the state’s governor.

"It’s not an absolute ban, but it makes it pretty tough," Matt Wood, policy
director at Free Press, a digital advocacy group, told Ars on Thursday.

Oddly, the bill also defines broadband as being "not less than one hundred
ninety kilobits per second," which is pretty laughable by any measure.
Municipal broadband watchers like Phillip Dampier also say that the bill’s
passage shows the effective lobbying of AT&T, the state’s largest telco,
who has contributed thousands of dollars in campaign contributions.


Lobbying from AT&T and conservative policy groups

Dampier and others also allege that the bill was crafted by the American
Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a conservative think-tank that lobbies
local, state, and federal representatives to push for bills and craft ideal
draft legislation that are conducive to its values. On its website, ALEC
says that cities should not be allowed to create broadband utilities in
competition with private corporations.

"If municipalities are inclined to pursue broadband initiatives then
certain safeguards must be put in place in order to ensure that private
providers, with whom the municipality will compete with, are not
disadvantaged by the municipality in the exercise of its bonding and taxing
authority, management of rights of way, assessment of fees or taxes, or in
any other way," the organization writes.

Public records show that in 2011, AT&T, itself an ALEC member, contributed
$1,000 to the coffers of Michael Gambrell, South Carolina assembly member
and lead author on the bill. Other sponsors of the bill, including Bill
Sandifer, Bobby Harrell, and many of its supporters, also received
donations from AT&T as well. Gambrell, Sandifer, and Harrell did not
respond immediately to Ars’ request for comment.

AT&T has said previously that it has invested more than $125 million in the
first half of 2011 to expand mobile and mobile broadband services across
the state.

"The South Carolina bill is the typical reactionary knee-jerk response from
the late telecom companies who can only compete by eliminating any hint of
competition, rather than compete by offering a better product or service,"
wrote Craig Settles, a broadband industry analyst, in an e-mail to Ars on
Thursday. "Unfortunately, as long as they wield truckloads of money and
state legislators are willing to suck up that money, consumers and local
businesses will have to continue fighting."
Many states face similar pressure

Other industry watchers note that similar battles are being fought in other
regions of the United States.

"States have different ways to achieve the same end—discourage, delay, or
derail public broadband initiatives," wrote Jim Baller, a telecom lawyer
based in Washington, DC, in an e-mail to Ars on Thursday. He noted that
similar bills were introduced in Minnesota and Georgia this year, the
former of which has led to a "study bill," while the latter did not make it
out of committee.

"In some ways, the South Carolina bill is worst of all because it does not
grandfather existing projects and would retroactively undermine federal
stimulus grants that Orangeburg and Oconee Counties have received,"  he
added.

Matt Wood, policy director at Free Press, added that similar battles would
likely continue for some time to come.

"The companies have literally armies of lobbyists in every state and are
able to protect their incumbent position," he told Ars.



Editor's Pick: Promoted Reader Comment

    Workaround | Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
    jump to post
    cdclndc wrote:
    Yeah, municipal broadband sucks. We did it here in Chattanooga without
taxpayer dollars. Now we have gigabit speeds available, cost of broadband
has gone down now that Comcast has competition, Our once monopolistic
overlord actually upgraded their equipment and service (we still have
choices). Amazon opened up a distribution center providing much needed
jobs. Volkswagen opened up a manufacturing plant adding even more jobs. IT
companies are flourishing here, construction is up so people not in IT
fields are getting jobs, the economy has improved overall. Can you believe
that crap?[ /sarcasm]


    I hate you Chattanooga people. Every time I read an article about how
shitty US broadband is, there's some guy from Chattanooga gloating.
_______________________________________________

Please be sure to include a URL to the article. Reply to the sender with a 
"Thank you" if you like this post.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to